He has a hard time coming up with the words.

"I... Uhh... It's... Well..." he tried to start a sentence, but everything seemed like the wrong set of words. If he told her it was his dick, how would she even react? She'd probably not talk to him ever again, he feared. Much to Andrew's terror, he felt the softness of Katie's hands as she inspected it, and began get turned on. His cock grew in Katie's hands.

"I can explain!" Andrew said as Katie dropped his cock back onto the bed.

"I... What..." it was now Katie's turn to be dumbfounded. "Why do you have a dildo?"

A dildo! He could play it off like it was a dildo! Wait, was that really any better?

Before Andrew could respond, Katie butted back in. "No, I actually don't really need to know. Uhhh... sorry? I didn't know that was..." She stammered a bit more before saying, "If you have a girlfriend, you can tell me. O-or a boyfriend; that's fine, too!"

"What?" Andrew responded, "No, no! It's nothing like that!"

"Or if you're just curious, you know?" A pause hang in the room as Andrew searched for the right words, but Katie continued, "You know I don't think I'm not 100% straight, either."

"No, it's... " That last comment landed in Andrew's brain finally and had him curious. "Wait, really? I mean, have you ever-" he started, but realized any line of questioning would only make this more awkward. "No. That doesn't really matter. Can we just maybe not talk about this right now?"

"Oh, yeah, sure! You can wait as long as you need."