He wants his dick back right now

"Sorry, but I want to know that my penis is safe first. Where is it?" Andrew pressed.

"Can't this wait until after I go pee?" Lisa asked.

"No!" Andrew said, getting frustrated. "I want to know where it is."

Lisa shifted her weight again. "Fine," was all she said as she reached under her skirt. Andrew was shocked as felt his dick slide out from the warm wet place it had been the past several hours. "Sectunisco," Lisa muttered. Andrew felt the still unfamiliar pinching feeling before Lisa pulled her hand out from under her clothes. In it was Andrew's erect cock, coated in a translucent white sheen of girl goo.

"What the fuck!?" was all Andrew could say as he took it back from her. "Was my penis... inside of you!?"

Lisa looked away from him slightly, as if avoiding his eyes. "Yeah," she said, trying to remain stoic. "I had it stuck to my panties... for safe keeping."

"Safe keeping?" Andrew repeated. "Safe keeping!? I was inside you!"

"Yeah, I didn't want to let it out of my sight, so I figured it would be safe there."

Andrew facepalmed with his free hand. Another knock at the door put a stop to their conversation. "Come in," Andrew said again. In came Katie, closing the door behind herself.

"What's up?" she asked before seeing the wet phallus in Andrew's hand. She immediately looked away. "Oh, uhh..." was all she said before falling silent.

"Sorry," Andrew apologized as he went over to his desk and dropped his slick cock inside one of the drawers. "So..."