I never had yet

I sat on the oversized sectional in Mia's living room, the dim glow of string lights casting a warm seductive haze over the group. The Never Have I Ever game had been Mia's idea and it had turned this hangout into pure filth. There were seven of us: me one of the guys, Mia the bubbly raven haired host, Sarah and Lena the athletic brunettes, Jess and Taylor the giggly ones, and Jake the other dude.

Mia grinned wickedly as she held up her shot glass. "Alright next one. Never have I had my naked body rated by strangers online."

Everyone drank except me. The girls slammed their shots and Jake took his with a smug grin. All eyes turned to me.

Mia's mouth dropped open in exaggerated shock. "Wait you are the only one who has never done it? Everyone else including us girls has had our naked bodies rated online but not you?" She laughed and the girls joined in eyeing me with fresh hunger. "We have to fix that right now. Set him up on Omegle. He and Jake are both getting rated live."

Jake chuckled but I felt my face heat up. The girls were already buzzing with excitement stripping off tops and flashing their tits to hype me up. "Come on strip," Sarah demanded. "We will make it fun."

I pulled off my shirt revealing my decent but not extraordinary body. Jake did the same. Then the pants came off. My cock hung soft at around four and a half inches. Jake's was smaller barely three inches soft. The girls whistled and giggled.

"His is already bigger than Jake's even soft," Lena pointed out. "This is going to be good."

Mia set up the laptop with Omegle video chat and a fake account. She angled it so the camera caught me and Jake from the waist up at first but ready to show everything. The girls crowded around naked or half naked their bodies pressed against us. "Next stranger ask them to rate both your bodies and dicks. Be honest pervs."

The first few chats skipped quickly until we hit a group of three college age girls. They lit up when they saw two naked guys with five hot girls surrounding them.

"Rate their bodies and cocks," Mia called out. "Be mean."

The girls on Omegle laughed and started scoring. My body got a solid seven out of ten. Jake got a five. Then the dicks. They made us stroke to full hardness. Mine reached about four inches thin with a slight curve. Jake topped out at three thin and unimpressive.

"Yours is bigger but still small," one of the Omegle girls said. "Jake has a micro. Four point five beats three though. Loser vibes on both."

The real girls cheered. Mia dropped to her knees and sucked my cock into her warm mouth right on camera. She bobbed fast making loud slurping noises while Sarah did the same to Jake but kept pulling off to laugh at how little she had to work with. The Omegle group went wild typing fast.

Holy shit they are sucking them live.

Rate the blowjobs too. Small dick energy but hot girls.

Next stranger was a solo guy. He rated my body higher than Jake's again and called my cock "average small" while labeling Jake's "tiny failure." The girls rewarded me by letting me grope their tits while I stayed hard on camera. Lena stroked my little pecker with two fingers showing the stranger how easily she could cover it.

"See how small he is?" she teased for the camera. "But still bigger than Jake."

We kept skipping until we found a mixed group of four people two guys and two girls. They demanded full body views. I stood and turned flexing my decent muscles while the girls posed with me. Jake tried to flex but looked awkward. Then the dick rating.

"Stroke them side by side," one demanded.

We did. My four inch hard cock throbbed next to Jake's three inch nub. The group laughed and scored me a six for dick while Jake got a two. "Yours looks more fun to suck. His is basically a clit."

Mia pushed me onto the couch and mounted me right there on camera. Her tight wet pussy sank down on my small cock with a loud moan. "Fuck he feels good enough," she said riding me slowly so the strangers could see my length disappear inside her. The wet sounds echoed. Sarah sat on my face grinding her soaked cunt on my tongue while I licked her deeply.

Jake was forced to watch up close while Jess and Taylor took turns jerking his tiny dick and mocking it for the Omegle audience. "Look how much smaller he is. Our boy wins the small dick contest."

The Omegle group typed furiously. This is the best random chat ever. Make him cum inside her.

Mia rode harder bouncing her ass and moaning like a slut. Her pussy clenched around my little shaft perfectly. I thrust up into her feeling her juices run down my balls. Sarah came on my face flooding my mouth while the strangers watched.

We switched partners for the next chat. A new stranger pair appeared and the girls explained the game. Lena took my cock now riding me reverse cowgirl so the camera showed everything. My small dick pumped in and out of her athletic pussy as she bounced. Jake got a pity handjob from Taylor but they kept stopping whenever he got close.

"Rate them again," Lena gasped while grinding on me. The strangers gave me higher scores across the board. My body was more toned my cock bigger and I was clearly pleasing the girls more. Jake looked humiliated but rock hard in his tiny way.

The girls rotated through me one by one. Sarah rode me next facing the camera so they could see her tits bounce while my little pecker stretched her. She moaned extra loud playing it up. "He is small but hits the right spots. Jake cannot compete."

Jess took a turn sucking me clean of Lena and Sarah's cream right on camera before climbing on and riding me like she was in heat. Her pussy was dripping and noisy as she slammed down repeatedly. Taylor sat on my face this time and I ate her with everything I had while the Omegle strangers cheered us on.

Jake was mostly used as a fluffer. The girls made him lick their pussies right after I pulled out tasting all of us mixed together. They slapped his tiny cock playfully and compared it constantly to mine. "See how much bigger our main boy is? Still small but he wins."

After nearly a dozen chats the girls decided it was time for the grand finale. They lined up on the couch on all fours asses up pussies dripping. I went down the line fucking each one hard and fast while the current Omegle strangers watched. My small cock plunged into Mia then Sarah then Lena then Jess then Taylor. Each girl moaned and pushed back demanding more.

Jake knelt behind me holding my balls or licking where we connected whenever I pulled out. The humiliation fueled me. I fucked harder my hips slapping against their asses. The laptop screen filled with comments praising the live small dick orgy and rating me the clear winner over Jake.

I saved my load for the end. The girls spun around knelt in front of me and Jake on the floor. Five beautiful faces tits out tongues extended. I stroked my slick little pecker furiously while they degraded both of us for the final strangers.

"Cum on us you bigger small dick king," Mia begged. "Paint the winners while Jake watches."

I exploded hard. Thick ropes of cum shot across their faces tits and into open mouths. They kissed and shared my load sloppily some of it dripping onto Jake's tiny cock. The Omegle chat exploded with final ratings giving me the overall victory despite my small size.

After we ended the calls the girls swarmed me. Mia kissed me deep her tongue tasting of my cum. "You were the only one who had never done it and now you crushed it. Beating Jake with your small cock was so hot."

We collapsed in a sweaty pile of bodies. The girls kept teasing Jake about losing while stroking and kissing my little pecker back to life for round two. Promises of more Omegle nights and even wilder ratings filled the air as we kept fucking late into the night. My small dick had won the ratings and earned me the sluttiest group reward possible.