Chapter 21
by namenotfound
Who does he pick?
He picks Amy
Your heart sinks at Olivia's words, It's suddenly become clear that you should probably be focusing more on what's currently happening.
"Wha-?!" You begin to exclaim, but Olivia squeezes you hard, bringing you even closer to her.
"Don't be rude." She says in a sweet, yet stern voice. "Give him time to think." You're not exactly sure why, but you listen to her and continue staying quiet.
"Hmm, this is a really tough choice." Jason says, eyeing the three of you. He looks happy, but calm and casual, like this is something that happens to him on a regular basis. He continues staring for a moment, appearing to be truly thinking over his decision, before pointing his finger. "Her." He says, pointing directly at Amy.
"Yay! Amy shout excitedly, before rushing over to him.
Olivia moves in closer to you, wrapping both arms around you as she hugs you from behind.
"Don't take it personal baby." She says lightly in your ear. "He didn't pick me either." You begin to say something in response, but find yourself distracted by the sight of Amy suddenly removing all of her cloths. She stands in front of Jason in all of her glory. He looks at her, his smile getting wider as he sets down his drink. He doesn't appear to be at all fazed by her caged cock, making you think that your are the only one who has been kept out of the loop on all of this.
Jason begins to sit up, but Amy leans in pushing him back.
"Let me get you ready first." She says as she crouches down. You watch as if in a single motion she yanks his pants off and down to his ankles. Now in full sight, is his clearly erect cock. As much as you think about looking away, you find yourself staring at it, the main thing you notice is it's size. It stands tall and thick, it would no doubt dwarf yours even if you were currently able to display it. Amy stares at it as well, but she's looking absolutely giddy. She takes a second to admire it before brining her hand up and gently stroking his balls. They are also rather big, and appear to be heavy. Amy plays with them a little as Jason breaths in deep. Amy smiles as she brings her head down, she caresses his balls with her tongue before slowly dragging it up to the tip. You then watch as she opens her mouth, brining the tip inside before pushing her head down, engulfing more than half of it in an instant. Her head then begins bobbing up and down.
"She's an expert at blowjobs." Olivia says to you, resting her head on your shoulder. "But I'm sure I don't have to tell you that."
Once again, you find yourself with the opportunity to start asking Olivia questions, but you also seem to be unable to pull yourself away from the sight in front of you. You watch Amy move her head expertly, clearly controlling the speed and amount she takes in. You only hear slight gagging as she brings herself fully down to the base.
"Ya know, I've never been the biggest fan of giving head." Olivia says as her hands begin to slide down your body. "But she fucking loves it." Her hands squeeze your thighs as she holds them just under your dress. "I guess some girls just love the feeling of having a warm, think, cock slide down there throat." Her hands begins rubbing your thighs up and down, bringing them farther up each time. "You can imagine it. Do you think you're one of those girls who would love it?" Your cock is aching as Olivia begins brushing her hand across your cage. Again you think about answering, but are more focused on Amy as she is now lifting her head fully off Jason's cock.
"Oooh! Don't stop." He moans in protest.
"Don't worry. "Amy says, standing up. "I'm about to give you the real treat." She then tuns around, lowering herself down, bringing his cock inside of her ass. It doesn't take long before she's fully sitting on it.
"Ooh! Think how good THAT feels" Olivia says breathing deeply into your ear. "Being stroked from the inside." Her one hand continues to lightly jostle your cage while the other ventures around towards your ass. "Toys and things, are always fun, but there's just something about the real thing that just can't be beat." She says as her finger begins to lightly circle around the entrance of your hole.
You can feel your body tremble as your cock is dying to burst out of its cage. Unsure of what to do, you continue watching as Amy is now practically bouncing up and down on Jason's cock. The look on her face is one of pure joy and ecstasy, she doesn't seem to be putting on a show, but genuinely enjoying it. It takes you a moment to notice that she is now looking at you. Her joy-filled eyes, staring right in your direction as she pants heavily. You watch as her hand lifts up towards you, she flashes her fingers in, signaling you.
"Ooh! I think she's asking for your help." Olivia says as she pulls her hands away from you. "Go on, I don't mind."
You stand there baffled. The sensation of no longer being touched is agonizing, but the thought of what will happen if you go over there terrifies you... or excites you? You're not exactly sure, but you know you have to make a choice.
What do you do?
- No further chapters
- Add a new chapter
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Your Girlfriend's Plaything
Your girlfriend decides that you'd make a better plaything than a boyfriend. Is it a dream come true or a living nightmare? You decide.
Your girlfriend decides that you'd make a better plaything than a boyfriend. Is it a dream come true or a living nightmare? You decide. Additions are more than welcome, please add!
- Tags
- toys, dildo, cum eating, bondage, latex, rubber, cuck, cuckold, sissy, Strap on, cock cage, chastity, pegging, Sub, Dom, Femdom, Female Dominance, Submission, Humiliation, Edging, Denial, Objectification, Teasing, Psychological Domination, Power Play, Possessiveness, Begging, Emotional Vulnerability, Sensual Manipulation, Clothed Female Naked Male, Aftercare, CFNM, Female Domination, Tease and Denial, Power Exchange, Humiliation Play, Orgasm Control, Erotic Mind Games, DominantSubmissive Dynamics, Obedience Training, Gentle Femdom, Sensual Domination, Mental Bondage, Seductive Authority, Domestic Discipline, Erotic Manipulation, Clothed FemaleNude Male, Orgasm Denial, Fleshlight, Anal, Roman, Romans, Lesbian, Yuri, Girl on Girl, Lezdom, Curvy, Brunette, Femsub, Female Submisive, Petplay, sex toy, toy, bound, After Care, After, Care, Sensual, Loving, Bukkake, Squirting, Handcuffs, trap, blowjob, Pet, Mistress, face sitting, pet play, fisting, Power Dynamics, Public Play, Roleplay, Costume Play, Playful Domination, Erotic Tension, Mind games, Degradation play, Praise kink, Tease denial, Exhibitionism, Voyeurism, Worship, Foot Worship, Switch Dynamics, Servitude, Sensual Teasing, Poly Teasing, Romantic Domination, Gentle Domination, Authority Play, Emotional Intimacy, Playful Humiliation, Group Dynamics, Light BDSM, eating out, Collar
Updated on May 27, 2025
by namenotfound
Created on Feb 14, 2021
by namenotfound
- 9,004 Likes
- 2,416,323 Views
- 1,323 Favorites
- 1,198 Bookmarks
- 266 Chapters
- 25 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments