Go easy on Nightmare

“I mean, you don’t have to do anything you don’t want!” you insist. “I don’t want you to be my **** or… well, get crushed by you either. I just thought this would be fun.”

Nightmare snorts heavily as she frowns at you. “So what are you saying? You’re not man enough to take me like your prize?”

“No! I mean, uh… you have to do what I say now, right?”

“I guess that was the bet,” she grunts as she stands back up. Her huge and muscular body is intimidating even as she tries to act submissive.

“Then… I order you to have a quiet night in with me. Like a little date.”

Nightmare just laughs. “Are you serious? Are you that big a pussy?”

You feel your body shiver and your cock harden at her petrifying glare, but you bolster some courage. “So you’re wussing out?”

“What?!” she snarled.

“You’re too weak to be my date for tonight? Cuz I thought I bought a horse animorph. Not a chicken.”

You can see Nightmare’s muscles tense in anger at the accusation. “I’m no chicken! I’ll date the fuck out of you! I’m not backing down from anything!”

While she seems pissed off, she does seem to be playing right into your hands. It’s an odd way to get her to soften up, but she seems to be playing along in her own way.