I'm All In

Ethan woke up and rolled over, glancing at the clock, seeing it was the middle of the day. A glance over at Penny was all he needed to know she’d be out for at least another hour or two. Sliding out and bed and getting cleaned up, he texted Alice to see if she wanted to grab some food and bring it back for Penny. She replied back and the two met downstairs on their way to the dining hall.

“Sleep well? He greeted her.

“Mmn. Not really.” She shook her head. “Nightmares.”

“From the raid? Wanna talk about it?”

“Eh.. not really.” She ran a hand through her hair. “Knew that an actual fight was going to be gruesome, still wasn’t ready for it. Not much else to it.”

“Okay. Let me know if you change your mind. And don’t forget the counselors are on staff just for this sort of thing if it doesn't go away.”

“I’ll look into it. One night, er, a day of bad sleep isn't going to knock me down.”

They went through the line, busier than normal for a popular special, keeping the conversation casual. The walk back was quiet if not for the sound of snow crunching underfoot as they walked, the snow and wind having picked up while they were ordering.

As they got back to Ethan’s room, Alice took the opportunity to change the subject. “So dungeon sex, hmm?”

“It was amazing!” Penny chimed in, still wrapped up in blankets but clearly awake. “Is that chicken parmesan I smell? Please tell me you brought me some.

Ethan lifted the to-go tray up for her to see, setting it down. “Still warm. And yes, dungeon sex,” he said, sitting down to eat.

“Next time, I get dibs on Boosts.” Alice demanded. “I was haremette number two, that means I get to go second on dungeon sex!”

“Oooh, make him promise to give you dominant Ethan. It was hot.” Penny spoke up, lured out of the warm blankets by the scent of lunch, wearing nothing but a shirt and her panties.

Alice raised an eyebrow. Dominant Ethan, hmm? We don’t get to see him too often. What’d he do?”

“Made me finger myself while Mei watched. It was so hot.” Penny responded around a mouthful of food. “Did the thing where he made me say out loud what I wanted. I surprised even myself how wet I was. I had planned to have him play with my hair the same way he did with Mei, having the script flipped on me made it so much better.”

Alice put on her best impression of Penny, puppy dog eyes and all. “Will you play with my hair, Ethan? I’m just so empty of essence and I need a refill so badly.”

Ethan stood and moved onto his bed, lounging against the headboard. He spread his legs, patting the bed while looking at Alice. A quick nod of his head was all that was needed for her to begin moving, crawling onto the bed. He grabbed her, positioning her much like he had Penny in the dungeon.

The air became thick with tension as Alice and Penny met each other's eyes, both knowing where this was heading.

“Touch yourself, Alice,” Ethan’s voice cut through the silence. His hands tightened on her hips as he pulled her tight against him. “Show us how much you want this.”

Alice hesitated, surprised at how quickly the moment had gone from teasing Ethan to being ordered to touch herself.

“Touch yourself.”

Alice’s eyes shot back to Penny, surprised as the command came from her, not Ethan.

Penny repeated herself. “Touch yourself.”

Ethan’s hands slid downwards, his thumbs sliding into her waistband and tugging downwards. Alice lifted her hips, allowing him to slide her leggings and panties down together over her thighs. Penny climbed onto the bed, reaching forward to help Ethan undress her.

“Touch yourself.” Ethan ordered, his hands tracing the bare skin along outside of her things.

She hesitated again, but Ethan and Penny’s tones left no room for argument. Her heart was pounding in her chest as she moved her hand down her stomach. She let out a held breath as her fingertips brushed against her lips.

“That’s it,” he whispered into her ear. His hands began to slide up her sides, under her shirt, pulling it up and over her head. He pushed her forward, her bra quickly being undone. Penny grabbed at it, throwing it to the side.

His hand cupped her left breast, fingers pinching her nipple lightly. She gasped and he pulled him back against him, tight. “I didn’t say stop,” he murmured, his right hand guiding hers back to her pussy.

A whimper escaped her lips as her fingers slid down, spreading her lips. She began to run the finger up and down, teasing her clit, Ethan’s breath on her neck sending shivers down her spine.

Penny, kneeling before them, placed her hands on Alice’s legs, beginning to slowly move them up. “Look at me.” Penny commanded, her tone matching Ethan’s. Alice obeyed, staring directly into Penny’s eyes as the hands continued moving upwards.

Penny pulled Alice’s knees apart, forcing her to spread herself open.

“You like this, don’t you? Ethan asked her. “Spreading yourself, letting Penny see you. Letting us watch as you touch yourself.”

Quick, fast nods were all Alice could manage. She pushed herself harder back against him, feeling his hardness pressing against her.

He pushed his hand down, pushing her hand out of the way. He slid a single finger between her lips discovering how wet she was. “Why don’t you tell Penny what I’ve found, Alice?”

“I-I’m so wet, Penny.”

His left hand moved from her breast up to cusp her jaw, turning her face upwards to look at Penny. “Tell us why.” He ordered.

“B-because you’re watching me touch myself.” She whispered.

Ethan slid a finger deep inside her as she finished speaking, causing her to suck in a large breath. He pulled it out, drawing it upwards to her clit, circling it, Alice shivering as he did.

“I didn’t say stop.” He reminded her.

She reached back down, sliding her own finger inside her while Ethan continued to circle her clit in a slow and steady pattern.

Penny pulled her shirt off, leaving her in nothing but her panties. She moved up the bed on her knees until her thighs were pressed against Alice’s, holding her legs open. She leaned forward, letting her breath play along Alice’s neck as Ethan still cupped her jaw, pointing her face upwards.

Alice shivered again as Penny traced her tongue along the outside of her ear. “You love it, don’t you? Being used to put on a show for us.” she whispered directly into her ear.

“Yesss,” Alice let out in a hiss.

Penny moved back up, her hands replacing Ethan’s holding Alice’s face up towards her. Penny leaned down and kissed her, soft for a moment before the need Penny felt took over. The press of the kiss pushed Alice against Ethan and she squirmed, the feel of him pressing against her driving her wild. Penny broke the kiss only to trail her mouth down Alice's neck. Penny continued kissing and licking as she made her way further down. Ethan pulled both of Alice’s arms back, forcing her chest forward towards Penny.

All Alice could do was moan as Penny began to tease her nipple with flicks of her tongue, held as she was by the two of them. She felt exposed, as if she was on display for their use, theirs to use as they pleased. Penny continued, squeezing and licking her way down Alice’s body.

Alice’s heart had never beat louder in her chest than it did as Penny’s kisses trailed down her stomach. They shifted Alice forward together, Ethan pulling her back, his hands around her upper arms, until she was laying down atop him. Penny **** her legs wide, sliding her hands up the back of Alice’s thighs to push her legs up and into the air.

For a moment they left her there, spread, exposed, laying completely open for them. Another moment. Then another. “Pleaseeeeeee,” she begged them. “Penny Pleaseee.”

Penny pressed her tongue against Alice’s clit as she heard her name being called. The moan she drew from Alice drove her further forward. Penny continued lower, her tongue exploring Alice. Her tongue moved with intent, tracing slow, wet circles around Alice’s clit before dipping lower to tease at her entrance. Alice’s hips bucked instinctively, her body wanting more, but Ethan’s firm grip on her arms kept her pinned against his chest.

“Fuck, Penny, don’t stop,” Alice gasped, her voice trembling. Her head tilted back against Ethan’s shoulder, her breaths coming in short, ragged bursts.

Penny glanced up as she pulled back just enough to speak. “You taste so fucking good, Alice. I could do this all night.” She dove back in, sucking on Alice’s clit while her fingers trailed along the inside of her thighs, teasing the sensitive skin.

Ethan let out a short laugh, his breath hot on her neck. “Look at her. She can’t get enough of you. You’re going to cum for us, aren’t you? Right on her tongue.”

Alice whimpered at his words, her body shuddering under the effects of his words and Penny’s mouth. “Yes, oh god, yes, I’m going to cum for you.” She stammered, straining against Ethan’s hold.

Penny’s tongue flicked faster now, up and down across her clit. She pressed two fingers inside Alice, curling them up to press upwards.

“Ohhh, I’m gonna cum, I’m gonna cum, oh please, oh please, oh pleaseee.” Her body strained, her hips pressing upwards against Penny’s tongue and fingers.

“Cum for us, Alice,” Penny urged. “Let go for me, let me feel it.”

Her moans grew louder, her body growing tense.

“Do it. Cum for her. Now.” Ethan commanded.

That was all it took. Alice’s entire body shook as her orgasm hit, a cry tearing out of her as she came. Penny didn’t let him, her tongue and fingers working Alice as she continued to shake, drawing waves of pleasure from her. Penny crawled up her body until she pressed a slow kiss against her lips, letting Alice taste herself. “Good girl,” Penny murmured against her lips.

Alice lay panting, eyes closed and still held tight by Ethan, her legs still held up spread in the air by Penny. She felt the two of them moving, not paying attention as she caught her breath.

It was when Ethan lifted his hips up, her along with them, that she finally took notice. Penny pulled down his pants and Alice felt it as his hard member pressed hot against her. He lowered himself back down, bringing his lips close to her ear. “My turn now,” he growled, his voice thick with arousal. “Are you ready for more, Alice?”

Still panting, she managed a weak nod, her body already aching for what she knew was coming.

Ethan slid her sideways off of him, depositing her on her back. He moved upwards, pulling his shirt off as he moved to take Penny’s place between her thighs.

Alice’s breath caught as Ethan settled between her thighs, his bare skin radiating heat against hers. Penny stretched out besides her, her fingers slowly tracing patterns over Alice’s stomach, dipping lower to touch at her inner thighs. The touches sent shivers up her spine, her body still sensitive from her earlier release.

Ethan’s eyes locked onto Alice’s as his cock, hard and heavy, brushed against her entrance for the first time, the heat of it making her gasp. He didn’t push in, though. Instead he slid his length along her wetness, his shaft sliding along her clit with each slow movement. Alice’s hips twitched, a small whine escaping her lips.

“Look at her, Ethan,” Penny murmured, her voice soft as her fingers circled Alice’s nipple, pinching lightly. “She’s so fucking **** for you. Aren’t you?”

Alice bit her lip, nodding, her hands gripping the sheets beneath her. “Yes.. I need it,” she whispered, her voice trembling with want.

Ethan’s jaw clenched, his control evident as he continued to tease her, dragging himself against her slick folds. He paused, his expression softening. Leaning down, his forearms bracing on either side of her, his face close enough that she could feel his breath on her lips. “Alice,” he said quietly, his tone shifting to something gentler, “this.. this wasn’t planned. We didn’t expect things to go this way. I need to know you’re sure about this. That you’re okay with us, with me.”

Alice’s heart stuttered at the tenderness in his voice. She reached up, her fingers brushing against his cheek, “I’m sure, Ethan. I want this. I want.. both of you. It feels right.”

Penny’s hand slid up to cup Alice’s face, turning her head slightly so their eyes met. “We love you, Alice,” Penny said softly, her usual playful edge replaced by raw emotion.

Ethan nodded, his thumb brushing over Alice’s hip. “I love you, Alice.

Alice felt a warmth rise in her chest, the feeling mixing with her need for them both. Her eyes flicked between them, seeing the sincerity in both of their faces. “I love you too,” she breathed, her voice steady despite the emotion swelling inside her. “Both of you. I’ve never felt.. anything like this. I’m in. I’m all in.”

Ethan’s lips curled into a small smile, and he leaned down to kiss her, slow and deep, pouring everything into it. Penny pressed a kiss to Alice’s shoulder, her hand sliding down to intertwine their fingers.

Ethan pulled back, meeting her eyes again. “Tell me what you want, Alice,” he said, his voice low, his cock still pressed against her, teasing. She could feel his head against her opening, knowing all she needed to do was ask for it.

Alice’s breath caught, her body aching. She squeezed Penny’s hand, her other reaching to grip Ethan’s shoulder. “I want you to fuck me, Ethan. Please. I need you inside me.”

Ethan let out a low groan at her words, his need for her clear in his gaze.

He pushed in slowly, just the tip at first, letting her adjust to the stretch. Alice moaned, her head tipping back as she felt him, hot and thick, filling her inch by inch. Penny’s fingers found Alice’s clit, circling gently as Ethan eased deeper. “That’s it,” Penny whispered, her lips brushing Alice’s ear. “Take him. Let him feel how much you want this.”

Alice’s nails dug into Ethan’s shoulder, her other hand clutching Penny’s as Ethan bottomed out. “You’re so fucking tight,” he gasped, holding still for a moment, letting her body acclimate to him.

“More,” Alice pleaded, her voice ****, her hips shifting, begging him. “Please, Ethan, fuck me.”

Ethan didn’t need any more encouragement. He pulled out almost completely before thrusting back in, setting a slow, deliberate pace that had Alice gasping with each stroke. Penny’s fingers kept working her clit, the dual sensation driving Alice closer to the edge again.

“Look at you, taking him so well,” Penny purred, her free hand roaming over Alice’s chest, squeezing and teasing.

Ethan began to move fast, his hips snapping harder now, the sound of skin against skin filling the room. Alice’s moans grew louder, her body arching beneath him as the intensity built. “I’m.. I’m gonna come again,” she whimpered, her eyes squeezing shut.

“Do it,” Ethan grunted, breathing heavy, his voice rough as he thrust deeper. “Come on my cock, Alice. Let us feel it.”

Penny pressed down harder on Alice’s clit, her lips finding Alice’s neck, sucking at the sensitive skin. “Come for us,” she urged.

Alice’s body obeyed, shaking under them as her second orgasm ripped through her. Her cry was primal, her walls clenching tight around Ethan, drawing a guttural moan from him. He slowed his thrusts, riding out her climax, his breathing heavy. His control was slipping. The way she squeezed him, so tight and wet, was pushing him to the edge.

“Fuck, Alice,” he growled as he pulled her hips closer, thrusting deep again. “You feel too fucking good. I’m not gonna last much longer.”

Penny smirked, her fingers still teasing Alice’s clit, keeping her sensitive and squirming. “Go on,” she whispered, kissing Alice’s neck. “Make him lose it. Let him fill you up.”

Alice, still breathless, moaned at the words, her hips raising to meet his thrusts. “Do it, Ethan,” she whispered “Come inside me. I want it.”

Her words snapped something in him. Ethan’s grip on her hips tightened, his thrusts turning harder. “Shit, Alice, you’re gonna make me-” He cut off, slamming into her one last time as his orgasm hit. His cock pulsed inside her, hot and thick, filling her with his cum. Each spurt made him shudder, his head dropping to her shoulder as he rode out his orgasm, his breath hot against her skin.

“Fuck yes,” Penny murmured, her hand sliding down to where Ethan and Alice were joined, rubbing gently as if to feel the heat of it. “Look at you, taking all of him. So fucking hot.”

Ethan stayed buried inside Alice for a moment longer, catching his breath, his hands still firm on her hips. Finally, he pulled out slowly, a mix of their fluids spilling from her, and he groaned at the sight. “Goddamn, Alice,” he muttered. “That was.. fuck.”

Alice lay there, her body still buzzing as she felt the warmth of him inside her. Penny’s smirk turned into something hungrier as she shifted, sliding down Alice’s body. She positioned herself between Alice’s thighs, her hands pushing them apart as she looked at the mess Ethan left behind. “Damn, look at this. He made such a mess of you.”

Alice gasped as Penny’s tongue flicked out, lapping at her sensitive folds, cleaning up the cum that dripped from her. The sensation was almost too much, her body jerking at the contact. “Penny.. oh fuck,” Alice whimpered, her hands gripping the sheets.

Penny’s tongue delved deeper, licking and sucking at the mixture of Ethan’s cum and Alice’s wetness. “Tastes so fucking good,” she muttered, her voice muffled as she worked, her hands gripping Alice’s thighs to keep her still. “Can’t get enough of this. You and him together? Fucking perfect.”

Alice’s head tipped back, moans spilling from her lips as Penny’s tongue worked her over. “Too much.. but don’t stop, I’m getting close again,” she panted, her body trembling under the ****.

Penny pressed two fingers into Alice, sliding them in and out, searching for every drop of Ethan’s cum she could find. “Cum for me, Alice, one more time,” Penny got out between licks of Alice’s clit.

Alice’s thighs closer around Penny’s head as she continued her ****, Alice moving closer and closer as she began to cum for the third time. Her mouth opened, soundless, as she came. Her body convulsed, shaking as Penny didn’t let up, her fingers and lips pushing Alice higher and higher.

Penny slowed her ministrations as Alice came down from the high, easing her back down. When Alice finally relaxed her body, her thighs falling away from where they had held Penny, she reached down and pulled Penny up into a deep kissing. “I love you, I love you both.” She whispered.

They all collapsed on the bed, Alice sandwiched between them. Penny and Ethan continued tracing soft patterns on Alice’s skin as they enjoyed the moment.

“You okay?” Ethan asked, his tone softer now, checking in.

Alice nodded, a small, satisfied smile on her lips despite the over stimulation. “More than okay. That was… incredible.”

Ethan laughed. “Good, because Penny still needs a turn.”