Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 34 by AlternativeNSFWPersona AlternativeNSFWPersona

Do you find a way to lube your dick, or do you test how much damage Claire can take?

I'm sure she'll be fine...

"Relax, Claire, Able Master said you can take it!" you reassure her.

"Who the fuck is Able Master?" she asks.

"Uh, just my magical talking horse guide... You know what, just don't worry about it." The head of your rock-hard 10-inch tool is already poking at her backdoor. Holding her auburn hair firmly in your right hand and squeezing her left asscheek with your other, you start to press into her slowly but firmly.

"AAAAH FUCK, STOP!" Claire shouts in pain and fear, starting to thrash again. You continue to hold her between your thighs and yank her head back.

After considerable resistance your swollen dickhead pops through her sphincter. The anticipation of burying yourself in her ass to the hilt has put you in a frenzy. Impatiently you press on.

"AAAAHHH AAAAHHHH NO!" Claire pleads, shuddering and beginning to sob.

"Oh yes! Here we go, bitch!" you answer, attempting to thrust in deeper. But without lubrication there's too much resistance, and your cock only slides in another inch, starting to bend in the middle. You readjust you position, letting go of her hair to reinforce and steady your dick. You thrust again, lurching forward another inch.

"Oh please, David, let me suck your cock, let me gag and drool and hurl on your cock so you can fuck my ass easier!" she begs. With your hand no longer yanking her hair, she turns her head sideways to see you digging into her rectum, pain and fear on her face.

"I'm getting balls-deep in your asshole, slut, even if it takes one inch at a time!" You thrust again, and again, burying yourself a little deeper each time. With each lunge Claire lets out a wild scream, looking up at you with pleading eyes, tears washing her mascara over her cheeks. By now you're five inches in, with five more to go. Her ass is so tight already and it feels good, but you know it's only a taste of what's to come. You continue.

"AAAHHH OWWWWWW AHHHH!" she keeps crying out. It's starting to get annoying. Your attention turns to Tommy and Rachel.

It appears Rachel has finished probing for the last of your cum in her asshole; Tommy is now gripping her wrist and directing her to lick off the thick sticky strands between her fingers. "Good girl, Rach, swallow it all up," says Tommy, and Rachel makes a satisfying audible gulp. "Now you just need to gag on my cock a couple times and I'm ready to fuck that petite little teen ass of yours!" She gives a feeble nod of submission.

This gives you an idea. "Tommy, while you're at it, see if you can shut my stupid step-mom up," you say. "She's getting distracting."

He glances over and gets a mischievous grin. "Sure thing, David," he replies. He grabs Rachel by one of her ankles and drags her slimy ruined body off the bed, smearing fluids all along the way. Rachel doesn't even protest, completely resigned. He flips her on her stomach, grips her ass with both hands, positions her petite cheeks under Claire's sobbing face, and spreads her legs wide. He then kneels down in front of Rachel, grabs a fistful of her hair, and presses his hard cock into her gooey face. Once he is firmly planted in Rachel's thoroughly abused mouth, he leans forward to grab Claire's head and forces her face down into Rachel's ass. "Lick your daughter's asshole, bitch!" Tommy demands.

"MMMPH MMMMMM!" Claire mumbles with her mouth pressed in between Rachel's asscheeks. She wheezes as her nose barely has space to breath between her step-daughter's crack.

"Bury your tongue in there! Suck on it! Drool on it! Make her nice and wet for my cock!" Tommy commands. He presses Claire's face hard down into Rachel's ass, all the while bucking his cock hands-free in Rachel's throat.

"GUG GUG GUG!" Rachel gags and a whole new torrent of fluid spews from her mouth and nose, coating Tommy's balls and running down his thighs and her chin and neck and onto the carpet.

With Claire finally muffled, you return your focus to burying your cock deeper into her unwilling ass. With each thrust, Claire spasms and emits a pitiful "MMMMMPHH!" from between Rachel's asscheeks, until your balls press against the back of her squeezed-shut thighs. You reposition your legs to spread hers, and give one last lunge to bottom-out inside her, your balls slapping against her cunt. "MMMMMMMNNNNNPHH!" is the noise emitted from between Claire's mouth and Rachel's asshole.

Now that your thick ten-inch cock is thrust balls-deep in your step-mom's asshole, you start to hump vigorously. The heavy resistance means you're mostly pushing and pulling at her sphincter rather than sliding in and out; there's only an inch or so of give in either direction. Nevertheless, the tightness over the entire length of your cock feels excellent.

Meanwhile, Tommy continues to facefuck your sister while forcing Claire's face down into her asshole. Tommy's waist is drenched as a seemingly endless flow of saliva and phlegm continue to erupt from Rachel's mouth and nose. "Yeah, tongue-fuck that teen asshole, you dirty MILF!" he shouts in excitement. He spanks Rachel's ass a couple times while giving a couple particularly forceful thrusts into her throat.

Suddenly, Rachel's body shudders and spasms and her limbs flail. At first you think she's having another orgasm, but Tommy's cry of disgust indicates she must have puked again. "UGH! Not again you stupid bitch!" he shouts angrily and slaps her face a few times with his filthy dick. Rachel says nothing; she has almost completely degraded into nothing but a submissive teen cocksleeve. In fairness, Rachel got most of her stomach contents out of her system earlier and this new fluid is barely discernible from the regular cocktail of phlegm and saliva that she'd been spewing all day. Nevertheless, Tommy takes it as a sign that it's time to fuck a new Hole, that Holiest of Holies, her petite teen asshole, which he's fantasized about for most of his life.

Not even bothering to flip her around, Tommy crosses over to Rachel's rear, pushing Claire's face out of the way while you continue to hump her ass. Claire takes the opportunity to complain again. "Fuck, David, you're going to tear me apart!"

Tommy warns her, "Hey whore, David told me to shut you the fuck up, so either put that mouth to work on me, or keep it shut!" He kneels down between Claire's tear- and mascara-smeared face and Rachel's ravaged rear-end, lining his cock up with the teen girl's backdoor fuckhole. "Oh, how cute, you got your makeup all over your daughter's ass!" he remarks, before stabbing his swollen and thoroughly-lubricated member into Rachel's sphincter. Rachel can't help but cry out as Tommy aggressively spears his way deep into her asshole.

The speed and ease with which Tommy begins fucking your sister's ass stands in stark contrast to your own situation with Claire. You begin to thrust more aggressively yourself, greatly increasing her discomfort. She is **** to cry out in pain again. In retaliation, Tommy reaches behind himself to grab Claire's head and **** her face between his legs. "Start licking, MILF," he demands, and directs her to slather her tongue back and forth from the base of his cock as it escapes Rachel's ass, to his balls, to his taint, to his own asshole, and back the other way, not letting go of her hair.

While Tommy abuses your sister's ass and your step-mom's face, you grip Claire's ass with both hands, spreading her cheeks and bucking faster and faster deep inside her. You feel ecstatic tension rise up in your balls as you prepare for another supernatural orgasm. For a moment you consider spraying Claire's face or tits, but realize you might not even be able to pull out of her ass in time without your own cum as lube. You resolve to cum in her asshole until she is overflowing and you've deflated somewhat.

"OH YEAH, OH FUCK YEAH!" you howl as you finally climax and the first of several spurts of ejaculate fill the small remaining space in Claire's ass. Soon your cock begins to slide through her sphincter with improved ease. Thick gushes of your sticky cum begin to ooze out, dripping off you cock and over her taint, pussy, thighs, and all over the inside of her skirt. You finally finish and pull out after what seems like minutes, leaving a gaping red-raw asshole glistening in a glaze of semen. Your cock, too, seems to be a little red, though now quite moist. You're actually pretty impressed there's no blood -- Able Master wasn't wrong, the girls here are remarkably resilient!

As soon as you exit her, Claire immediately tries to crawl away, but Tommy still has a hold of her hair, forcing her to continue licking him. She tries to wrench free several times until he finally relents, too enthralled with Rachel's ass to pursue her. As she sits up, another torrent of your cum pours out her still-gaping ass. She gingerly pulls her black panties back up, and tries to cover and press against the stretched hole with her hand, but your juice continues to run past the cloth and her fingers and onto the floor. It honestly seems like almost a pint of semen.

"Oh fuck," she cries, panting and spasming in pain as her gaping raw sphincter twitches and pulses, trying to relax again. "How am I going to sit, let alone walk, after this? I'm going to be sore for days!" she complains, shooting you a hateful glare. Her body is glistening with sweat, her hair tussled, streams of tears and dark mascara smothering her cheeks. A tendril of saliva hangs from her chin after licking both Rachel and Tommy. Beneath her now-moist blouse you see her heaving breasts gently quiver and jiggle. She looks incredibly sexy on her knees like this. You have half a mind to ravage her again.

However, Tommy still isn't done. "Claire, I think your daughter wants to taste more of David's cum, get over here and give her some!" he says sinisterly while pounding Rachel's ass into the floor. "Let her eat it out of you," he insists. Claire simply stares at him in horror. "C'mon, bro, a little help?" he asks you. You give Claire a shrug, then grab her by the hair and drag her over to Rachel.

"Sis, now it's time to return the favor to Mom: eat that ass!" You bend Claire over in front of your sister, pulling up her skirt and removing her panties again. Without hesitation Rachel begins licking and slurping all the cum she can find, from Claire's thighs, her pussy, and her taint. Finally she begins running her wet lips around the rim of Claire's gape, before probing her tongue deep inside looking for more. "Fuck, you are one dirty little whore!" you remark. You're starting to get hard again already.

"Hey, UHN!, it's, UHN!, YOUR fantasy..." is her only reply while Tommy continues to pound away at her ass.

Suddenly, you hear a woman's voice call from down the hall: "HellooOOoo? David? Are you about finished? I've been waiting almost an hour!" That's right, you nearly forgot, it must be the mysterious visitor Claire mentioned!

But before you can think of how to respond, Tommy lets out a shout. "HUHNNNNNN FUCK YEAH I'M GONNA CUM!" He continues to growl as he grips Rachel's waist and begins rapidly and violently jackhammering into her asshole, sticky fluid leaving long tendrils between her butt and his pelvis each times he pulls away.

He assfucks her so hard that she can no longer keep her resigned composure and screams out in pain, "AAAIIIII! AAAAIIIIII! NNNNNnnnnnnmmmmmm...." before finally mumbling as she bites her lip, trying to control herself. The **** of Tommy's pounding pushes her forward so hard she rams face-first into Claire's still-gaping asshole, knocking her over.

Just then, you hear the bedroom door open.

How does Tommy finish, and who is the visitor?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)