Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 7 by MegaMarshmallow MegaMarshmallow

What's next?

Is A Girl Cock Best Served Anally

Jennifer had had three showers and she could still feel it. The hot cum oozing out from her pussy. Strangely she did not feel gross or dirty from those feelings. Scared of being knocked up? Yes. Violated and used? Yes. But if anything she felt aroused by it. Much to her embarrassment and frustration. As she lay there in her fluffy pink bathrobe on her bed, legs kicking in the air and clutching her phone, waiting for it to ring, she could not help feeling flushed from those thoughts.

"Come on, Woody…" Jennifer whined as she fidgeted with her phone. "How hard is it to kick someone's ass and get my shit back?" She bit her bottom lip. What if Woody failed to get the toy back? She had not paid a lot of attention to the safety information provided with it nor the end-user licensing agreement from when she first set it up, but she definitely remembered having to sign a hefty waiver around ownership of her holes before she bought it.

"Fianally," Jennifer exclaimed as her phone rang and Woody's contact popped up. "Did you get it?" There was silence on the other end of the line. "Wooooody? Tell me you did get it."

"I'm sorry Babe…"

"You fucking useless bastard!" Jennifer screamed as she squeezed her phone tightly. "Why the fuck did you not get it back? It's a simple fucking task… can't you do anything, right? First football and now this? You're a fucking joke, you know that right? A real fuck-up. A failure!" She could audibly hear Woody cringing and flinching on the other end of the phone as she yelled at him, but she was so worked up that she did not care about the vile she was spitting at him. "Can't you do anything for me…"

"Babe… you don't understand…"

"I don't understand? Do you fucking understand?" She yelled at him down the phone. "There's some degenerate creep who has unfiltered fucking access to my holes. They can fuck my mouth, my pussy and even my bloody ass whenever they want. Hell, they can share them with others… do… nasty fucking shit to them. Stick more than just their fat stupid dick in me. Do you know what that feels like? To know that at any moment they could use me like that? You have no fucking idea what it is like to be at their whims and feel so… **** to them. A complete bloody stranger who can use me anytime, anywhere. It's humiliating, degrading, shameful!"

Jennifer paused, she was flushed and burning up, from her forehead to her chest. Her breathing was coming rapidly and she felt her little nipples stiff, poking at her robe down against the bed, as she still lay on her stomach. Rage, fear and frustration mixed with arousal, shame and a deep seeded thrill. She remembered that night last year… with the football team… she banished those thoughts from her head.

She did not know if she was more angry or turned on right now and that further annoyed her. Why was her body responding this way? She heard Woody let out a strange noise on the other end of the phone. It sounded like a whimper or a sniffle. Oh no… maybe she had been too harsh.

On the other end of the phone, halfway across the country, laying on his bed, Woody covered his mouth after letting out that groan. He shifted around awkwardly on his back as he felt himself pitching a tent in his pants. He was racked with sympathy for Jennifer and what she was going through.

Guilt over what he had just done with Kim less than an hour ago. Anxiety over Jennifer finding out about that or what someone might do to her with that toy in their hands. Frustration at being unable to have found the toy and gotten it back. But most of all, shame over how aroused hearing her talk about the matter made him feel.

"Are you okay Woody?" Jennifer asked and he jolted in his bed like a startled dog before biting his bottom lip. Did she know? "Listen… I'm sorry I said that… I shouldn't have brought up the football thing… I'm just… really scared right now and I hoped you would be able to fix things like you always do. I wish you were here with me…"

"I'm sorry Baby," Woody said, his heart racing in his chest as his fear gave way to a feeling of love but the guilt lingered in the shadows, ready to plunge a knife through his back and right into his heart. "The package didn't get delivered there or if it was, it was stolen."

"How do you know that?" Jennifer said, as she felt a frog in her throat at the thought of the toy being out there in the wild.

"Kim told me so."

"Kim?"

"The woman who lives there now," Woody explained. "She reckons it either got delivered somewhere else, was stolen from one of our doorsteps or lost in the mail… perhaps stolen from there."

"You told her about this?" Jennifer exclaimed, mortified at the very idea of even some woman she had never even met being told about her situation.

"I had to tell her some of what was happening, Babe. To make her understand. I barged into her apartment like I was there to kill her or something… she was terrified… I'm lucky she did not call the police and we could work this out… I was a real fucking asshole to her… a thug."

"You really barged into some strange woman's apartment just for me?"

"Yeah Babe, course I did. After what you told me about what that creep did to you…" Woody said, biting back a moan at that particular thought. "... I was ready to break their legs… maybe worse."

"Awwwwww Baby… that's strangely sweet," Jennifer said, unable to keep from smiling. "I weirdly love that you would go full thug for me."

"Yeah… well… I was very ashamed afterwards and sorry. Kim's a sweet girl. I'm so glad she was understanding about our situation. She was really sorry for me… and you." Woody quickly added on that last part, as memories of Kim and their short time together clouded his mind. He could still feel her soft feet wrapped around his glistening dick, her honied words spoken to him, her orders and commands. The shape of her pale breasts burned into his mind. Those thick rosy nipples. He was rock hard now.

"I'm glad too. Maybe next time you go all thug for me… make sure you have the right person, okay?" Jennifer asked with a sigh. "I don't know what to do now though…"

"You could call the police," Woody suggested.

"I really don't want this to become… a thing. What if it has to go to court or some shit? I don't want to be embarrassed like that."

"Then maybe… try contacting the mail service? They have a whole department for missing packages and if it's stolen… well I can't imagine it's the first package that has ever been taken. I think they would have a way of dealing with that."

"That's… not a bad idea, actually. I'll call them first thing in the morning. You know, maybe it's not true what they say. Blondes aren't all dumb."

"Ha ha ha," Woody said, rolling his eyes but grinning ear to ear nonetheless.

"I'm serious. You're not as big of a himbo as you look, Mister. There's some brains in there after… oh hell no!"

"Jenny? Babe? Love? You okay?"

"Yeah… no… I mean… no," She said as she wiggled around on the bed. "A portal just opened up. The creep is at it again."

"Where did it open? Your mouth? Pussy?" Woody asked as he felt his softening dick go back to full hardness.

"No… no… it's my ass! The bastard has my ass!" Jennifer scrambled off the bed, almost dropping her phone, as she threw off the robe and turned to look in the mirror. She had to spread her big, thick cheeks to see it but there was just a twinge of pink between them, no bigger than the base of a butt plug. She tried to poke at it but like the one that appeared across her mouth before, it was solid and impenetrable.

"Jenny! Jenny! Babe! What's going on?" Woody's voice yelled from her phone.

"I don't know… nothing yet," Jennifer answered as she picked the phone back up from the edge of her bed. "Just a portal opened between my… ass cheeks… nothing has come through… yet."

Woody sucked in air through his teeth. He could feel his cock straining hard in his pants. Painfully erect already. It was almost worse than when Kim had been rubbing it through his pants. He shifted on his bed and pulled them down along with his boxers. Just to give his cock some room to breathe, he thought, not for any other reason. "Listen Babe… it's going to be okay. I'm here. Whatever happenes… I'm right here."

"I'm scared," Jennifer lied. Her heart was racing, body shaking, knees weak but not just out of fear. She was incredibly turned on as she stood there, naked and alone in her room at the sorority house, with her boyfriend on the phone and some stranger with direct access to her untouched asshole.

Back across the country, minutes ago, only a floor down from Woody, Kim lay atop her own bed. She was frustrated. Both sexually after toying with and making Woody cum but also still angry and bitter towards Jennifer. It was worsened by the fact earlier today she had forgiven her former childhood bully. Only for Kim to learn that the greatest present, the massive olive branch between them, had been little more than a mistake.

She was so furious and resentful at Jennifer fucking Wilson. Even after fucking her bullies throat, pussy and then her boyfriend behind her back. Kim felt rage that she had thought was well behind her. Stuff she had put in the past, years ago when she finished high school and moved as far away from Jennifer as she could. She wanted to punish her for everything she had ever done to her. Years of her life ruined…

Fortunately, she had just the tool in hand to do that. The Multi-Portal Pleasure Unit X-3000 from Deviant Desires. A sex toy that could open a portal straight to any of Jennifer's holes. Her stupid, fat mouth, that wet fucking cunt or her tight, virgin asshole. Kim looked at the dial as she considered her options. She had already tried the first two, and they were more than pleasurable, but she wanted to hurt Jennifer tonight, so there was one easy option for that.

Kim watched as a portal opened, and on the end of her sex toy, appeared a butthole. The skin was dark and winklely around the puckered hole. She looked at it with amazement. This was Jennifer fucking Wilson's asshole. A spot untouched by neither her boyfriend nor anyone else that came before him or since. Even the football team that Kim had recently learned ran a train on Jennifer had not touched her ass.

She brought it close to her face to see clearly. It looked so delicate and pristine. Kim wanted to destroy it. She breathed out heavily and watched as it twitched when her hot breath hit it. Fuck… she was still hard from playing with Woody and this only turned her on more.

Annoyingly, she had left her lube out in the living room. She really did not feel like getting up to retrieve it but she was not mean enough to go in without it… even for someone she hated as much as Jennifer.

Instead she tried something different. She hit that button from before. The one that had sprayed that weird cold stuff into Jennifer's mouth. Kim had a theory… and it paid off immediately as she watched clear lubricant appear around and within Junnifer's asshole as it clenched down tight. Kim reached out with a finger and softly pressed on the hole. Feeling it give, very reluctantly, but her finger sinking in nonetheless. It was very slippery and well lubricated.

Jennifer jumped as she felt the hot breath against her. Oh god… were they going to lick her asshole? Eat her butt out? One of her cheerleader hookups in high school had done that to her. Jennifer had lost her mind and cummed buckets, but had been too scared to try it again since. She had only just recently worked up the nerve to try and offer Woody some butt fun. That was half the point of the toy. She squealed as she felt her insides, suddenly, doused with a cold liquid.

"What's happening Jenny?"

"I… something cold just filled my ass... liquid I think," Jennifer gasped out as she stood there shaking on the spot.

"Like lube?"

"Yeah… I guess… I don't know what that feels like."

"Cold, gooey and kinda slimy?"

"Yeah… how do you know what lube feels… oh… oh… ooooooh!" Jennifer exclaimed as she felt herself be penetrated by something. "I think… I think they just stuck something in me!"

"Their dick?" Woody asked, sounding a little too excited, but Jennifer was too distracted to notice.

"I don't know… it feels really fucking big… but I've never put anything into my butt… so maybe… no wait… it's flexing about… I think it's only a finger!" Jennifer said, sounding horrified. If that was their finger, how were they going to stick their fat fucking dick in her ass? Were they even planning to do that? What if it was only fingers for now… or what if it was something bigger than their fingers or that thick dick?

"How does it feel?"

"It um…" Jennifer tried to muster her words as the finger shifted around within her. It seemed to be feeling her out, exploring her depths. "It hurts… a bit… it's uncomfortable… but… less so now that I am… getting used to it." Her face burned and she felt a little dizzy from both feeling of humiliation and arousal at her admission.

"Dose it feel… good… at all?" Woody asked between laboured breaths.

"No… welllll… maybe… a tiny, little bit," Jennifer admitted and whimpered as the finger pulled back. Was that it? She felt… strangely disappointed. Her eyes widened and her legs gave out as she felt the finger return alongside a second one. "Oh fuck!" She collapsed back onto the bed.

"What happened? Jennifer?" Woody demanded. "What's going on? Are they fucking you?"

"I… give me a second," Jennifer groaned as the two fingers plunged into her. They were slower going into her than the first. Her ass clenching tightly around them. She was not sure if she was doing that in a futile attempt to keep them out or if her body, by itself, was doing that in response. She was overwhelmed by the feeling.

"Babe? What's happening? Tell me!" Woody said, sounding frantic.

He must be seething mad right now, Jennifer realised. He had been so angry before when she told him what happened. Poor guy, she could only imagine how furious she would be if some other woman was fucking him like this… her thoughts were interrupted as the pair of fingers sunk fully into her. She could feel the other digits rubbing against the outer sides of her rear hole. The knuckles resting right below her entrance.

"Babe!"

"Two… two fingers inside me," Jennifer hissed out before gasping as she felt them begin to move around. Her thighs quivered and she bit hard into her bottom lip as she felt them scissor out from one another and explore her untouched hole, well not so untouched now. "They're playing with me… touching everything they can inside of me… I can feel them stretching me out!"

"Oh yeah?" Woody said. He was so mad, he sounded like his whole body was tense, Jennifer could hear it in his tone, he must be shaking with rage.

"Yeah they… they just pulled back… their pushing back in! I think… I think they are fingering my ass!" Jennifer yelped as she felt them plunge back into her. "Fuck… everything is so slipery in there. I can't… can't halt them at all… no matter how hard I clench."

"Oh fuck… are you okay? How are you feeling?"

"I… Woody… it… doesn't hurt anymore… still weird… but… it feels… good. Really fucking good!"

"Mmmmmmm."

"Oh… they pulled out," Jennifer said, her voice sounding almost disappointed. She felt strangely empty now. Her nipples were stiff as diamonds, she could feel her pussy leaking onto the bed below her and her breathing was almost as laboured as Woody's. Worst of all… she wanted desperately… to beg for those fingers to return. Her heart skipped a beat and she almost choked on her own saliva as she felt something new, yet familiar, push against her puckered hole next. That dick…

Kim took a moment to admire her work. One moist, well lubricated, and stretched open asshole. It was just begging to get fucked as she wiped her slippery fingers off on her bedspread. Her girl cock was more than ready as she brought the toy down towards the stiff member. Lining it up was strangely easier than lining up with Jennifer's pussy. Kim smirked as she pushed the head of her girl cock into that tight hole.

She groaned as the puckered hole slowly gave way. Unlike before, she did not want to savour this experience. She wanted to fuck Jennifer hard and rough. She wanted to ruin her. Break her ass. Make her feel this in the morning. The only thing that even slowed her down was just how tight Jennifer was. She felt amazing around Kim but it was a chore to **** the toy down upon her cock.

"Oh my fucking god!" Jennifer cried out as she felt the cock push brutally into her. Tears welled in her eyes and she hissed as her fist clenched around her phone. "Woody… Woody… they're fucking my ass… with… with…" Her bottom lip quivered and she let out a little sob. "That big fucking cock!"

"How's it feel?" Woody asked, sounding strained.

"It fucking hurts! Oh fuck… fucking… fuckity… fuuuuuck!" Jennifer cried before clenching her teeth together as she felt the cock fill her deepest places and continue to push into her. It felt like a literal baseball bat was being shoved up inside her. She was breathing hard and gasping as inch after inch of cock penetrated her ass and she could do nothing but lay there and take it.

Finally, it bottomed out, at least Jennifer hoped it had, as she tried to catch her breath only to whimper as it pulled back and then slammed into her. She felt like all the air was hammered out of her lungs. She tried to speak to Woody, tell him what was going on, she could hear him saying something, but she could not even understand him let alone form words of her own. Instead, all she could do was sob, whimper, moan, groan and wail as her ass was torn apart.

Kim took out years of pent up rage and fury upon Jennifer's ass. With each thrust she thought of a time she was humiliated, belittled, physically abused, called names by, had her whole day ruined by, literally, hunted around the school by and made into the laughing stock of all her peers, by Jennifer fucking Wilson.

"Who's laughing now, Jennifier?" Kim taunted as she thrust the toy down upon herself. She could feel Jennifer's anal passage shaking and quivering around it. She liked to imagine she was feeling Jennifer crying and sobbing. "Not you… not you anymore or ever again!"

It did not take long for Kim to arrive at her peak. She pulled the toy down all the way to the base of her girl cock and just unloaded inside of Jennifer's ass, painting her guts white. She must have cum more inside Jennifer's bowels than she had in her pussy and throat combined. Kim felt smugly satisfied as she came down from her high. Her cock slowly softened inside of Jennifer as her whole body went lax.

"Sleep well bitch. I know I will," Kim said as she pulled the toy free and turned the portal off. She thought about switching it instead to the oral function and making Jennifer clean off her own ass from Kim's girl cock, but she was honestly, too tired. Kim placed the toy back in the drawer and pulled her blankets over herself as she tucked her girl cock back into her pyjama pants. Sleep found her easily as she drifted right off.

Meanwhile, up stairs, Woody was fighting to stay as quiet as he could while he listened in on the phone to his girlfriend being fucked in the ass. He had given in and begun stroking his cock, like he knew he would when he first took off his pants. Jennifer was able to get out a free word or two every so often between her sobs and moans to tell him what was happening. She did not convey much information but it was clear as day what was happening just from her other noises.

She was being harshly bum fucked by the stranger. The other dude who was fucking Woody's girlfriend. He hated them so much but at the same time… he was filled with so much lust from what they were doing to her. He angrily jerked himself off to the sounds she was making. All the while trying to whisper soft comforts to Jennifer as she endured this rough treatment. At one point he came as he heard her exclaim that the stranger was cumming inside of her.

Woody had to gag himself with his own pillow to muffle the cry he let out as he exploded in his own hand. That was the second time today he cum like that. Painting his hand with sperm like he had painted Kim's feet. Thoughts of her filled his mind, strangely, as he came. He remembered her confident voice, the feeling of her perfect little feet, those pale boobs with thick, lovely nipples…

Thoughts of Jennifer also filled his mind. The awe inducing sound of her voice as she was fucked in the ass right now. The divine taste of her pussy after he had cum inside of her and was eating her out till she came all over his face. The beautiful sight of her being railed by his teammate after that game last year…

Woody collapsed back onto his bed with a deep sigh. He could hear Jennifer still sobbing, quietly now, on the other end, sniffling. "Are you… are you alright… Babe?" Woody asked, his voice sounding rough.

"I… I don't know… I wish you were here."

"I am Baby. I am here."

"No I mean… really here. I want you to hold me safe in your big strong arms. Whisper to me that everything is going to be alright. Kiss me and tell me I am alright."

"You are alright and it will be okay," Woody said as he glanced at the time on his phone, it was late. "I think you should go have a shower, clean yourself up and get some sleep."

"I'm sick of showering… I'm too tired and sore to get up… I'll have one in the morning." Woody had to suppress the urge to growl at that. The thought of her going to sleep with an ass full of someone else's spunk… it made him violently horny. "I love you. Goodnight."

"You too. Night Babe," Woody said almost robotically as he hung up. He immediately pulled up his travel app and began searching for flights home in the morning. It felt like there was little he could do here away from Jennifer. At least, if he was there, he could comfort her. He ignored the guilt weighing him down as he booked the soonest flight out he could afford.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)