It's... Something, But Possession Could... Be Fine?

Chapter by Hellexia

"Babe?" You began, gulping as Cari locked eyes with you. "If uh... I..."

"Yeah?" Cari interrupted, raising an eyebrow. "What's up? You've got a weird look on your face, what's-"

"If you possess one of my family, we're not... doing anything, are we?" You asked, gulping as you finally got that thought out. "Y-You know?"

"I mean... I'd be okay with it." Cari said with a shrug, her cheeks reddening slightly. "Maybe that's just the Carrie part of me though..." Cari muttered, a guilty smile forming on her face. "Oooh, okay, the more I think about it-"

"Jesus, Cari! No, they're-"

"You're telling me that you NEVER clicked on those videos? The sister getting stuck in the clothes dryer or-"

"That's different!" You shouted, wincing as the ring inside your hand seemed to heat up suddenly. Unsurprisingly, Cari noticed, gently grabbing your hand as a worried expression flashed across her face. "I'm fine, the ring-"

"Nick... Emi's theory, remember?" Cari asked, her eyes locked onto your ring finger. "How the ring is... altering reality or something along those lines? Making Henri a girl and Luna and Ava obsessed with you and all that? All retroactively?"

"Yeah. Why?" You asked, gulping as Cari bit her lip. "W-Why?"

"My... I..." Cari mumbled, shaking her head with a sigh. "My head's... very foggy about something all of a sudden..." She trailed off, furrowing her brow as she looked up into your eyes. "I can't be sure, but... I think the ring just did it again."

"What do you mean? Cari, what-"

"Juniper and Ashley are your stepsisters. Your mother is your stepmother." Cari said softly, caressing the back of your hand. Urged on by the face you were probably making, Cari continued. "I remember it, like-like I've always known it! Luna and Ava snooped around and found..." Cari paused, gulping. "...Nick, just after Ashley was born, your father married her mother. And-And, it wasn't out of wedlock or something, I swear that-"

"That can't be true. I mean, I'd know. Right?"

"N-No. Your parents kept it... I mean, are keeping it a secret from you and your sisters." Cari muttered, squeezing your hand tight as she leaned in close. "I don't think it was true. Until subconsciously, you wanted to..." She paused, blushing. "...You know. But you didn't want to with your sisters, so... the ring changed that. Kinda."

"Cari, you... I don't want you to take this the wrong way, but... Carrie and Emily are smart. Luna and Ava... pull B's, right?" You asked, waiting for Cari to nod before continuing. "Honestly, you're smarter than me. By a longshot."

"Mmmhmm."

"You could at least deny it a bit, babe..." You sighed, smiling a bit as Cari blushed and kissed your bruised neck. "Look, I trust you. But... I need to know. Is this actually the truth, or are you just saying this because you've got some kink? With Carrie a part of you, I just-"

"I'm dead serious. Although..." Cari paused, loudly exhaling as she fidgeting beside you. "It's not just Carrie, you know... WAIT!" She loudly exclaimed, glaring at you all of a sudden. "YOU DIDN'T MENTION HENRI! A C AVERAGE IS NOTHING-"

"C average with cheating off of me."

"You..." Cari grumbled, albeit behind a smile, as she snuggled back in beside you. "Nick?"

"Mmm?"

"When you head home... if you really wanna have my possess someone, I... I'll go with whoever is the least awkward for you." Cari whispered, wrapping her arm around your waist...

Suggestions:

•One Of Your Sisters Will Be The Least Awkward...

•Your Mom, Maybe? It's... Definitely A Choice

•On Second Thought, Possession Isn't Great.