Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by ManRayMansker ManRayMansker

What's next?

How about both

In the master bedroom was set up like a cheap porn studio again harsh ring light, phone on tripod, laptop playing side-by-side comparisons. You were naked except for Nick’s old college jersey draped over your shoulders, Erin’s tiny pink thong barely containing your painfully hard cock.

The printed AI measurement report was taped to the mirror: Nick 5.2 inches, thick, impressive girth. You 3.1 inches, thin, cute little button.You stared straight into the camera, voice shaking with shame as you stroked your tiny prick.

“Five-point-two inches… that’s what my stepson brings to the table. And it dwarfs my pathetic little 3.1-inch nub. Look at it. My cock looks like a sad little boy’s dick next to his. Erin’s going to laugh when she finally sees what a tiny-clitted stepdad she’s getting…”

You were on all fours, ass up toward the camera, sliding a finger into yourself while moaning about how Nick’s “big” 5.2 would stretch Erin in ways your miniature dick never could, when the door swung open.

Tawny stepped inside, took one look at the scene, and burst out laughing. “Holy shit, babe. You finally understand that you are that small.”

Your face burned crimson. Your tiny cock twitched and leaked in Erin’s thong.

Tawny locked the door, stripped off her top, and took full control. “Camera stays on. We’re making this one extra humiliating. Your fans deserve to see exactly how tiny you are compared to average.”She dragged you in front of the ring light and made you stand at full attention, hands behind your head. Tawny held the ruler right against your throbbing 3.1 inches.“Three… point… one,” she announced loudly, tapping the head of your cock with the ruler so it bobbed pathetically. “Fully erect. Look how short and skinny it is. A respectable average of 5.2 looks like a real cock next to this little button. Yours barely has a head.”She made you repeat degrading lines on camera while she slapped your tiny dick lightly with the ruler: “My stepson’s 5.2-inch cock completely dwarfs my pathetic 3.1-inch baby dick.” Tawny gasped, “you used AI to compare yourself to my son, well this does remind me of when I could get a real dick from my sorry ex-husband. So what do you say for yourself comparing yourself to Nick?”

“I could never satisfy Erin the way Nick can with his superior size.”

“I’m just the tiny-dicked stepdad who gets hard watching his stepson outclass him.”

Tawny escalated beautifully. She put you on your back in a humiliating folded position knees by your ears, tiny cock pointing straight up at your own face. She straddled your mouth reverse, grinding her wet pussy on your tongue while she jerked your miniature shaft between two fingers.

“Two fingers is all it takes,” she mocked for the camera, easily circling your entire length and girth. “Nick’s 5.2 would fill my hand. This sad little thing is basically a big clit with a pulse. I bet Erin’s already stretched out from riding him — she probably doesn’t even feel you when you try to fuck her.”

She edged you mercilessly. Every time your tiny cock started to throb and leak, she stopped, gave it a few sharp slaps, and made you thank her while staring into the lens.“Thank you for exposing my tiny 3.1-inch dick.”

“Thank you for reminding me about my past with cocks; I bet my cocky son owns Erin.”

“I’m smaller than my own stepson, and I love it.”

The finale was pure degradation. Tawny made you put on Erin’s thong as a mask again, nose buried in the crotch, while you desperately humped the 5.2-inch dildo she’d bought specifically because it matched Nick’s measurements.

She sat on your face and narrated every second:“Look at him go. Fucking a dildo the same size as his stepson’s cock because his own is too small to matter. Beg for it, tiny. Beg the camera to cum while admitting Nick’s 5.2 is bigger and better in every way.”

When she finally allowed it, you came hands-free pathetic, watery spurts shooting onto your own chest and chin while Tawny laughed and milked the last drops with two fingers. She scooped up your load and fed it to you on camera.“Swallow your shame, little one. Good tiny-dicked husbands eat every drop while dreaming about superior cock.”She kissed your cum-smeared lips afterward, eyes sparkling.

“Title this one ‘Stepdad’s 3.1 Inch Pathetic Nub vs Step-son’s 5.2 — Full Humiliation.’ Post it raw. They’re going to destroy you in the comments.”

Four days later, the video had blown up even harder than the last one. The comments were savage endless jokes about your “micro dick,” comparisons to Nick’s “actually decent” 5.2, and demands for more public exposure.You were in the kitchen trying to act normal when the doorbell rang. Tawny answered with a grin.

Erin’s cheerful voice carried down the hall. “Hi! I brought some of the sorority girls. We were talking OnlyFans strategies and side hustles. Thought my future father-in-law could give us some very specific tips on humiliating content that actually performs…”Four gorgeous mid-twenties women followed Erin into the living room. The curvy brunette and the athletic redhead with the wicked smirk stood out immediately.Erin smiled at you sweetly. “Girls, this is him! He’s been doing some super honest, super **** size comparison content lately. We figured he’d be the perfect person to ask about scripting tiny-dick humiliation scenes.”

The brunette’s eyes flicked down toward your crotch for a deliberate second, lips curving into a knowing smile. “We saw the newest video. That measurement scene was brutal. So… be honest with us. How does it feel knowing your stepson’s 5.2 completely dwarfs your little prick?”All four young women stared at you expectantly, amused and intrigued. Tawny leaned in the doorway behind them, mouthing silently with pure delight: Tell them how small you are, tiny.Your face burned hotter than the ring light ever could. Your pathetic little cock was already twitching helplessly in your pants.

This conversation was about to get much more embarrassing.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)