Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 43 by BreaktheBar BreaktheBar

What's next?

Girl Talk (Guest Post)

Authors Note: This is a continuing Guest Post by BreaktheBar

“I- I dropped the showerhead and almost busted my ass trying to pick it up,” Alice said, and Lucy suppressed her smirk at the fumbling lie. Alice grabbed the shower head and stood up, brushing herself off like she’d gotten dirty or something. Lucy knew it was just her trying to feign that nothing had been happening. “Need something?” Alice finally asked.

“You seen my bikini?” Lucy asked. “The red one.” That had been her original reason for coming up here to begin with.

“Yeah. It’s in my room,” Alice said as she opened the glass door to the shower and grabbed a towel, starting to dry herself off. “I think Mom thought it was mine. Give me a second and I will grab it.”

Alice was drying her tits, getting the towel around and under them, which lifted them up towards Lucy almost like Alice was offering her hard nipples to her sister.

“Did your boobs get bigger?” Lucy suddenly asked, realizing that Alice was looking almost as filled out as she did. She stepped forward and put her hand under Alice’s left breast, hefting it and then bouncing it a little. It was heavy - not like when Lucy’s had been full of milk from breastfeeding, but that proper weightiness that Lucy had recovered only a few months ago.

“Yes, I had to pick up new bras today,” Alice frowned.

Lucy chuckled and brought her hand up to cup both of Alice’s tits, eyeing them to see if they were coming in even. Every woman had one breast that would be slightly larger than the other, but it could be really obvious with tits as large as Lucy or Alice. Thankfully Alice’s looked pretty even. “Bet your boyfriend loved that,” Lucy smiled. She gave her sister’s tits a squeeze, then again a little closer to the nipples.

“I didn’t model them for him or anything,” Alice said.

Lucy raised an eyebrow. The last time she’d brought Jake being Alice’s boyfriend, it had been stumbling ‘Not yet’ remarks. This time Alice didn’t seem phased by it. So it really is happening, Lucy thought. Hopefully he can keep up. “His loss,” Lucy said. “They look amazing. That boy would have probably creamed his pants if he saw these damn things.” Then Lucy pinched Alice’s nipple hard and shook it, making Alice’s entire chest wobble delightfully.

“Lucy!” Alive half gasped, half moaned, and tried to pull away. Lucy knew that after the big orgasm Alice had just given herself, her nipples were probably extra sensitive - that’s how she always loved. After a good fuck, she loved her tits being sucked on. So Lucy held on just a little tighter as Alice tried to pull away, putting that little bit of extra pinch in there before letting it go and watching Alice’s tit drop back to her chest.

“Just saying li’l sis,” Lucy said. “I wish mine were still so firm. You have some great tits.” Lucy cupped her own through her dress and bra, pushing them up into a firmer, more projected cleavage she imagined she had when she was Alice’s age, before the pregnancy.

“So what did you do with Emily?” Alice asked, changing the subject as she wrapped a towel around herself.

“I put her in the living room with some food. Your boy is watching her. Honestly, I’ve never seen her take to a guy so fast,” Lucy said.

“That’s because he actually plays with her and pays attention to what she says,” Alice said. “She is a good judge of character. Just don’t leave them alone too long, Emily will have him playing dress-up or something.” Alice led Lucy out of the bathroom, now wrapped in the towel, and into Alice’s bedroom.

“Alice,” Lucy said, closing the door behind them. “I’m just saying this as your big sis, and just once alright?”

Alice looked over to Lucy with a raised eyebrow.

“You obviously trust Jake. I just- you left the bathroom door unlocked while you were showering. Do you really trust him that much?” Lucy asked.

Alice beamed and bit her lips happily. “Yes, actually, I do,” she said. “And you know I have rules, sis. I want to have fun, but you’ve definitely made it clear what lines I should draw for myself and I completely believe you. Jake is- Jake is just really good. And I don’t mean like ‘Oh, he’s a good guy.’ I mean like I think I could probably drop him in a room full of the hottest, horniest women on the planet and he’d still always come to me first.”

Lucy could feel herself getting wet, listening to her sister and watching her face as Lucy talked about Jake.

“Well, good,” Lucy said with a nod. “I just don’t want you to get taken advantage of.”

Alice laughed. “If anything, I’ll probably take advantage of him!”

Both sisters laughed, and Alice went over to her drawers and dug through them, coming up with Lucy’s two-piece red bikini. “Here you go,” she said and handed it to Lucy. Then she took off her towel and tossed it onto her vanity and grabbed a pair of panties from the drawer.

“Thanks,” Lucy said, then held the top up to Alice’s naked tits. “You know, this might actually fit you now.”

“Maybe,” Alice said, and Lucy knew that look. She’d already tried it on, and maybe even worn it for Jake.

“You don’t mind if I ask your boy to take some pics on my phone, do you?” Lucy asked as she pulled her dress over her head. “I’m thinking of actually trying a dating app and want to see what they would maybe look like.”

Alice, still holding her panties, looked Lucy up and down quickly and Lucy hoped she hadn’t made a wet spot in her thong. Fuck, I probably did, I was practically rubbing myself off out there.

“If you can,” Alice said. “Jake is a little timid in that regard.” She bent and put on her panties, then reached for a bra and started putting it on.

“I can see that,” Lucy said. “He seems very sweet and trustworthy.” Lucy dropped her bra as Alice was just getting hers on, her large breasts dropping uncovered. Lucy’s nipples were always a little erect because of the little silver rings she had piercing each one. She usually wore thick, padded bras for her size anyways, so no one at work or around the city would know that she had them put back in when she stopped breastfeeding Emily. Lucy saw Alice immediately stop putting on her own bra, stopping to stare at Alice’s piercings like always. She was fascinated by them, which sort of turned Lucy on a bit. “At least I don’t have to worry about him making a move on you,” Lucy continued. “It’s your ass that needs watching, sis.”

Lucy gave Alice a smack on the ass to wake her up from her staring.

“Hey,” she said, jumping a little at the contact. “Sorry.”

“Just saying,” Lucy said.

“Pot, have you met Kettle?” Alice frowned, gesturing at Lucy’s pierced nipples.

“Yes, and don’t I have the little teapot downstairs because I didn’t think things through? You’re a smart girl, sis. Just use your head, please.”

“I will,” Alice frowned.

Lucy sighed and turned, presenting her tits to her sister. “If you’re going to stare like that, just get a feel.”

Alice got a sneaky little smile on her face and put both of her hands on Lucy’s tits, catching the silver nipple rings between her fingers and fondling them lightly. “They just look like they hurt, but also like they would feel so good,” she said.

“That’s about right,” Lucy nodded and sighed. The feeling of Alice groping her tits was only semi-sexual, but whenever her sister ran a thumb right over the top of her nipple she got a little buzz of pleasure down her stomach and into her clit.

“Do you think I should get mine done?” Lucy asked.

“That’s a personal choice. I’d take you if you wanted,” Lucy said. “But honestly? If you’re sure about Jake, I’d let him enjoy yours without for a while before you start thinking about it. They can add some fun, but also make other things harder. And when people find out they tend to make judgments.” God, she could only imagine what that asshole Drake and his girlfriend or wife or whoever would have thought if Lucy had worn a bra that let the bumps show.

“Good point,” Alice said, letting go of one of Lucy’s boobs to grab her own, testing the differences. Lucy reached out and did the same, the two sisters feeling themselves and each other.

Alice finally broke down in a giggle, and they both let go.

“You know, if things do get that far and you need advice about sex, you can come to me, right?” she said to Alice as her sister finished putting on her bra. “I’d rather you do that than go to your friends, and you sure as hell can’t talk to Mom.”

“Oh God, hell no,” Alice laughed. The tension in the house had been palpable four years ago when Lucy had had to admit to her parents that she was pregnant. Alice had gotten the Birds and the Bees talk that weekend, and it had almost been traumatizingly specific and detailed.

Lucy let a sneaky smirk come back onto her face as she dropped her thong to the floor, glancing down and seeing that she did indeed have a wet spot on the purple fabric. She had no idea if Alice had noticed or not. “And if you just so happened to be doing anything in the shower, lock the damn door next time. No matter how much you trust your boy,” Lucy said.

“I wasn’t doing anything,” Alice blushed and shook her head.

“If you say so,” Lucy smirked, stepping into her bikini bottoms. “I’m not judging. Personally, I keep one of those large suction cup dildos that can stick to a wall in the bathroom at my place. I have to hide it whenever you guys are coming over.”

“Oh, God,” Alice laughed, putting her first to her mouth and biting it to stop from laughing too loudly. She actually sort of laughed and blushed too hard, but Lucy let it go.

“That’s what I say,” Lucy said, needling the joke a little deeper. “Over and over, and over!”

“Lucy!” Alice said, putting her hands on her hips while still standing in just her bra and panties. “I am a virgin still, thank you.” Then she blushed again and Lucy could see Alice’s nipples get harder again as she looked towards her crotch. She covered the look quickly though, sliding an innocent little dress over her head.

“You say that now, but just wait,” Lucy said. “Sometimes a girl has to take care of her own needs, baby girl.” She winked at her sister while she tugged just a little on her nipple rings. “If you want something done right, do it yourself as Mom is so fond of telling us.”

“I don’t think that’s what Mom meant with that saying,” Alice said. “But you should definitely try suctioning your dildo to the bathroom mirror.”

“Why is that?” Lucy asked, pulling on her red bikini top and starting to tuck her tits into the cups.

“So you can pretend it’s a double dildo and go fuck yourself,” Alice replied with a laugh, leaning forward and taking her turn to smack Lucy’s ass.

“Ah, bitch,” Lucy laughed. Alice got behind Lucy and helped her with the top, wrapping the shoulder straps across her chest first, which had a nifty way of hauling her tits into an even perkier position. “But who said I didn’t own a double dildo as well?”

“You do?” Alice asked, wide-eyed.

Lucy smirked and shrugged. “Maybe. Would you really want to know if I did?”

Alice blushed, biting her bottom lip. “Maybe.”

“Well you’re going to need to ask me straight up then,” Lucy said. She fixed her tits one last time, making sure she was all tucked in. “Another time. How do I look?”

“Hot,” Alice nodded. “Just try not to break Jake.”

“No promises, baby girl,” Lucy grinned, and leaned forward and gave Alice a peck on the lips. She turned and opened the door, leaving Alice in her room. As she descended the stairs, she hoped she hadn’t held that kiss a little too long and made things weird.

I really, really need to get laid, Lucy sighed to herself. She really had to stop getting horny around her sister and Jake, her fantasies were getting entirely too realistic and close to him.

There will be one more guest post in this sequence.

Breakthebar erotica is powered by Patreon. PM if interested in making a Commission.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)