Jackie in pink

"Jackie is in pink. She thinks I'd never guess that, but it's secretly her favorite color."

Josie laughs and Jackie scowls "How do you know that!"

You think back and recall Josie telling you once, but you don't want to rat you out. Then another memory hits

"We were playing in a co-ed tournament last year and we were sitting on the bench together. You said you liked the pink jerseys they made the girls wear to keep them straight on the ice because it was your favorite color."

"Ugh...can't believe I let that slip."

"Well, she's yours now!" Josie says playfully and she pushes her into your arms.

Jackie asks "What's my punishment I suppose?"

What should it be? You won after all. Could you ask for a threesome with Josie or the redhead, or even a four-way? Would they agree, or would that just make Jackie mad? The other two are already talking out of earshot looking around at other boys. Maybe you prefer a night alone with Jackie anyways?