Give Jessica a choice

"I wish that time was frozen for everyone except Jessica and myself."

Jessica clenched her thighs together, doing her best to keep her juices from running down her legs. When she managed to focus again, the first thing she noticed was how quiet it was. Not only due to the lack of music, but any background noise at all, even something as subtle as the breeze. It was pretty unnerving, but not as unnerving as seeing all of her friends frozen in place like statues.

"Whoa, this is so freaky," Kevin said, vocalizing what Jess was thinking, "And breaks so many laws of physics. Then again, that's kind of par for the course with magic, wouldn't you say?"

Jessica turned to face her tormentor, "Master, what are you doing?"

Kevin grinned as he responded, "Sorry, but your friend's desire to put on a show gave me an idea for what to do for your punishment. But to do what I want, we're going to need a moment to ourselves, so I created one."

Despite her growing anxiety at what was coming, Jessica did her best to maintain a sarcastic tone of voice, "Very cool. So what are we going to do here exactly?"

"Why, we're going to watch Cassie put on a show," Kevin said, "But not the one she was planning to do. I have an idea that'll be for fun."

"In case you haven't noticed, Master, Cassie's frozen too," Jessica said gesturing to the pixie of a girl, pearly white smile frozen on her face.

"Not a problem," Kevin said, "I wish that Cassie would unfreeze and perform a cheer for us that reveals her deepest, most humiliating fetish, then refreeze the moment she finishes."

Jessica stumbled, managing to hold herself upright, though she was too breathless to do anything but watch in horror as Cassie unfroze and started her routine. Cassie stretched her arms out as she started to spell out the beginning of her cheer.

"Gimme a C! Gimme me a U! Gimme a M! Now gimme a R-A-G!

That spells what I want to be!

Jizz or juice, I don't care, wipe up either with my hair!

Coat me with cum from head to toe, my arousal will only grow!

So no need to fret, no need to stress, just use my body to clean your mess!

Degrading me like that's not mean, it's not my purpose to be clean!"

Cassie finishes her cheer with a leap, and the second she hits the ground she freezes once more. Jessica meanwhile just stared at her friend in stunned silence.

The only sound present was Kevin's applause, "That was amazing! Much better than whatever it was she was about to do, wouldn't you say?"

His voice snapped Jessica out of her stupor, and she glared at Kevin, "That was... What did you even do that for?"

"You'll see pretty soon," he assured her, "For now though, I wish that... hmm, Nina, would unfreeze and perform a cheer for us that reveals her deepest, most humiliating fetish, then refreeze the moment she finishes."

Jessica felt another pulse of pleasure course through her, and ended up having to sit down on the bleachers beneath Kevin just as Nina unfroze, turned to face the two of them, and begin her cheer.

"I've got an ass that just won't quit, and I dream of people spanking it!

Use paddles, canes, or your bare hand, any way you want I'll find just grand!

Long as you don't break the skin, I'll bear it with a big old grin!

Don't hold back, no need to fret, the pain will make me super wet!

So spank me 'til my ass is blue, that's what I'm telling you to do!"

Nina freezes after her final line, her skirt flipped up and her bubble butt pointed directly at Jessica, who averted her eyes with a blush.

"Hope you're paying attention down there, this will all be on the test," Kevin said mockingly, "I think we need one more cheer to round things out... I wish that Tiffany would unfreeze and perform a cheer for us that reveals her deepest, most humiliating fetish, then refreeze the moment she finishes."

Jessica let out a moan as the wish hit her, the juices starting to pool on the metal seat beneath her. Tiffany meanwhile walks over next to Nina, and Jessica swore she saw a look of confusion on Tiffany's face before she started to cheer.

"I'm one of the hottest girls in school, so wouldn't it be so uncool,

If the word ever got around, that I get off on being bound?

And though I'll struggle, beg, and plead, deep down I'll never want to be freed!

Just imagine how hot it'd be, my body strung up for all to see!

Dressed or nude I don't know which, would better satisfy my itch!"

Tiffany froze, her face plastered with a cheesy grin. Jess shuddered, this time out of worry about why Kevin was putting her through all this.

Kevin meanwhile just laughed, "Man, I could do this all day! But I'm eager to get to the actual punishment, so let's just say these three are good for now."

He stood up and walked down to the field, "Here's the thing, Jess: I could warp reality to make things more humiliating for you personally... and believe me, I'm far from done doing that. But I'm thinking I need to do something drastic to get it through your thick head that I am not to be mocked anymore."

He gestured to the three frozen girls that had just exposed their fetishes to him, "You've heard what kind of kinky shit each of these girls are secretly into, so now you have a choice to make. Whichever girl you choose, I'll craft a wish for them to change their lives to revolve around that fetish, as much if not more than your life now apparently revolves around your wet little cunt."

"...And if I refuse?" Jessica said, her voice dripping with venom.

"Then I'll just do it to all three of them," Kevin replied coldly, "And maybe even throw in something extra just for you. So I suggest you bite the bullet and choose, before I get bored of waiting."

Jessica bit her lip, looking between her three friends. This was sick, incredibly fucking sick! How could she be expected to do something like this? And yet if she didn't, she'd be condemning them all. So she had to figure out which was the lesser of three evils... if that was even possible.