Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by SomethingLewd SomethingLewd

What's next?

It's a Threesome

Ethan, Penny, and Alice returned to Ethan's room, the atmosphere heavy in anticipation of the discussion. They hung their coats up, Alice and Penny making their way across the room and sitting down next to each other on the couch while Ethan remained standing.

Ethan took a deep breath, ready to start the conversation. "I think we've put this off long enough. We need to talk about what's been happening between us. We’ve all spoken to each other alone, but now’s the time to do it as a group. Lay out all of the cards."

Penny and Alice nodded in agreement, their eyes fixed on Ethan.

"I feel like we're all in agreement, but we still need to say it to each other," Ethan continued. "I'll go first."

He paused for a moment, gathering his thoughts. "My class... it felt like it had ruined things at first. That because of it our plans to form a team were ruined. Even despite the sex, I felt like it was too much, too fast. I worried that we were just forcing ourselves to accept the conditions of my class through sheer stubbornness. That because we’ve planned for so long to form a team that we’d be willing to adhere to my classes’ requirements, but that we were doing so reluctantly.” Ethan paused to take a breath. “But this morning, when I overheard you two talking, I realized that wasn’t the case. When Alice and I spoke earlier, that confirmed it. I realized that I needed to stop worrying and instead embrace what was happening."

Penny looked surprised at Ethan revealing he had heard her and Alice speaking that morning, but listened intently.

"I overheard your conversation," Ethan admitted. "And the kiss.”

Alice turned to Penny next to her on the couch. “He’s not upset with us.”

“I’m not.” Ethan continued. “I’ve told Alice this already, but when I heard you both talking about how you felt for each other and the kiss, all I could do was smile. I felt so damned lucky to have the both of you. Even saying it doesn’t feel like enough, like I don’t have the words to convey how happy I am for all of us.”

Penny stood up and wrapped Ethan in a hug. “I’m sorry I didn’t tell you.” She murmured.

Ethan returned the hug. “There’s nothing to apologize for.”

“I think we need to know that going forward things between the team are between everyone.” He released Penny and she sat back down. “Things are going to happen between us, either one on one or as a group, and I don’t think any of this will work if we all feel like we’re running around behind each other’s backs.”

Penny and Alice both nodded as Alice spoke up. “I’m worried about how that’s going to work when we add two more to our team. The three of us have a relationship that someone like Mei isn’t going to be able to copy. We’ve been close for years now and she’ll be stepping into our team as an outsider.”

Alice paused as she looked at both of them before continuing. “It’s not like we can pretend that the three of us aren’t going to be closer and that Mei is going to be on equal footing. So much of this is going to come down to what Mei wants. I think what we’re talking about here is a relationship between the three of us.”

“We’re going to have to let Mei tell us what she wants.” Penny said, looking at Ethan. “We made it clear that sex is part of your class, but the way that plays out can look different depending on what Mei Wants. If it turns into something clinical where we do the bare minimum to generate essence, that's going to be completely different from if she decides she’s okay with joining us. Or maybe she just wants to be one on one with Ethan? We can’t really know.”

“Would either of you be okay with that? If Mei wanted to be alone with me?” Ethan questioned them. “I think that would feel like I was cheating on you.”

Penny’s brows furrowed as she thought about Ethan’s question. “I think you’re right.. There would be some of those feelings. I think this is a good time for me to confess some things. I’ve been doing some soul searching of my own about all of this and it’s only fair to both of you if I share.”

Ethan walked over to the couch and the girls moved over on the small love seat to make room for him. As he sat down, he pulled Penny over to sit sideways on his lap, her legs resting on top of Alice. The three of them sat there getting comfortable as Penny worked out what she wanted to say.

Penny took a deep breath before speaking. "I've been surprising myself with my own actions lately. I was afraid that I was pushing you both too far, too quickly. But hearing what you’ve said here makes me feel relieved that I haven’t."

She looked down at her hands, her voice soft. "The idea of group sex has always been a turn-on for me. The instigating and pushing I've done so far is a massive part of the fantasy for me. I think I enjoy being the devil on your shoulder telling you to just give in and enjoy yourself.”

She looked up as she felt Alice start to run fingers up and down her legs. "Last night felt amazing, and I don't want to let that go. But I'm concerned about bringing in Mei. It feels like bringing in a 'third wheel,' considering how tight our relationship is."

Ethan reached out, taking her hand in his. "We'll figure it out together."

Alice nodded in agreement, her voice supportive. "We're in this together, Penny. Whatever happens."

Penny smiled softly at them nodding as they reassured her.

Alice squeezed Penny’s leg as she spoke. "Ethan and I discussed where all of this leads earlier today. We both agreed that we're okay with it."

Penny looked surprised but unsure, her eyes widening. "What does that mean?"

Alice nodded, a small smile playing on her lips. "I put it a bit differently earlier, but we spoke about where this all leads. We agree that what’s happening feels different, but in a good way. That nothing we’ve done so far has been wrong and the idea of doing more, going further, is exciting." Alice laughed again, shifting herself to face towards the other two on the couch, sitting on one leg folded beneath her. “And I’m speaking for myself on this one, but I like instigator Penny. I said it this morning already, but the way you led us on last night was hot.”

Penny laughed with Alice, a sly smile on her face. “Then maybe you should prove it to me.”

Alice cocked her head sideways at Penny’s request.

Ethan took a deep breath, his voice steady as he spoke. "Alice, kiss Penny." They both look at Ethan in surprise before turning to look back at each other.

Penny leaned forward as Alice leaned in, her lips meeting Penny's in a soft kiss. The kiss deepened as Alice became more aggressive, rising up on her knees to push Penny to lay back across Ethan's lap and the armrest of the couch. Alice followed Penny down, their bodies pressing together as they lay across Ethan.

Ethan's hands began to wander, one hand running up Alice's back and lifting her shirt up, feeling the softness of her skin under his fingertips. The other hand caught in Penny’s hair, cradling her head while the two women kissed atop him. The kiss between the two women broke, and Alice leaned sideways away from Ethan so she could look at him. Both women's hair was tousled, their cheeks flushed with desire.

Ethan took a more dominant tone, his voice firm as he commanded, "Both of you, get up."

Penny and Alice stood in front of him, wondering what he wanted next. Ethan made it obvious as his eyes moved up and down their bodies, taking in every detail. "Undress each other for me," he ordered.

The women were surprised by the more dominant Ethan but complied eagerly. Penny moved quickly to listen to Ethan's command, her hands reaching for Alice's shirt. The two women decided to give Ethan a bit of a strip show, sensually undressing each other while weaving in kisses and letting their hands wander over each other's bodies. Alice moaned loudly as Penny lifted her shirt over her head, using the opportunity to tangle Alice’s hands and block her sight. Penny leaned down and began to tease Alice’s breasts with her tongue. First one and then the other, Penny’s tongue flittered back and forth over Alice’s nipples.

As the girls put on a show for him, Ethan felt himself through his pants, not hiding the fact that he was stroking himself through the material. The sight of them stripping each other and teasing was enough to make Ethan completely hard. The women could see the outline of his hard cock as he stroked himself, and it excited them even more.

Alice, with only her bra and panties on, turned the still dressed Penny to face Ethan. She moved behind Penny, wrapping her hands around Penny’s waistband. Alice pressed her fingers into Penny’s pussy through the material of her leggings, forcing Penny to lean back against Alice. Penny let out a loud moan, her head going back as she enjoyed the feeling of Alice pressing up against her. Alice brought her hands up either side of Penny’s stomach, bringing her shirt with her. Alice pulled Penny’s shirt off and swept her hair to the side before leaning down and kissing Penny’s bare shoulder and neck, eliciting another moan from Penny.

Grabbing a handful of Penny’s hair, her other hand on Penny’s waist, Alice pulled Penny’s ass against herself as she **** Penny to bend forward. She pulled back on the hair, causing Penny to look up as she bent forward at the waist, her mouth falling open as she was **** to look right at Ethan as he stroked his cock through his pants.

“Hey bra next.” Ethan commanded. Alice obeyed, letting go of Penny’s hair and unclasping her bra. It fell off her to the floor, her breasts now hanging free. Alice wasted no time, grabbing Penny’s leggings and panties together and pulling them down. Penny kicked her feet out from them and stood fully naked for them both. Alice moved in to kiss Penny and Penny took the opportunity to undo Alice’s bra. She unclasped it and pulled it away, sliding the straps down her arms while they maintained this kiss, dropping it to the floor. Alice pulled them together, their breasts pressing up together as they kissed.

Ethan stood up then, too impatient to wait any longer, the sight in front of him too much to stay a spectator for long. “Undress me.” He commanded both of them. They both turned to him, enjoying the more dominant and confident Ethan.

The women worked together to remove his clothes, taking turns kissing the revealed skin as the other removed an article of clothing. First unbuttoning his shirt, next the zipper on his pants. Alice pushed his pants down and as Penny knelt to finally remove Ethan's boxers, his cock bounced free, completely hard.

Penny wasted no time, moving to give Ethan a blowjob. She licked up his entire length from the base before taking him into her mouth. Ethan groaned as he pulled Alice against him, his hand sliding down the back of her panties to hold her there. They met each other's eyes for a moment before they began to kiss deeply. Ethan had one hand on Penny's head as she sucked on his cock, encouraging her, while his other hand cupped Alice’s tight ass.

Ethan laughed as Alice copied him, her hand finding its way to his ass, squeezing it tightly. "Still an ass woman, I see," he teased, referencing their earlier conversation.

Her eyes full of mischief, Alice grinned at him. "Always."

Ethan pulled Penny up to kiss her, and then the two women kissed while Ethan held them both close. He guided them to the bed, pushing Penny down firmly onto her back where she bounced slightly, her breasts jiggling with the movement. He turned to Alice, spinning her to face away from him. He grabbed her panties and swiftly pulled them down, dropping them to her feet. He gave her a quick spank, causing her to laugh. He pressed himself against her back, his cock pressing against the small of her back where she could feel the heat of it against her skin. Ethan kissed her neck, his hands running up from her bare thighs to her breasts as he pressed himself against her. She let out a soft coo as Ethan nibbled on her ears before he began guiding Alice to the bed and to the waiting Penny.

They positioned themselves on either side of Penny, looking down at her while Penny met their eyes. Penny reached up to pinch her own nipple in a teasing challenge to them both. Ethan kneeled on the bed next to her and began to lick and kiss all over Penny's body. Alice followed suit, joining him as both of them began lavishing attention on Penny. Penny moaned and squirmed under their touch, her back arching up as they touched every inch of her.

Ethan moved between Penny's legs, a trail of kisses down her stomach leading him there. “Spread your legs.” He commanded, a hand on each of her knees pushing her legs apart. He bent down and began to eat out Penny's pussy, raising her legs up to spread them for easier access. First he gave her quick licks along the outside of her lips before he gave up on teasing her and began to flick his tongue up and down her clit. Alice silenced Penny’s moans from Ethan’s touch with a kiss before moving down to continue kissing down Penny’s body. Alice lightly pinched Penny’s nipple as she brought her mouth to Penny’s other breast. Both Alice and Ethan could feel the essence as if it were washing over them as Penny got closer and closer to the edge. It wasn’t long before Penny began to tense, experiencing a mind-blowing orgasm that left her dazed.

Ethan and Alice looked at each other, proud at the pleasure they had brought to Penny. They came together for a kiss over the top of Penny as she lay there, panting and recovering. Alice was surprised for a moment at the taste of Penny on Ethan's lips before leaning in harder to the kiss, the taste turning her on at how dirty it felt.

Penny came back to them, recovering from her orgasm. She looked up at Alice with an aggressive glint in her eyes. She pushed herself up and grabbed Alice, almost manhandling her to swap places and lay her down between herself and Ethan. Penny began to give Alice the same treatment she had received. Penny started on Alice’s breasts, sucking one nipple into her mouth. The sensation of the essence being built up between Penny sucking on her nipple and Ethan’s hands roaming across her hit hard her hard. Penny’s hand trailed down Alice’s stomach while she kissed her way up to her ear, whispering to Alice. “I’ve wanted to do this for so long.” As she spoke, she pressed her fingers against Alice’s sex and Alice let out a gasp that melted into a moan. Penny’s fingers pressed into her, first a single finger, quickly followed by a second.

Penny moved down the bed, never taking her hand away from Alice. Ethan took her place, beginning to play with and suck on Alice’s breasts.

Alice was turned on as she looked down her body and saw Penny kneeling there between her legs, looking up at her while she kissed her way down Alice's thigh closer and closer to her pussy. Maintaining eye contact, Penny pulled her fingers out of Alice. Penny brought her fingers to her mouth, sucking them, letting Alice watch as Penny tasted her. Penny moved to lean forward, starting to kiss her way down Alice’s thigh towards her pussy. Alice cried out as she felt lips make contact with her clit, the combined attention from Ethan and Penny driving her wild. Alice was loud as the two focused on her, moaning out their names as she squirmed under their combined attention.

Alice came hard. Her body shook in reaction to the intensity of the essence as she orgasmed. The tremors of the after effects went on and on, both Ethan and Penny continuing to touch and pleasure Alice while she came down from her orgasm. They continued the soft touches as Alice recovered her breath, easing her down.

The process repeated again with Ethan taking his turn to be the one being the center of attention. Penny and Alice whispered to each other and laughed as Ethan lay on his back between them, his hard cock pointing upwards. “What’s so funny?” He asked, raising an eyebrow. Penny shushed him and moved again to begin giving Ethan a blowjob as Alice began with kissing Ethan, nibbling on his ears, and slowly kissing over his chest and neck.

“You’ll find out soon enough," Alice said. “Now close your eyes.”

He brought a hand up to cover his eyes, feeling them both moving around the bed. "No peeking!" Penny reminded him.

Ethan listened, confused as he felt them begin to touch him again. It wasn't long before he realized that what he was feeling as a second tongue joined the first, both of the women licking on his cock at the same time. He uncovered his eyes and lifted his head up to look down at them. As he did so, he made eye contact with Alice while she was in the middle of running her tongue from the base of his cock to the tip. The sight of her licking his cock nearly drove him to release, he felt it throbbing at the sight.

Alice pulled away and put a hand on the back of Penny’s head, grabbing a handful of hair. She used her hold to guide Penny down onto Ethan's cock. Alice began to use Penny’s mouth to fuck Ethan, guiding her up and down Ethan’s cock. Alice led Penny into a rhythm that quickly drove Ethan wild, the sight of what was happening to him one of the hottest things he’d ever seen. Alice pulled Penny off of his cock and kissed her before taking her place, taking as much of Ethan's cock as she could into her mouth. Alice was nearly able to take Ethan’s entire cock before she felt him hit the back of her throat. She pressed her tongue against the bottom of his cock as she brought her head up until only the tip of his cock was in her mouth.

Alice again looked up and made eye contact with Ethan. As the siblings maintained eye contact, she began to flick her tongue over the underside of his cock. She focused on teasing that soft and sensitive spot just under the head of his cock, her tongue never stopping and she sucked on his head.

He looked down and the sight drove Ethan to warn them that he was getting close. When Penny took his balls into her hands and began to play with them it was too much for him. Ethan came, the first shot going directly into Alice’s mouth. She pulled off his cock and he shot string after string of cum, shooting more than he had ever done before. Penny laughed and aimed Ethan's cock between Alice and herself, forcing Ethan to cover both of their faces with cum.

Alice and Penny began to kiss each other, cleaning the cum off of each other's faces. The night ended with the three of them entangled in a mess of limbs and laughter, crowded into the small bed together.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)