He'd rather do Amy and others together

Ultimately, Amy was not his goal. She was a means to an end and that meant doing her in conjunction with other girls.

"You're nice, Amy, and I like you. But it's not fair to either of us for us to spend a lot of alone time together. Your mom hired me because she wants you to be more popular and that doesn't mean us sneaking off together where no one can see us. You'll become more popular by spending time with me and with other girls."

"But I feel sort of used."

"Think how hot it is, though. Think how you felt when you were sucking my cock and April was stroking my arm and giving me her phone number and thinking maybe she could get my cock in her mouth but it was already in yours. Think what my sister's foot felt like in your pussy while you were eating me. If it had just been the two of us, you couldn't have had that."

"But... Fine. I guess that's the way it is. I think we might as well be getting home. I've got homework to do and we've got to at least curry the horses and maybe we have time to take them out for a ride."

"You'll see, Amy." Matt suspected he'd made the wrong choice here. "It's going to be fun."

"I said it was fine. We'll make it work."

"We can think about Matt when we get those horses between our legs," Karen said. "It's going to be fine, Amy."