Go with Cake

Finn thought about this. It was clear that the only one with any remotely innocent intentions was Cake, and while all of these women were beautiful, he didn’t really feel like having to sleep with one eye open tonight. “I think I’ll stay with Cake.”

The princesses looked disappointed, while Cake smiled gleefully. “Oh, you are gonna have such a wonderful time with us! I can show you around Ooo, we can watch movies, play BMO, and I just know Lady is going to adore you! Oh! I better call Lady and tell her the good news!” Cake ran out to call her girlfriend.

“Here Finn,” PB said as she handed him a blue shirt and jeans. “Your clothes were practically in ribbons when we found you, so I took the liberty of getting you some new ones.”

“Thank you, your majesty,” Finn said with a bow.

The princess giggled. “You don’t need to be so formal. Most princesses in Ooo aren’t that uptight, you can just call me PB.”

Finn quickly changed into his new clothes, paying no mind to the two women who were watching him get changed with almost predatory looks. PB even started drooling.

When Finn got changed, Cake walked in. “I just called Lady, and she can’t wait to have you staying over!” Cake said excitedly, then grabbed Finn's hand. “Come on! Let’s not keep my girl waiting!” Then Cakes body forms a second pair of arms below her regular ones that wrapped around Finn, pulling him into her. Then she stretched them out of the window on extended legs, while Finn screamed in confusion.

“Dang it!” Dr Princess exclaimed in disappointment. “I was hoping to get some fun with him!”

“Those nymphomaniacs are gonna milk him dry,” PB sighed in disappointment. “Better get ready for the ensuing funeral.”

Back with Finn and Cake, Cake was now walking on all fours with Finn riding on her back. “How-How are you doing this?!” Finn asked in shock.

“Oh this?” Cake asked. “This is just a little trick I can do, nothing special.”

Eventually they made it to a house that slightly resembled a horse stable. “Lady, we’re home!” Cake called out as they came in.

Finn heard the voice of another woman shouting from another room. Now when Finn heard the name, “Lady Rainicorn” he had expected maybe something like a rainbow colored unicorn that maybe had an incredibly long body. What Finn saw was not that. Floating down towards them was another humanoid with pale pink skin, long unkempt blonde hair, a matching tail, and a single pointed horn protruding from the top of her forehead. Like Cake, she was completely stark naked leaving her well endowed figure exposed for all to see. The closest thing she had to clothes was rainbow colored thigh high socks and arm warmers.

“keikeu, jib-e wass-eo! dangsin-eun Finnieoya habnida. mannaseo bangawoyo!” The horsewoman greeted them both in a language that Finn didn’t understand before giving Cake a hug and a kiss.

“What is she saying?” Finn asked.

“Oh, Lady is just saying that it’s nice to meet you. Sorry, I forgot to mention that Lady can only speak Korean,” Cake explained.

Lady lightly punched Cake in the arm and said something to her. Again, Finn didn’t understand a word of it, but he could tell she was upset. And her little pouting face she made was possibly the most adorable thing Finn had ever seen.

After Cake apologized to Lady, the three went on to have a fun night. They had dinner, Cake told Finn about all the adventures she’d been on, they watched a movie together, and when night came, they showed Finn to his room. It had a king sized bed in the middle and soft silky sheets, and that night Finn slept well.

Finn opened his eyes in the middle of the night, he felt something weird, he looked at the covers and saw two large bumps near his crotch. Finn threw the blanket off and saw something that shocked him. Right before him, Cake and Lady were licking his penis like they were sharing an ice cream cone. Finn tried to say something, but the feeling of the two women licking his cock made him let out a moan.

“Mmmm~ its even more delicious than the legends say!” Cake moaned out in joy. Lady said something that sounded like an agreement.

“W-W-What are-Ungh! What are you two doing?!” Finn asked in confusion.

“Oh, we’re just getting you all ready for a fun night. If you’d like that, that is.”

“What are you talking about?”

Cake giggled. “Well you see Finn, me and Lady have been wanting to take our relationship to a whole new level. We want to have babies together, but unfortunately we’re both women so we lack the required material to make some kittens. But you sir have exactly what we need.”

“Why can’t you…get some other guy…to help you?!” Finn asked, trying to hold back his moans.

Cake giggled. “Oh, Sugar, there are no men in Ooo.”

Finn’s eyes widened in disbelief. “Wait, what?”

Cake stopped licking Finns cock, leaving Lady there to have it all to herself. As the horsewoman stuffed Finn’s slowly hardening member in her mouth, her lover got closer to Finn’s face, and placed her hand on his chest, gently rubbing her hand up and down. “Ooo hasn’t had any men in it since the Mushroom War,” Cake said before giving Finn a kiss on the side of his face, her whiskers tickling him.

“But, if there’s no men in Ooo, how do people here still have children?” Finn asked.

“Each kingdom has its own methods,” Cake said. “Now, enough lore, can we get to the good part please?”

“keikeu, bwa!” Lady exclaimed something, catching both of their attention. Cake looked towards her girlfriend and gasped in shock. Finn wasn’t just huge, he was absolutely HUNG! His fully erect penis was at least 13 to 14 inches in length, and had an appropriate amount of girth to compliment it.

“Oh my Glob!” Cake gasped, her lower lips flooding with arousal.

Both women could only stare at the phallus in awe, drooling. It looked like they were waiting to get permission to do anything with him. Lady looked Finn in the eyes, a look of desperation plastered on her face. She looked like someone who hadn’t seen water in ages and had just discovered an oasis.

“F-Finn…” Cake began, her entire body trembling. She almost looked like the rational part of her brain was having second thoughts about this, but her horniness was too strong. “Please, give us your babies! We’ll let you pick which one of us you fuck first!” Cake pleaded.