In the bomb shelter once again

"Are you sure you're okay Kat?" Caleb asked once she was settled crosswise on his lap on one of the bomb shelter couches.

Seated beside Lori on one of the loveseats, June softly said, "Of course she isn't. So we need to figure out how to fix this. We could make it so that the Sisterhood never makes their offer."

Kathy sighed, pressing a tit against Caleb's chest as she leaned over to kiss his cheek. "It's sweet of you to worry about me, both of you. But I'm fine. Before Caleb created miracle milk, I had been watching my dad slowly die for years, so his death isn't as big of a shock as you might expect. And I'm ashamed to say this, but there were times when I resented him. Mom had to work two jobs just to pay the bills. Dad's disability checks didn't cover his medications, much less the house payment. So Mom worked all the time. I had to do all the housework, and take care of my dad. That's how I learned to cook. I had to."

She looked over at June and said, "And I really don't think anything can be done. We don't even know exactly when Dad died. And changing the past could really screw things up. If Dad doesn't leave Mom when he did, that means she won't join Caleb's harem when SHE did. Fast forward to now, and would they still be engaged? Would she even still live here? Remember Amelia? She disappeared from our lives after creating the normality where sons take ownership of their mothers. Even if we changed the past and had Dad simply walk out on Mom, things would still change. Mom was heartbroken after Dad left. That's why she fell in love with Caleb so fast."

She looked into Caleb's eyes and said, "I don't want to risk losing that. I can't. I don't just love her. I'm in love with her. I have been for a long time. And she belongs in your harem."

Caleb put his arms around her and squeezed. "You know that's new reality Kathy talking. You probably weren't in love with her in the original reality."

Kathy grunted, "So? Caleb, my love, how many times do I have to tell you, I don't care what the original Kathy would think. She doesn't exist anymore, if she ever did. You don't know if the original version of me had the hots for my mom or not. Just because incest was a taboo doesn't mean people didn't indulge in it. You get a thrill out of fucking your family, so maybe the other me would have too."

Caleb shook his head, chagrined at her reprimand. "Okay babe. But that still doesn't change the fact that the Sisterhood manipulated us. And it's mostly my fault. I really fucked with the world. I keep thinking with my dick, and it keeps biting us on the ass."

Kathy snorted at that mental image of his big dick biting people like a snake. Then she kissed him and said, "You're not the only one changing the world because you're horny. I didn't tell you this, but Mom wasn't the only one the Sisterhood manipulated into joining your Harem. They offered to sneak some of your cum into Cora's food so that my harem effect would work on her while she was so far away at college. At first I said no. I was horrified by the idea actually. This was right after we first learned about the harem effect and what it would do to our moms. But then Deanna and the softball team had an orgy with Maggie's boyfriend and some of his friends. After I saw the picture of Deanna's cum covered face while she was jacking off another guy, well, I got mad. I told Sonia to go through with it because I wanted someone I knew would be loyal to you in the harem. One of their Lotus Sisters put an entire vial of your cum in Cora's coffee. She broke up with her boyfriend a few hours later, and came home the next day."

"Holy shit Kat. That's..." Caleb paused before he blew out his breath. "You know what, fuck it. You were going to use the harem effect on her the next time she came home anyway."

Kathy smiled and said. "Well, I didn't know I could use it to get the things I want. Not then. I do now though. And I was going to get Cora for your harem if I had to chase her halfway across the world. She's sweet and kind, and one of the hottest girls I know. That fact that we can share bras now is just icing on my cake," Kathy finished with a smirk.

Lori got their attention by asking, "Okay. Now we really need to decide what to do about Tabitha. You can't really want to keep her, do you?"

Kathy sighed, "Yes and no. It's not really her fault. She was just following orders. I know that's a piss poor excuse for what she did, but I feel sorry for her. The way she looked at me, the turmoil in the harem link, her begging for my forgiveness as she slit her throat. I can't forget that. It's been running through my head all day."

Looking back down at Caleb she added, "And you have to admit, she's pretty fucking hot. Taller than me, and her boobs aren't as big, but the sisterhood did a pretty good job picking her to play the role. She set a fire in your nuts, and I need her to teach that to me. She did such a good job turning you on, you claimed her without meaning to. But that also makes us responsible for her happiness. My love, when we mess around with reality, we need to make sure we don't hurt others. Remember how you freaked out when you realized you'd wiped eighty percent of men out of existence?"

Caleb huffed, "Okay, but what about your mom? She was married to your dad for over twenty years. And Brandy is certainly going to have a problem with this, not to mention Cora."

Kathy shook her head and said, "Brandy I can deal with. Mom might be a problem but also workable. And Cora will be fine. Dad was creeping on her. That's why she didn't come home very often. You need to make sure you never make it norma..."

Kathy bit her sentence off and lifted his wrist to look at his watch. Seeing the seconds hand moving at a normal speed she went on. "Don't make it... commonplace that girls fuck their dads. You and our daughters, yes. But not other men."

Caleb huffed, "Dang it Kat. I don't want to bang our babies. I'm not into that kind of thing. MILF's and married women, remember?"

Lori snorted, "Give it a few decades Sweetie. Even June's baby won't be an adult for another eighteen and a half years. You might change your mind by then. I didn't start thinking about Emily sexually till you found your watch, but I can't say the same about the way I looked at you. I did want you, in both sets of memories."

June agreed. "Honey, I looked forward to giving you your first blowjob. Anticipated it. I'm sure if my memories had changed after I came up with the mother ownership normality I would have been looking forward to giving myself to you. As soon as they become adults, our daughters are going to want their daddy's dick. And you'll give it to them because you love them. The same way I gave myself to you."

Caleb half laughed, "You do realize how many daughters that will be, right? I've gotten over a hundred women pregnant since I found the watch. And all of the women in my harem will only have girls. Kat wants an army of children, and I know you do too. Lori wants a bunch of kids too, and that's not even mentioning the rest of my harem. None of you are going to get any older either, so you'll get to have the huge ass family you want. If you all get your way, I'll be sticking my dick in my daughters twenty four seven. I'll never even have time for you three anymore."

Kathy snorted, "It won't be as bad as you think. You're forgetting that all women are bisexual, and I have my shadow cock spell. I can teach it to the others. All of our children will be witches, so they can use the spell too. My shadows are a copy of your cock, so we can use them to play with each other when you're busy. And we still have the normality that makes anyone watching us have sex feel your cock in them too. You can fuck a dozen daughters at a time."

Caleb frowned, "I already got rid of that one. People got hurt when we fucked at the service party Kat."

Lori cackled and said, "So we got to word it right when we bring it back. Make it like the pleasure increase normalities and only have it affect women in the same room as you."

Kathy excitedly blurted, "Hell yeah! We could rent an auditorium or amphitheater and fuck in there! You could fuck a hundred women at once! Or better yet, a stadium! Then you could do thousands in one shot! And you could make your loads even bigger! Fill an entire bathtub with-"

Caleb put his hand over Kathy's mouth to silence her and said, "You, my sexy little minx, are fucking crazy. There is no way I'm doing that."

June giggled and said, "Don't toss the idea aside without thinking it through. Right now, sure, it's crazy. But Caleb Sweetie, we are going to live hundreds of years. You probably will have giant fuck-a-thons at some point. And it doesn't have to be just Kathy that you do this with. You could make that normality work with all the women in your harem. A hundred, two hundred years from now, you might like the idea. By then, every woman on the planet will know that sex with you is better than what any other guy can give. So they will all want to feel your dick in them."

Lori snorted, "Yeah, but he won't get to enjoy a fraction of them. This is all a nice idea, but how do we keep our man from getting bored if the only women he gets to fuck in person are his harem?"

Kathy shrugged, "We'll make sure he gets plenty of married MILFs. And he won't admit to it, but he likes fresh young women too. Melanie is going to bring him lots of fresh, tight, unstretched pussies every year. A lot of them might even be virgins. After all, I waited to have my first time with Caleb. Chris's brother Kyle tried desperately to get me to sleep with him. Like fucking yuck! But anyway, the girls at the high school will wait too, once they realize they get to have Caleb as their first."

Caleb got Kathy's attention and said, "Wait. Go back. Kyle tried to sleep with you?"

Kathy snorted, "Not just me. He tried to get Gabbie, Misty, and even Chris. And all their half sisters. He failed every time. Gabbie only had eyes for you, and Misty was a virgin till you popped her cherry. Chris was never gonna surrender the pink to her brother, and I doubt he got any of their sisters either. You aren't the only one that wants to fuck his family. It's not a big deal like it is for you."

Lori smirked, "Yeah Sweetie. Even before you became a Stretcher King, your sister didn't think it was odd to have sex with you. Incest isn't really much of a kink in this latest reality. Brothers and sisters fuck now. Not all that much, or that many, but way more than in the original reality. It's not illegal like daddy daughter sex is, just a social taboo. Dads still don't fuck their daughters, but mothers have sex with all their children as soon as those kids become adults, regardless of gender."

Caleb complained, "Then why do you three want me to bang my daughters? All three of you want it."

Kathy sighed, "Ugh. This again. Caleb, I want it because I want every woman worthy of you bouncing on your dick. These are going to be your children. Born a Stretcher King's child, smart and in perfect health. They will be raised on miracle milk, meaning they will stay super healthy. You're the one that made our milk heal minor illnesses for everyone that drinks it. That includes our kids. Their mothers are the hottest women we know, and they will grow up being just as hot. They will be perfect little cum sluts for their perfect Daddy."

June agreed and said, "Caleb Sweetie, our daughters, mine and yours, won't just be daughters, they will also be your sisters. You know you love fucking Hazel. Are you only going to fuck and breed one sister and not the others?"

Lori piled on by saying, "Don't forget Amber and Amanda, or the rest of the dairy herd. You are their bull. And Hucow daughters expect to get stretched and bred by their daddies. Connie was heartbroken when her dad refused to breed her the day before her wedding."

Caleb's lips thinned, remembering Nikki telling him about why her grandfather stretched her instead of her father. She wanted her dad to do it, but he left her mother's herd for a younger one.

June added to their side of the argument by saying, "And you're the one that gave women the cum eating fetish. You can't sit there and tell us you'll refuse to feed your daughters the best cum around. Daughters get their first cum load from their fathers by sucking their cocks. In this reality, Hazel's very first blowjob was to your dad, not you. Chris and her father, Gabbie and hers, Megumi, Mary, Sonia, April, Katie, they all gave their fathers a blowjob on their eighteenth birthday. Almost your entire harem has had their father's dicks in their mouth. The only reason Lori and I didn't blow your grandfather is because he was cheating on your grandmother. It's a special moment in a young woman's life to get on her knees and show her daddy she loves him by taking the cum she needs to be healthy straight from the dick that made her."

Kathy ran her fingers through Caleb's hair and said, "Think about that, my love. Chris is a lesbian, but she sucked her daddy's dick. Because she loves him. And our daughters are going to love you. They are going to want to show you their love."

June regained his attention and said, "And Sweetheart, there is one kind of dad that does fuck his daughters. A dad with a stretcher. Your daughters are going to expect to get their daddy's dick. Not just Amber and Amanda's daughters, all of them. And your wives are going to want to watch you do it. What are you going to say to Angie, or Gabbie, when they ask why you won't give their daughters a stretch? I love watching you fuck Hazel, and Lori loves watching you fuck Emily. Mary loves that all three of her girls have had you inside them. We, the moms club, we all love that we get to share you with our daughters."

Caleb looked at each of them in turn, noting the smug looks on their faces. They knew he knew they'd won the argument. He couldn't even begin to refute them. With a sigh he said, "Fine damn it. I'll think about it. Now, is there anything else we need to talk about while we are down here?"

Kathy giggled and said, "Sorry my love. We kinda ganged up on you. But you created this reality. Sure we helped, but you have to live with the consequences. You don't have to concede defeat right now, but you will give in eventually. We won't change our minds, and neither will the rest of the harems, or our children."

Caleb pulled Kathy closer to him so he could rest his head on her giant tit. She continued to run her fingers through his hair, enjoying the cuddle.

June and Lori leaned against each other, holding hands as Kathy flooded the harem link with her love. June returned it, while Lori continued attempting to manipulate her own link. She was learning, but hadn't quite mastered it the way Mary, Kathy and June had.

Suddenly June sat up and said, "Oh, hey Kathy, how is your plan with the cheerleaders coming along?"

Kathy smiled brightly, "It's going great. We just finished an orgy in the Pit when Chloe called and told us to come home. Over half the cheerleaders showed up, and Burnie arranged it all with them. Caleb stretched one of them too."

"Actually Kat, I stretched another one before you got there." Caleb interjected. At June he added, "Hazel took charge, but she made sure the cheerleaders knew Burnie picked them out."

June smiled, "That's great. I'm sure Burnadette will take over as captain of the squad soon."

Caleb blurted, "Hey! I just had a thought. If Kesha is a butt slut, maybe Dad might like to have her. She's pretty, with a hot body too. Nice big tits and an ass plumper than Kat's."

Kathy briefly gripped his hair and barked, "Hell no! Absolutely not! No way am I letting her get anywhere near your dad. Caleb, we just had a lesbian orgy with his girlfriends. That's probably not gonna be the only time, especially if you are gonna be breeding them. Kesha is NOT getting you or your dad's dicks. I will never allow it."

"Damn babe, it was just a thought." Caleb quickly backpedaled, even as he winced from the pain of having his hair pulled. "I was thinking I could use the watch to turn her into an obedient servant or something. Like a bang maid in a slutty maid outfit. She just needs an attitude adjustment."

Kathy grumped, "Still no. Yeah, I'd love to see her as nothing more than a little fuck toy. But I want her to become a cum dump for the guys among the Denizens. She terrorized them every bit as much as the girls. Jeremy has been fucking her on the regular, I think they might even be a couple now. But I want all the guys fucking her. Did you know she hates getting cum on her face? She even hates blowjobs. You could use the watch to make her keep hating it, but she has to do it anyway. Like she has a disease or something similar to Shrew Syndrome that makes her need it."

Caleb chuckled at Kathy's tone. She sounded like someone hating blowjobs and not wanting cum on their face was somehow offensive. "I don't know about using the watch like that. It could really fuck something up."

Lori thoughtfully asked, "Why not use magic? Like a charm spell? Hazel told me that charm spells are something that love witches like her specialize in. She could cast something on Kesha."

Kathy kept her face even, not wanting to explain that she'd used charm spells multiple times already, including on Cindy. "I don't think Hazel could. She's just started learning to use her magic. I could probably do it though. I don't have an affinity for them, but I have way more mana than anyone else, so the cost isn't a problem."

June frowned, upset at the turn of the conversation. "I don't like this at all. Do you hear yourselves? What you're contemplating is evil. Turning a woman into a sex slave? What is wrong with you all?"

Kathy sighed, "It's not that much different from using the watch. The watch makes all of us Caleb's sex slaves. Even you have to admit, we all love being your son's fuck toys. But I do see your point." She smirked and added, "We should be using our powers for good."

Caleb nodded and said, "Yeah. Sorry Mom. Back when all this started I made myself a promise that I wouldn't let it turn me into an asshole."

Lori had an idea, "Hey now. Okay, using our magic on Kesha would be shitty, but why not use it on Tabitha? Before you say anything, hear me out June. Brandy is going to hate having Tabitha around, not without punishing her somehow. But what if we use charm magic on Tabitha to punish her for killing Mark?"

June squinted her eyes at her sister and growled, "And just what exactly would you suggest doing to her?"

Kathy tried to hide her excitement, but it was difficult for the young woman. "I have an idea! Lori, you're a genius! This is perfect!"

---

Thanks for making it this far. I hope you've enjoyed the story up to this point. Leave a comment, hit the like button, and tell me the things you would like to see. If you love the story, and want to show your appreciation, how about buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001