It's complicated

"I dare you," said Susie, heavily breathing, "to fuck me!"

I smiled and started to move forward but sudden thought stopped me. "I dare you, Susie, to make sure you won't get pregnant. I don't have a condoms at this moment."

"I'm not on a pill but just do it! Take it out or whatever."

"It's too risky," said I licking her pussy again and applying a decent amount on saliva on it. "You're so hot that I might not be able to do it."

"And what to do? I want you in me!" insisted she.

"Well..." grinned I, using my thumb to move saliva from her vagina to other hole and rubbing it, "there is a very reliable way."

"What way?" started to ask she, "Oh, no way! Not there! Make other dare!"

This idea was taking over me. "Well, you you want it so much and your dare was "fuck me", then I dare you to let me do it in your ass!"

"No! I don't want that! That's wrong!"

"More wrong then what we are doing now?"

"But I've never done that!"

"Wouldn't you want me to be your first?" asked I.

"It will hurt!" protested Susie, but I've noticed the spark in your eyes.

"I'll be very gentle." said I, pushing my thumb a bit deeper. "I'll be as gentle as I would be with a virgin, because the virgin you are."