He gives in

Audrey, still bent over the counter laughs to herself as Jake fucks her from behind, with what she believes is his cock. Unknown to her, it's his fingers. Jake is laughing to himself as well although for very drastically different reasons.

She arcs her back playfully, looking over into the mirror at Jake's face of false concentration, biting her lip.

'Fuck this' Jake thinks to himself, 'this slut needs to a good pounding'. Thinking less that she actually needs to be fucked but more that his cock needs some attention. Pulling out his fingers, he rubs her lower lips with his hand, receiving a little moan out of Audrey.

Although with a drastic tone change, he grabs her shoulder with one hand, and lines up his cock to her pussy lips, pushing the tip slightly in and moving his other hand to her hip.

"Wai-! Ah!" Audrey get's off before Jake slams his hips forward, till his hips slap her ass, holding himself deep inside of her for a moment. He enjoys seeing Audrey's eyes widen and then slam shut as her mouth is left in an open O shape, her whole body tensing.