Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 251 by airwreck airwreck

What does Ian decide to do?

He has trouble deciding.

I gawked at the three gorgeous women lying on the bed in front of me. It suddenly dawned on me that I never had sex either Stephanie or Corrine as often as I had with Talia and Amy in my youth. To Talia and Amy, I was their best friend with benefits but to my two blonde friends, I was their best friend and lover.

Eeny, meeny, miny, moe, I thought while looking from one girl to another. Who do I fuck first was a question as hard as answering who do I love more?

"You can go first, Stephanie. Talia and I will keep ourselves busy," Corrine suggested after noticing my indecisiveness. She leaned over to kiss the dark-haired beauty. There was never competition between the girls for my attention, as close friends they were more than willing to share my cock with each other. We were more than friends -- we were lovers in our special, unique way.

Stephanie spread her long, slender legs apart to welcome me between her thighs. Her beautiful blue eyes locked with mine as I nudge the tip of my cock past her wet, delicate folds. She bit her lower lip as her pussy slowly engulfed my shaft and let out a sigh when my balls touched her ass cheeks. "Fuck me, Ian."

Subconsciously I just wanted to madly fuck Stephanie like I had done with Talia and Amy earlier in the bathroom but I wanted make love to her. I bent down and kissed her, my chest squishing her huge tits, while I slowly thrust in and out of her tight pussy. I felt the heels of her feet dig into the back of my thighs as I increased the tempo of my thrusts.

Letting a moan in my mouth and her nails digging into my back, Stephanie's soft, curvaceous body stiffened beneath me as she climaxed. I broke our kiss so I could push myself off her of enough so I could watch her beautiful face contort in erotic agony as her orgasm washed over her. Letting out a barely audible sigh, her body relaxed. I watched her breasts heave up and down as she caught her breath.

"I love you, Ian," she smiled up at me, playfully squeezing my cock with her pussy.

"I love you too," I grinned and gave her a quick kiss.

We looked around us and saw Corrine and Talia were still busy kissing and caressing each other while my wife and Amy were cuddling on the couch, watching the action on the bed.

"Who's next?" Stephanie asked with a mischievous grin.

What was Ian's decision?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)