Intermission: Moonlit Reflections

Night was absolute. The world had been emptied of all color and consequence, reduced to the surface tension between water and sky. Arabella floated nude in the inky black water, hair blooming around her head in a sanguine corona, eyes wide open to the inverted universe overhead. Her body ached. Every muscle was a wire stretched to its breaking, and her lungs made do with each thin, tremulous sip of air.

The water’s rim vanished into the darkness, and for a while Arabella had the sense of floating not in water but in the void between the stars—an old, familiar trick of the architecture, meant to awe, but never more effective than on a night like this, when the constellations had drifted far from their proper positions and nothing below or above could be trusted to behave.

The sea beyond the edge was soundless, as if the island had been unplugged from the world. Even the insects had given up their little rituals. Arabella found it comforting. She was, after all, the oldest thing left here. There were times she could barely remember how many cycles she had overseen, but in the presence of the stars she always seemed to recollect.

Tonight, her work was nearly done. The old ways had cost her more than usual. Even now, her skin tingled with the residue of their ancient friction, as if she’d been lightly sanded from the inside out. The exhaustion was pleasant, in a way. It was the kind of pain that came from doing a job thoroughly, a rare luxury in this age of quick edits and cheap spectacle.

Her eyes were open, but her mind ran unspooled, thoughts tumbling in gentle, concentric circles.

She remembered her very first Earth season: before “Arabella,” before the titles, when she’d still had a voice that quavered. The first Master—Abi-Eshu, he’d been called—was a brute in the most literal sense, a Sumerian with hands like spades and a head shorn to scarred leather. The Contestants that year wore drab kaunakes, heavy with oil and sweat, and the island was more mud than magic. There were no infinity pools then, just brine and bricks of mud and straw and the steam pools. Luxurious by comparison, though in memory they had always smelled faintly of ****.

She recalled how easily those first girls adapted, how quickly they started to giggle and bicker and sing, even as the cycles erased them, even as the Master’s tastes grew more elaborate and cruel. She remembered how one day, Abi-Eshu decided he only wanted twins, so the whole cohort was paired up, and the girls spent their afternoons matching their steps, learning to braid each other’s hair the same way, their minds melting into each other’s until, for a while, Arabella could not recall which pair she had been summoned to referee. But the girls never protested. They wanted only to survive, desperately, and sometimes, to be beautiful.

Arabella’s lips twitched at the memory. The more things changed, the more the core impulse stayed: a yearning for something just beyond reach, be it mercy, love, or simple understanding.

The stars overhead blurred, then reassembled. She blinked, surprised by her own tears. Arabella did not weep—she had been made, in part, to outlast that—but tonight, her body betrayed her with salt. It must be the Old Paths, she told herself. No other explanation.

She let herself sink, just an inch, so the water closed over her face. The cold was a jolt. Her lungs rebelled, demanding air, and she surfaced, gasping. This was how it always went: the taste of freedom, the return of gravity.

She rolled onto her back and let her arms go limp, legs splaying. She floated, suspended, letting the water bear the brunt of her fatigue. Every part of her was sore: her thighs from running the basalt causeway in the lower tunnels; her wrists from wrestling the stupid, stubborn lid of the iron box; her jaw from speaking the invocation with perfect diction, a task she had not performed since the time of the Romans. The Old Paths were never easy. But the alternatives were worse, and she was nothing if not thorough.

She remembered the feeling, as a younger Arabella, of thinking she might someday choose not to return from the Old Paths. That she might simply stop, somewhere in the dark, and wait for the rest of the universe to notice her absence. In those moments, she’d almost felt alive. But she always came back. Always. It was her duty. She had a contract.

Above her, the stars had shifted again. They were not the stars she remembered of old. How had the universe aged? Or was she simply out of sync with time?

She thought of Andy, the new Master, and the girls. Especially the girls. They never changed, not in any way that mattered. Each carried her own logic, her own sad or hopeful vision of what the world owed her. Each brought something to the game, whether she knew it or not.

Arabella reflected on the week’s progress. The first elimination was always a formality, but this time the field was crowded with unusual talents and liabilities. Claire, with her ghostly intuition, seemed to know things that surprised Arabella. Marissa, who disguised every vulnerability with the armor of irony and intellect, was already seeing further ahead than any previous “therapist” type. Liesa and Dawn brought a lightness that was neither faked nor fragile, and Norah—well, Norah had teeth, but also a streak of sentimentality so wide it bordered on the tragic. There were always oddities, but this time, the balance was different. She had picked them for this. But she would need to be careful.

Andy would be tested. She had arranged for it. The first challenge would either break him or make him. Arabella was uncertain, for the first time in a dozen cycles, which outcome she preferred. This ambiguity disturbed her. She was not meant to have preferences, not in the long run. But the sense of looming finale was unmistakable.

She had collected the first of the things she needed. For the rest, the message was secured, the turtle waiting at the appointed place. With any luck, it would make its way to its appointed destination before the next elimination. Arabella was good at managing such details. That was her gift, if not her curse.

She drifted, eyes unfocused, until she lost track of time. The world was just a pattern of dark and chill, with the press of the water and the slow, metronomic drumbeat of her own pulse.

Eventually, she let her feet find the bottom of the pool. She pushed up, breaking the surface with a spray of cool droplets that caught the starlight in bursts of impossible color. She walked to the edge, water sluicing from her skin in perfect beads. She stepped out and stood a moment, utterly naked in the night air, letting the world reacquaint itself with her shape.

The turtle was waiting on the stone lip, precisely where she’d left it. It was enormous, easily two feet across, its carapace patterned with whorls and scars that mapped a history longer than any human had lived. Its eyes were ancient and knowing, and Arabella regarded it with something like affection.

She knelt in front of it, her knees pressing into the cold tile. The turtle looked at her, as if awaiting instructions.

“It is time,” she said softly. Her voice, raw from the invocations, was almost unrecognizable. “You know the way.”

The turtle blinked, gravely, and for a moment, Arabella imagined it truly understood. Maybe it did. She had seen stranger things.

A length of red twine was knotted around the creature’s shell, securing a tightly rolled tube of parchment. Arabella reached out, ran a gentle hand along the shell’s ridge, then nudged it in the direction of the far path.

“Go,” she whispered.

The turtle moved, slow but inexorable, its legs scraping the tile with a sound like old teeth on stone. It reached the end of the pool deck, hesitated, then dropped into the grass below and vanished into the darkness.

Arabella watched it go, the faintest smile twitching at the corners of her mouth. She stood, shivering, and drew her arms around herself. She had done what she could. Now, she only had to wait.

She cast one final look at the stars. They were still wrong, but maybe that was as it should be.

She padded inside, leaving wet footprints on the tile, her mind already skipping forward to the next day, the next challenge, the next reckoning. There would be time to rest later. For now, she was exactly where she belonged: in the thin, bright moment before the world woke up and remembered its own cruelty.

At the summit of the island’s old volcano, a bare platform of obsidian served as a stage. The wind was cold and constant, pushing at every hem and strand, but Arabella stood rooted in the center, her body an exclamation point of glamour against the living wilderness below.

She was dressed for the role. The gown was a slip of liquid copper, the kind of garment that rippled and glimmered with every movement, casting shadows that flickered in the dying light. The cut was high at the neck, low at the back, and impossible at the legs, where a slit ran from thigh to ankle. Her hair was perfect, a lacquered sculpture of waves and coils, and her lips were the lacquered red of a promise never to be kept. The shoes—six-inch heels, blade-sharp—gave her height and command. Nothing about her was accidental.

Arabella’s transformation from shivering pool-wraith to Host was complete. She smiled into the searing spotlights that ringed the platform, and waited for the three-count cue that would beam her image to every Audience device and wall-screen from here to the edge of the known world.

She breathed once, in through the nose and out through the mouth, then let her mask snap into place. The lights flared, the wind cut, and the island was hers.

“Good evening, darlings,” she purred, voice carrying over the entire caldera, and, via glass and wire and streaming silicon, into a million hungry homes. “It’s your ever-faithful Host, Arabella, perched at the very heart of The HH, ready to announce this week’s most anticipated event: the Best Girl poll!”

She said it with relish, lips curving just enough to hint at secrets yet to be spilled. Arabella’s every movement was calculated—she gestured with open, generous arms, palms up, as if physically inviting the audience in.

“We have eight remarkable young women, each of them striving to charm, seduce, and outmaneuver not only their Master, but also each other. You’ve watched their stories unfold, you’ve argued in the forums, you’ve debated every twist and turn. Now, at last, the power is yours. Cast your vote for your favorite. Let your voice shape their destiny.”

She paused, giving just a beat too long for the cameras to linger on the lines of her neck, the careful dip of her shoulder. “Remember, your votes don’t just count. They change the game.”

The wind caught the edge of her dress, but Arabella only leaned into it, making the moment a tableau. “The polls are open. You may vote as you wish. Who will be this week’s Best Girl? Will it be Claire, the silent genius? Sam, the steady rock at the eye of the storm? Marissa, the maverick with a mind like a razor? Or perhaps gentle Liesa, whose heart is bigger than her smile? The choice is yours, and only yours.”

She lowered her voice, a smoky aside. “And, as always, you may send your comments, suggestions, or heartfelt confessions to the Master or to any Contestant directly. We read every word. Nothing is too scandalous. Nothing too tender. You have a few days, if you wish, to send your notes. They will receive your messages, should you choose to send any, before the challenge begins.”

A fresh gust of air, carrying the scent of sulfur and flowers, twisted a strand of her hair into her eyes. She brushed it aside with a flick, and smiled again, this time less for the crowd and more for herself.

She straightened, lifted her chin, and let her voice ring. “As for the next Challenge… well, you’ll have to wait and see. But I can promise you this: it will be unlike anything you’ve witnessed before.”

The sun dipped below the rim of the crater, painting her silhouette in fire and ink. Arabella closed her eyes, just for a heartbeat, and when she opened them again, every trace of weariness had vanished.

She gave the camera a last, slow wink. “May the best girl win. Until next time—this is Arabella, signing off from paradise. Good night, sweethearts.”

She held the pose as the light faded, the wind finally claiming the stage. When the cameras cut, she let the smile drop, rolled her shoulders, and turned her back on the island. Only then did the fatigue reassert itself, a seam of pain running from calf to crown. But she didn’t stumble. She never did.

Arabella’s shadow stretched across the volcanic stone, long and elegant and indelible. She watched it move with her, one last trick of the light before darkness closed in.

When she reached the far edge, she stopped, and for a moment seemed to teeter—between stage and reality, between duty and desire, between what she was and what she’d been made to be. Then she steadied herself, squared her shoulders, and strode into the gloom, the world once again ready to be remade at her pleasure.

The Host was still on the clock.

Best Girl Poll is open until Sunday, 11.59pm EST!

Poll closed. Thank you!

Please feel free to send fan mail to any character (you can do so via DM on CYHOA or via Discord). Any fan mail received before the Best Girl Poll closes will be featured before the Challenge.