Honest [Allure +3, Audacity +1]

The women line up with their asses out for you, giggling. Riley turned the music down a bit, but the beat still adds to the mood. You take a slow breath, letting your gaze sweep over the beautiful butts before you. Each one is impressive in its own way. Of course, these are women in their prime years, but genetics and youth still needs effort for this result to show. These girls have spent hours in the gym, all of them, and it shows.

As if you were a food critic, you run your fingers lightly over their smooth curves, feeling their weight, their firmness. Slapping gently and watching the jiggle.

"First of all, I have to say—you've all done an incredible job. Each of these is remarkable, and it was genuinely hard to decide. But a winner must be named."

"Tatiana, your ass is beautiful - full, well-shaped and with a nice bounce. It's an amazing effort, and it really shows. I’m giving you an 8- no! An 8.5 out of 10."

Tatiana gives a small nod, arms crossed. "Fair score. I’ll take it." Her voice is casual, but there’s a flicker of something else—a quiet respect—in the way she looks at you.

Next up, Eve. Again, you press your hand against her smooth ass, feeling her warm flesh in your palms.

"This one is a work of delicate art. Your skin is unbelievably silky, and the shape is amazing. It’s almost perfect. You get a 9/10."

Eve tilts her head, running a hand over her ass. "Silky smooth and shapely, huh?" she muses, lips quirking into a half-smile. "You actually made an effort, I appreciate that."

Riley, your wife. You know how much this means to her, how hard she’s worked, especially after struggling with weight for most of her early twenties. You meet her eyes and offer a reassuring smile. "Riley, what you’ve achieved is nothing short of impressive. Your ass is nice and big, but well-rounded, and your effort really shines through. 8.5/10."

Riley exhales, glancing at you with something softer in her eyes. "I know you wouldn’t sugarcoat it for me," she says, almost to herself. "That means more than the score."

Finally, you turn to Chloe. From the moment you laid eyes on it, you knew hers was something special. You cup the hefty, perfectly round bubble butt, marveling at its sheer size and fullness. It has the ideal balance of firmness and bounce, and the shape absolutely flawless. You exhale in admiration.

"Chloe, this… is perfection. The plumpness, the roundness, the sheer presence—it’s everything a woman's ass should be. 10 out of 10. Flawless."

Chloe beams, practically glowing with satisfaction. "Perfect score, huh? Can’t argue with the evidence." She wiggles her ass, and then, just for a second, gives you a look that shows a certain affection for your genuine rating.

They don’t say it outright, but it’s there - in the way they linger, the way their smiles last a little longer than expected. They admire your honesty, even if they’ll never admit it.