“You could turn me into a virgin again” she said, smiling up to him. “Someone who’s never seen a penis in her life.”
“Yeah, like that would work.” He replied, sarcastically. “You and I have been experimenting since what, you were thirteen? Sure, we’ve never had sex but you’ve seen my cock plenty of times. And then there’s your ex Francis-”
“That’s why you should try it!” she exclaimed, cutting him off. “I can’t just magically become a virgin again!” She gave him a mischievous grin, edging him on.
He thought about it, wondering if it would work. It seemed obvious enough. Then again, so had all of his other attempts. He sighed, half expecting it to not work, and ensured he had a nice handful of pussy before speaking.
“Amy, you’re a virgin. You’ve never had a boyfriend. Heck, you’ve never seen, let alone fucked a cock in your life.”
The siblings looked at each other, John's gentle massage on her pussy being the only motion between them. Seconds passed before Amy blushed and looked away, avoiding her brother’s gaze.
“Okay John,” she whispered, “you’re more gullible than I thought. You of all people should know I’m a virgin.”
He stopped masturbating her, small amounts of anger coursing through him. “Okay, now you’re just making fun of me Amy!”
She held up her hands defensively, trying to calm him down. “Sorry, I had too! It’s just so unbelievable. I do believe you, truly I do. But come on, a wish that allows you to change reality as you please? You have to admit that’s pushing it a little. I mean-“
He gently rubbed her clit, causing her to stop and yelp. He kept his ministrations to a gentle rub, pleasuring her with nothing more than a slight tingle. “How about this then? You’ve always been exclusively attracted to me; no other guys appeal to you.”
He spoke as though he was trying to prove a point. Amy simply looked away, defeated.
“John, you’ve known that for years.” She sighed, the stress of John's wish overwhelming the pleasure he was giving her. She reached down between her legs and grabbed his hand, telling him to stop. He pulled his hand away, drying it on her sheets.
The siblings stared at each other, unsure how to proceed.
“Gah, fuck this!” John suddenly yelled, frustrated with it all. He grabbed her leg in a flash of anger. “We should just forget all about my power for now and-”
He was about to say more, but something made him stop. It felt like he was forgetting something important; something that had bothered him all day. He shook his head, bringing his attention back to his near-naked sister beneath him. Whatever it was, it could surely wait.
He had more pressing matters on his hands. Like his sister’s ever wet pussy.
