Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 57 by keron keron

What's next?

Invitation to stay

"John!" Nick calls out to you as you start to walk out of Olivia's bedroom. You stop and look over your shoulder. "You don't have to leave. You can stay if you want to watch or anything," Nick says. "Right, darling?" he asks Olivia, who looks confused at first and she looks into his eyes for a while before she speaks.

"Of course. Whatever you want, honey," she says, kissing him.

As Nick and Olivia resume making out, you're not really sure what to do so you just stand there near the door and watch them. You don't exactly feel comfortable but you don't want to leave either. Their hands are all over each other and soon Nick has pulled Olivia's slip all the way up to under her arm pits and her full, nubile body is exposed. The sight of her familiar body excites you as you think about the countless times you've enjoyed her snug pussy and nuzzled your face in her small but perky breasts. You feel some jealously as you watch Olivia stroke Nick's sizeable cock while he gropes her and inserts a finger into her slit. You could easily use your mind control ring to get rid of Nick and make Olivia yours again, but they look like a genuinely happy couple and you feel that it's only fair to Olivia after being in a coma for so long to let her have her happiness.

You're wondering how much longer you should stay when Nick looks over at you. "You're more than welcomed to join in, mate. Olivia told me everything about you 2," he says.

"You sure?" you say.

"Of course!" Nick replies and Olivia smiles and nods in agreement to let you know that she's okay with it too.

You're a little taken aback by the invitation, but you find yourself walking slowly over to the bed and taking your shirt off. You keep watching them make out while you get naked and when you are, Nick and Olivia shift around on the bed to make room for you. The petite blonde lays down in center of the bed while Nick grabs a pillow and puts it under her head. Then, he moves closer to her head until his cock is hanging over her face. Nick motions to between Olivia's legs as you climb onto the bed. "Go ahead, shag her first," he says.

It's 1 thing to be polite, but inviting you to fuck his fiancée seems too good to be true. Needless to say, you're already hard and you get between Olivia's legs, spreading her thighs apart while staring down at her familiar shaved pussy. As you line your cock up to penetrate her, Olivia is already sucking on Nick's cock while he's watching your cock and you slowly push it in.

"Ughh!" you groan in pleasure, remembering how tight Olivia is as you enter her gradually until you bottom out.

Olivia pauses blowing Nick and looks up at you smiling. "I've missed you," she says as you start fucking her and you're tempted to lean down to kiss her, but she quickly tilts her head away to take Nick's cock back into her mouth and gets fucked at both ends.

Please log in to view the image

"It's a great snatch, innit?" Nick says after a while.

You look up at him, thinking it was a rhetorical question, but he's staring at you and appears to be waiting for a response.

"Uh... yeah... tight..." you say awkwardly, maintaining eye contact with Nick while your hips continue to thrust against his fiancée.

"You had many women, right? Since you got those rings?" the Englishman asks, keeping the conversation going while Olivia sucks his cock intently. Your eyes narrow as you start to wonder how much Nick knows about you and your rings. Even before the incident, the only person you had told the whole truth to was Melanie and it's possible she told Olivia while you were in a coma. Did she then tell Nick? It seems the most possible answer.

"Um, I guess you could say that," you say.

"But you kept Olivia around all the time," Nick says.

"Um... well... she was the first I had been with after I got...the rings.... I mean, she's a really nice gal... very sweet..." you stumble through your response, unsure of how Nick feels about your past with Olivia even though he had invited you to join them. However, while the conversation is uncomfortable for you, it doesn't seem to bother your cock as you suddenly feel a familiar tightness in your loins and you know you're about to finish soon. Looking down at your cock plunging into Olivia's snug pussy for a few more times, you pull it out just in time to start spraying your cum on her stomach, something you have never done with her before. Prior to the coma, you had always finished inside Olivia, but now circumstances are changed. Shortly after you're finished, Nick pulls his cock away from Olivia's mouth and starts pumping it patiently until he cums too, aiming for Olivia's face while she opens her mouth to taste some of it. When Nick is done, he leans down and kisses Olivia on her forehead and she closes her eyes.

"Let's get some fresh air and chat, shall we?" Nick says to you.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)