He ain't no chicken

There really was no question whether or not he would do this dare. But he didn't know how Ms. Peyama would react; if he didn't have his psychically-powered "get out of jail free" card, what would happen to him?

"Ms. Peyama?" He whispered nervously, trying to catch her eye. She seemed lost in thought, so he continued speaking louder. "Do you think my penis could please a woman?"

Ms. Peyama looked up at him with a mischievous expression.

Nate stood up, revealing his naked body to the table and walked over to Ms. Peyama, who was cock-level to the standing Nate. Nate stepped close until he had his cock pressed to Ms. Peyama's nose. When she didn't say anything right away, he continued rubbing his cock against hers, enjoying the smooth feel of her skin.

"The look, the smell, the... taste? Is it all okay?" He asked tentatively.

Ms. Peyama nodded slightly. Nate stopped rubbing and looked down at her. Her eyes were closed as she breathed in deep through her nose, obviously savoring the scent of his dick, which was leaking pre-cum onto her face like some sort of white marker. She opened her eyes suddenly and stared directly into Nate's, which were full of desire for her.

Ms. Peyama opened her mouth to speak, but Nate couldn't hold back anymore. He pushed his cock into Ms. Peyama's mouth with a loud moan and grabbed the sides of her head firmly, holding her there while he began to thrust forward. Ms. Peyama didn't seem to struggle much as she opened her throat for him and swallowed eagerly. She moaned in delight as he pounded his cock into her mouth while she played with his ass with both hands, spreading his asscheeks apart with her fingers. Nate let go of her head and grabbed her shoulders so he could push harder and deeper into her throat.

The dining room was deathly quiet, besides the wet 'twap'ing noise of Nate's cock entering Ms. Peyama's mouth, her own gurgling and sucking sounds, and a few giggles from Nate's parents. Selina was getting more and more uncomfortable, and Gretchen was turning a deeper and deeper shade of red. But none of them dared interfere while this was happening in front of them.

Nate held Ms. Peyama's head tightly with one hand, pulling himself as far into her mouth as possible before pushing back out again, grunting loudly in pleasure. Then he pulled her hair and slapped her face softly, making her gasp briefly.

He continued thrusting into her mouth, fucking her mouth as best he could and enjoying every minute of it. He grabbed at the back of her floral dress, ripping the zipper open in front of everyone at the table while he fucked her throat like an animal. Finally he felt his orgasm approaching and he let go of her shoulders, holding himself still as he stroked his cock furiously to reach release as quickly as he could.

Then he released a huge stream of cum into her mouth.

At the same time, Ms. Peyama pulled back from him, gasping in surprise as she swallowed down the load he shot into her throat. He held himself inside for a few seconds and then pulled out of her lips to reveal his spurting cock, which was coated with saliva from Ms. Peyama's mouth and his own cum, which dripped from the tip of his shaft and ran down onto his balls and stomach. Her dress straps had torn off, revealing her bare breasts and making Nate's parents laugh at the sight of Ms. Peyama's bare chest covered in sperm, while she just smiled happily at them.

Selina and Gretchen looked away from the spectacle, trying not to make eye contact with their brother and friend, who now stood completely naked in front of them and was watching the two girls' reaction.

Ms. Peyama looked at Nate with sparkling eyes and licked her lips, still smiling.

"Hmm, the smell is exactly like your dad's cock, but the taste... It's just like your mother's..." She trailed off, but Nate thought that what she said clarified a few things. He didn't know if he wanted to hear that, though.