Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by Ihatethisshit Ihatethisshit

What next?

Humiliation

The night wore on, and the intimacy shared between Ava, James, and Tom left a lingering sense of connection and anticipation. As the moonlight filtered through the curtains, casting a soft glow across the room, Ava and James lay entwined, their breathing gradually evening out.

Tom, having cleaned up and composed himself, quietly stepped into the room. His presence was greeted with knowing, almost predatory smiles from Ava and James. They had all crossed a threshold together, and the unspoken bond was palpable.

Ava reached out her hand to Tom, inviting him to join them on the bed. "Come here," she said softly, her eyes gleaming with a mix of affection and something more. "We want you with us."

Tom hesitated briefly, then moved to the bed, lying down beside Ava. She nestled between the two men, feeling a profound sense of comfort and belonging. James' hand rested on her hip, his thumb gently stroking her skin.

"How are you feeling?" James asked, his voice tender but with a hint of something more.

Tom took a deep breath, gathering his thoughts. "I'm... good. More than good, actually. This was everything I hoped it would be and more."

Ava smiled, her fingers lightly tracing patterns on Tom's chest. "I'm glad. We wanted this to be special for all of us."

James nodded in agreement, but there was a glint in his eye. "It was. And I think it brought us closer in ways we didn't expect."

For a while, they lay there in a comfortable silence, the only sounds being their steady breaths and the distant hum of the night outside. Eventually, Ava broke the silence, her voice soft but with an edge.

"I think we should talk about what happened earlier," she said, glancing between Tom and James. "About the things we said."

Tom's heart skipped a beat, but he nodded. "Yeah, I think we should."

James squeezed Ava's hand gently, encouraging her to continue. "We didn't mean to make you uncomfortable, Tom," she said. "But it was clear you were really enjoying yourself."

Tom shook his head, a small smile forming on his lips. "No, it didn't. Actually, it was... exciting. Hearing you talk about me like that, about my size... it turned me on."

James looked at Tom with a mixture of curiosity and something darker. "So, you like being humiliated? It excites you?"

Tom nodded, feeling a mix of shame and excitement. "Yes, it does. I know it's strange, but it's something I've always felt, deep down."

Ava leaned in, her voice a seductive whisper. "It's not strange, Tom. But let's be honest, you know you're not enough for me in that way. James satisfies me in ways you never could."

Tom's eyes widened, his pulse quickening. The sting of her words mixed with the thrill of his arousal. "I... I know."

James smirked, his hand moving to rest on Tom's leg, his touch both comforting and patronizing. "It's pathetic, really. But if that's what you want, we can make you feel as small as you really are."

Tom's face flushed with a mix of humiliation and excitement. "Thank you," he whispered, barely able to meet their eyes.

Ava's eyes gleamed with a predatory satisfaction. "Good. Because you're going to watch us, Tom. You're going to see just how much more of a man James is compared to you."

Tom nodded, feeling a deep sense of submission. "Yes, Ava."

James leaned in, his voice dripping with condescension. "And you're going to stay right there, like the pathetic little cuck you are."

Tom's breath hitched, his arousal intensifying with every humiliating word. He felt a profound sense of isolation, yet the degradation fueled his desire.

As Ava and James began to kiss passionately once more, Tom found himself unable to look away. His hand moved to his erection, the shame and pleasure intertwining in a heady mix. The sounds of their lovemaking filled the room, each moan and gasp a reminder of his own inadequacy.

Ava glanced over at Tom, her eyes alight with cruel amusement. "See, Tom? This is what real pleasure looks like. Something you'll never be able to give me."

Tom's strokes quickened, the humiliation and isolation pushing him to the brink. He watched as James took Ava with a confidence and power that he could never match. The sight of them together, the sounds of their pleasure, drove him to the edge.

But just as he was about to climax, Ava's voice cut through the haze of his arousal. "Stop, Tom."

Tom's hand froze, his body trembling with unfulfilled desire. "What?"

Ava's smile was cold and commanding. "You don't get to cum, Tom. Not tonight. Just watch and suffer."

Tom's eyes filled with a mix of desperation and submission. "Please, Ava..."

James laughed, his tone mocking. "You really are pathetic, aren't you? Begging to come like that."

Ava's expression softened briefly, but her voice remained firm. "No, Tom. You don't deserve it. You're going to sit there and watch us, and you're going to stay hard for us, but you won't come."

Tom's breath was ragged, his arousal a painful ache. "Yes, Ava."

As Ava and James resumed their passionate lovemaking, Tom watched, his body tense with unfulfilled need. Every thrust, every moan, every gasp was a reminder of his own inadequacy and his place in their dynamic. Ava and James grew louder, their sounds more animalistic and raw, each cry and groan a knife to Tom's pride.

Ava's eyes met Tom's, her gaze filled with both dominance and a strange tenderness. "This is your place, Tom. Watching us, serving us. You'll learn to love it."

Tom nodded, tears of frustration and desire mingling in his eyes. "Yes, Ava. I understand."

James' movements became more intense, his groans louder and more primal. "Ava, you're incredible," he panted, his voice thick with passion.

Ava's responses were equally loud, her moans filling the room. "Yes, James! Just like that!"

Tom's body trembled with unfulfilled desire, the sounds of their pleasure driving him to the brink of madness. He watched as James reached his climax, his body tensing and his groans turning into a triumphant roar.

As James finished, Ava's eyes locked onto Tom's with a commanding look. "Come here, Tom."

Tom crawled closer, his heart pounding. "Yes, Ava?"

Ava's voice was firm and unyielding. "You're going to clean me up. Lick James' cum off of me."

Tom's eyes widened, a mix of humiliation and arousal washing over him. "Please, Ava..."

James laughed, his tone still mocking. "Do it, Tom. Show us how pathetic you really are."

Tom's breath hitched, his submission complete. "Yes, Ava."

He lowered his head, his tongue tentatively reaching out to lick the remnants of James' climax from Ava's skin. The taste was a bitter reminder of his place in their dynamic, the ultimate act of submission and humiliation.

Ava's hand rested on Tom's head, guiding him as he cleaned her. "Good boy, Tom. This is where you belong."

Tom's heart swelled with a mix of shame and fulfillment. "Thank you, Ava."

As the night wore on, Tom continued to serve them, his body trembling with unfulfilled desire. The humiliation and isolation were intense, but they only deepened his submission and his bond to Ava and James.

In the aftermath, as Ava and James held each other, Tom lay apart, feeling both isolated and strangely fulfilled.

And for our next act

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)