Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Freeuse_Magazine Freeuse_Magazine

What's next?

Happy End

After his unsettling encounters at the farmers' market, Alex couldn’t shake the creeping unease gnawing at him. The fact that every woman from the art class was four months pregnant—exactly the amount of time that had passed since their first session together—wasn’t just a coincidence. He knew it, and so did they. But what bothered him most wasn’t the mystery of how it had happened; it was the fear of being held accountable.

He needed advice, reassurance—anything to help him process the situation. And there was only one person who might give him the perspective he needed: Mrs. Crenshaw, the art teacher who had witnessed everything that day.

The next day, Alex found himself walking to the art studio where it had all begun. The memory of that day was vivid, etched into his mind—the strange energy that had filled the room, the way the women had looked at him, and the undeniable pleasure that had followed. But now, with the reality of their pregnancies staring him in the face, the memory felt more like a weight than a thrill.

When Alex arrived at the studio, the late afternoon sun cast a warm glow over the empty space. Mrs. Crenshaw was at her desk, flipping through some old sketches. She looked up as he entered, her eyes immediately narrowing with concern when she saw the expression on his face.

"Alex," she said, setting the sketchbook aside. "What brings you here? You look troubled."

Alex hesitated for a moment, then took a deep breath. "Mrs. Crenshaw, I... I’ve been thinking about what happened during that art class a few months ago. I ran into Emily, Cynthia, Jasmine, Hannah, and Aiko—they’re all pregnant. Four months pregnant, just like the time that’s passed since the class."

Mrs. Crenshaw’s expression softened, a knowing look in her eyes. "Ah, I see. You’re worried about what this all means for you."

Alex nodded, anxiety tightening his chest. "I know what happened that day, and I know I was a part of it. But what if they hold me accountable? What if they expect something from me?"

Mrs. Crenshaw leaned back in her chair, her gaze steady and calm. "Alex, I understand your concerns. But you need to know that none of those women are expecting you to take responsibility. They’ve each made their own decisions about how to handle this, and they’ve all decided to pass their pregnancies off as the result of relationships with their boyfriends, husbands, or partners."

Alex blinked, surprised. "So... they’re not going to say anything? They’re just going to pretend it never happened?"

Mrs. Crenshaw nodded slowly. "Yes. They’ve chosen to move forward with their lives in a way that works for them, without involving you. They don’t want you to carry this burden. And frankly, Alex, neither should you."

Alex felt a mix of relief and lingering guilt. "But what about you, Mrs. Crenshaw? You were there too... You know what happened."

A small, almost mischievous smile tugged at the corner of Mrs. Crenshaw’s lips. She took a deep breath, her hand resting gently on her abdomen. "Yes, I know exactly what happened. And just like the others, I’m pregnant too. Four months along, just like them."

Alex’s eyes widened in shock. "You too?"

Mrs. Crenshaw nodded, her smile turning soft and reassuring. "Yes, me too. But like the others, I’ve made my peace with it. I have a partner who’s willing to raise this child as his own, and I’m not looking to complicate things for you."

"But how can you be so calm about this?" Alex asked, his voice tinged with disbelief.

Mrs. Crenshaw leaned forward, her gaze kind but firm. "Because, Alex, life is complicated enough without dwelling on things that can’t be changed. What happened in that class was... unexpected, but it was also consensual and, dare I say, a lot of fun for everyone involved."

Alex felt his face flush at her words, the memory of that day still vivid in his mind.

Mrs. Crenshaw continued, her tone soothing. "You’re young, Alex. You have your whole life ahead of you. Don’t let this weigh you down. Remember the fun we all had that day and let it be a part of your past, not a burden on your future. No one is holding you accountable. You’re free to enjoy your life without this hanging over you."

Alex took a deep breath, feeling the weight on his shoulders begin to lift. "So, I should just... move on?"

Mrs. Crenshaw smiled warmly. "Yes. Move on, live your life, and don’t let this hold you back. We’ve all made our choices, and now it’s time for you to make yours. Don’t let fear dictate your future."

Alex nodded slowly, her words sinking in. He still didn’t fully understand the strange events that had transpired in that art class, but he realized that he didn’t need to. The women had made their decisions, and now it was time for him to make his.

"Thank you," he said finally, his voice filled with gratitude. "I needed to hear that."

Mrs. Crenshaw squeezed his hand gently, her eyes filled with compassion. "You’re welcome, Alex. And remember, if you ever need to talk, I’m always here for you."

The room fell into a comfortable silence, and Alex began to stand, ready to leave with a newfound sense of relief. But before he could go, Mrs. Crenshaw spoke again.

"You know, Alex," she began, "I’ve been working on a new series of sketches, and I could use a model. What do you say? Would you mind posing for a couple of sketches before you leave? It’s been a while since I’ve had the chance to capture your form."

Alex hesitated for just a moment, then smiled. "Sure, why not? It sounds kind of nice, actually."

Mrs. Crenshaw’s eyes lit up as she stood and moved toward her easel, setting up a fresh sheet of paper. "Great! You know the drill."

Without any of the hesitation he’d felt that first time, Alex began to undress, his massive dick flopping out of his boxers, letting his clothes fall to the side. The atmosphere was different this time—lighter, more casual. As he stood in front of her, completely bare, he felt oddly comfortable.

Mrs. Crenshaw studied him for a moment, her pencil hovering over the paper. She looked him up and down, a hint of admiration in her eyes. "You know, Alex, I’ve worked with a lot of models over the years, but none of them had quite the... presence you have."

Alex raised an eyebrow, a slight smile on his lips. "My presence?"

Mrs. Crenshaw chuckled softly, her eyes glancing down briefly before meeting his again. "Yes, your presence—and by that, I mean your size. It's... impressive, to say the least," she continued, her voice taking on a more sincere tone, "And the way you handled everything that happened after the class last time—how you managed all of us so well—I have to say, it was remarkable."

Alex felt a surge of pride mixed with a hint of embarrassment. "Yeah, it was definitely intense," he admitted, his tone both light and reflective. "I didn’t expect to handle everything so... well, considering how overwhelming it was. I’m glad it seemed to work out, though."

Mrs. Crenshaw's gaze shifted downward for a brief moment, and she smirked knowingly. "Yes, it seems like you're remembering that quite vividly," she said with amusement, noticing the notable reaction of his penis to the flattery.

Alex couldn’t help but feel a bit flustered, though the pride in him was undeniable. "Well, it was... memorable," he said, trying to play it cool.

Mrs. Crenshaw smiled warmly as she began to sketch. "Indeed, it was. You’re quite remarkable, Alex. And it’s not just your... physical attributes. It's how you carry yourself. That’s what makes you such an interesting subject."

As Mrs. Crenshaw continued to work, Alex relaxed into his pose, feeling at ease in a way he hadn’t expected. The worry that had brought him here seemed to melt away with each stroke of her pencil, replaced by a sense of calm acceptance. Maybe life was more complicated than he’d ever imagined, but at least he could find moments of peace, like this one, amidst the chaos.

For now, that was enough.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)