Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by tcorbett691 tcorbett691

What do I say?

I'm taking you home!

"I'm taking you home, young lady!" I said as I grabbed her wrist which she immediately snatched away from me.

"I'm not going anywhere!"

"Everyone needs to calm down." From inside, a tall, brown-skinned man came out and stood in front of Sarah. He had short, black hair and a short beard and was dressed only in a pair of black boxers. My eyes widened when I looked down at his boxers. While I had never seen his face, I knew exactly who this must be. And I knew what was hiding in those boxers: a 9-inch big, black cock! A big, black cock that my daughter loved having deep in every hole. A big black cock that-- "Ma'am?"

"Huh? Oh, I just spaced out for a bit there." I couldn't help but blush.

"Let's all go inside, sit down, and talk this out."

"Right..." As he lead us inside, I noticed the smug smile Sarah had and it pissed me off, again. I needed to focus on that anger and ignore how wet I was already. I'm a highly paid lawyer, damn it! If I couldn't focus, I'd fold like a house of cards if he tried something.

He lead us to the living room which had a sofa and a loveseat. "Have a seat." He offered me a seat on the sofa while he and Sarah sat on the loveseat together. He put his arm around Sarah possessively and she cuddled up to him still smiling smugly. Steve, who I had honestly forgotten about, tried to sit next to me on the sofa but the glare I gave him made him move to the other end. "First, let me introduce myself. My name is Dave Cunningham. This is my house and Sarah has lived with me for the past year."

"You mean you kidnapped my daughter!"

"Kidnapped? You've got it all wrong, Mrs. Doe."

"MISS Doe. Debra Doe."

"Okay. Miss Doe. Anyway, I certainly did not kidnap Sarah. Let me explain. Oh, and Steve, was it? I hope you don't mind if we deal with this unpleasantness before we film your scene."

"Go right ahead," Steve said with a chuckle. "This is very entertaining!"

"Anyway, I'm a high school teacher. I don't know what it is about this generation but high school girls don't look like what I remember them looking like when I was that age. Too many of them look like, well, Sarah. And while I never have and never would touch any of my students, I'd be lying if I didn't think about it. Because of that, I used to frequent adult roleplay chats. Three years ago, I met Sarah in one."

"Three years ago?!" I was shocked! "She would have only been 16!"

"Yes, I found that out later."

"Wait, how did you get on some porn site? I had parental locks on your computer!"

"Mom, I figured out how to bypass those years ago," Sarah said as she rolled her eyes.

"Anyway," Dave continued, "when she admitted to being only 16, I put a stop to things. Or at least tried to. We had built a real connection at that point and apparently she really needed someone to talk to. For over a year, that's all we did. Talk. Then, on her 18th birthday, she asked to see my cock as a birthday present."

"It was love at first sight!" Sarah said with a giggle. "Then, I sent him some nudes, too. After that, we cybered. A lot!"

"A few months later, she messaged me very upset saying she was running away from home. I asked her if she had anywhere to go like a relative. She said no, so I bought her a plane ticket to come here."

"Daddy was such a gentleman. He was actually going to sleep on the couch! Can you believe it? But when he came to check on me, he found me naked in his bed pretending to be one of his students. And yeah, I lost every virginity that day. We were both a little too enthusiastic and I ended up with an unprotected creampie. He was so excited to be fucking my virgin, schoolgirl pussy that he couldn't pull out when I came on his big, black cock. But if you've seen one of my schoolgirl roleplay videos, you know how riled up that gets him."

"Those are my favorite!" Steve added.

"I'm glad you enjoyed them! But yeah, we got really lucky that I didn't get knocked up. Daddy always cums deep inside me and that day was no exception. Then, I gave him my ass. After all, A is for anal! It took me awhile to get used to his big, black cock in my ass. It definitely hurt the first time but I always enjoyed it. I just love being dominated like that!"

I had felt the same way with Steve and that memory pissed me off, again. "And then, he made you do those disgusting videos and whored you off to random strangers!"

"Made me? Daddy doesn't make me do anything!"

"Miss Doe," Dave said, "the Only Fans account was her idea."

"What?!" I asked in shock.

"Yes. A teacher's salary isn't that much and after living her for a month, she decided she wanted to help out with the bills."

"We were playing around with a camera," Sarah continued. "I think I was blowing him or something. After seeing how hot the video looked, I said I bet people would pay to see that. Daddy was against it at first. Even after I convinced him to let me try, he wouldn't be on camera himself. After all, this state has some crazy laws about the conduct of teachers! He could be fired! So at first, it was just nudes of me and videos of me masturbating. But one day, I was blowing Daddy and I took his cock out of my mouth to say something at the worse time. He ended up giving me a surprised facial. I hate when he cums on my face. It's just so messy. So, I'm sitting there with this shocked expression and a face covered in cum and he snaps a picture! I posted it and got so many comments and tips about it asking to see Daddy and I in action. After a lot of begging, he agreed to film a video with me and we made a lot of money."

"The majority of it is going towards her college tuition. She starts at Elon University in the Fall."

"You're going to college?" I asked with wide eyes.

"Of course I am, mom. Just because I'm not living the life you planned out of me doesn't mean I don't still want to do something with my life."

"That brings us to the real issue," Dave said. "Why did you run away from home? You never told me."

Sarah frowned at me. "Mom and I...had a fight."

"I came home and caught you making out with my boyfriend Chris!"

"That's not what happened, mom!"

"He was in your room and you were kissing him! You even had your boobs out and was letting him feel them!"

"Ma'am," Dave said in a stern tone, "let her have her say."

Sarah glared at me. "Yeah, your creepy boyfriend Chris. I never liked him. You never noticed the way he looked at me. He was always staring at my tits. I guess he liked big ones."

While I had never received any complaints about my tits, it had annoyed me that Sarah's were bigger. "You little--"

"Ma'am," Dave said and I stopped.

"Anyway, I never liked that guy but I put up with him because of you. But that day, he showed up wanting some pussy but you weren't home yet. I told him you would probably be home soon and he said he would wait. Then, he came in my room. He said he wanted to talk to me. That we should get to know each other better since he might be my step-dad some day. I should have kicked him out but I didn't for your sake. But after we talked for a bit, he suddenly kissed me and pulled my top up! He robbed me of my first kiss and was probably going to take a lot more if you hadn't showed up just then. I thought you had come to save me. But he shoved me away and said I came onto him! And you called me a slut and slapped me!" She started to cry. "All my life, it had just been the two of us. Guys came and went and I learned to ignore them. And while you were strict and overprotective, I thought that meant you loved me. But that day, you took his word against me without hesitation. I was done. I was so angry that I didn't even pack anything. I got dressed and left with just my purse, my phone, and the clothes I was wearing. Daddy even paid for an Uber to take me to the airport. And you know the rest."

Seeing the pain in her eyes shook me to my core. "Sarah, I didn't... I--"

"Wait a sec," Steve interrupted. "Neither of you mentioned her father in all of this. Where was he at?"

"You know, you've never mentioned your father," Dave said. "Why is that?"

"That's a very good question," Sarah said still glaring at me.

I let out a long sigh. "I guess you should know. I...don't know who your father is."

"You don't know?! What do you mean you don't know?! I figured he was a dead beat but you don't know who he is?!"

"I was at a party for graduation and made a drunken mistake. I was in the middle of having sex with some guy I had just met when he roommate came in and made it a threesome. And because I wouldn't let him put it in my ass... Well, either one of them could be your father."

"So that's it. I'm a mistake. That's why you resented me."

"No! You weren't a mistake! I did a very stupid thing and my parents basically disowned me when they found out I was pregnant without knowing who the father was. But I loved you with all my heart. You're right. It was always the two of us. I should never have let some man get between us."

"Well, you did. And I'm never going back with you. After I graduate from college, Daddy and I will get married and I'll give him lots of babies!" Dave actually looked a bit embarrassed with that last part.

"I do still have one more question," Dave said. "How did you get here?"

"Oh, that was all me!" Steve said. "See, I'm the janitor at the law firm where Debra works. I had seen you before and imagine my surprise when I stumbled upon your Only Fans. When you offered to let me come fuck you, I told her she could tag along if she let me fuck her. And she did! I fucked her this morning in a broom closet. She sucked my cock and swallowed my cum. Then, I fucked her from behind. I even fucked her ass!" I turned beet red with anger and embarrassment.

"Oh wow, mom!" Sarah's eyes were still red from when she cried but now she looked very amused. "I've seen his cock. He has to be at least 10 inches. How'd you like taking that big, black cock in your ass?"

"Oh, she wasn't happy about it at first. But then she really liked it!"

"I didn't like anything about what you did to me!" I yelled defiantly.

"Oh, you didn't? Well, you definitely came when I fucked your pussy, And you came really loud when I fucked your ass! Now, as amusing as this whole thing has been, how about we get down to business?"

"Are you still up for this?" Dave asked Sarah.

She smiled at him brightly. "Oh definitely."

"Then give Leon a call."

"Yes, Daddy." She got up and went to another room.

Who is Leon?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)