Getting to "know" Matthew

"It's ok, Anna..." Carly whispered, kissing the nervous girl's neck with soft, sensual touches from her lips, "He wants you. You want him. You wanted me to teach you to be more like me, right? Let's call this your first lesson in taking what you want as a woman..."

Anna trembled under Carly's touch, her heart pounding wildly in her chest. The older girl's words resonated deep within her. She knew this was wrong, that she shouldn't take advantage of Matthew like this, but Carly's suggestion that he enjoyed being taken by force had left her positively dripping.

With a shaky breath, Anna nodded, surrendering herself to the moment and to Carly's guidance. The dominant girl rewarded her with a wicked grin, her eyes flashing with excitement.

"Good girl," Carly purred, giving Anna a quick peck on the lips for encouragement. "Now, let's get you out of those soaked pants, and your top if you're up for it. Your rack is too good to hide."

Carly's experienced fingers slid the condom on Matt's throbbing length while Anna shyly shimmied out of her yoga pants. Daring herself to go a bit further, the girl tossed her tank top aside, though she kept her red sports bra on.

"Fuck, you're gorgeous," Carly hummed, her hands coming up to cup Anna's bountiful breasts, kneading the soft flesh through the fabric and earning a moan from the shy girl. "Mattie's gonna lose his mind when he sees you like this."

True to her word, Carly guided Anna to straddle Matthew's hips, positioning her dripping core inches above his throbbing erection. Even unconscious, Matt could feel the heat from Anna's center, and he let out a low groan, his hips twitching upwards instinctively.

Carly grinned mischievously before turning back to Matt and giving a few sharp, but gentle smacks to his face. "Rise and shine, Mattie! You don't want to sleep through this~"

Matthew's eyes fluttered open, hazy and unfocused at first. As his awareness slowly returned, he blinked up at Anna, his gaze roaming over her nearly naked form with shock that turned to awe, and then undisguised hunger. A low groan rumbled in his chest as he realized who and what were hovering just above him.

"A...Anna...?" he croaked, his voice rough from his knockout. "H-holy shit! Is this real? Am I still dreaming...?"

His hands came up to rest on her hips, fingers digging in to the soft skin of her ass and thighs to ensure she was real. Despite the confusion in his eyes, there was no mistaking the desire burning there, eyes wide and hungry. Anna shivered with delight as Matt touched her, looked at her, in a way she had only fantasized about. A soft whimper fell from her lips, and Carly watched the exchange with a satisfied smirk, clearly enjoying the sight.

"You're very much awake now, Mattie," Carly purred, trailing a finger down Matthew's chest. "And lucky you, our guest of honor is ready to give you a very special welcome back~"

With a wink at Anna, Carly reached between them and grasped Matthew's shaft, lining it up with Anna's slick entrance. The head pressed against her lower lips, instantly coating it in her arousal. Anna gasped, her hips bucking involuntarily at the touch. When she looked down again, there was a new determination in her eye.

Carly smiled proudly as she saw the girl's fire return. "Whenever you're ready, shortstack. Nice and slow, and savor every inch~"

Taking a deep breath to steel her nerves, Anna began to sink down onto Matthew's thick shaft. She had to pause halfway, overwhelmed by the intense sensation of being stretched and filled by something so much bigger than her own fingers. Matthew groaned beneath her, gripping her hips tighter as he fought the urge to thrust up into her welcoming heat.

Carly watched intently as Anna slowly impaled herself on Matthew's throbbing cock, a wicked grin spreading across her face at the delicious sounds spilling from the shy girl's lips. She loved seeing Anna come out of her shell, embracing her desires with such passion.

"That's it, sweetie," Carly cooed her encouragement, her hand sliding up Anna's trembling thigh. "Take every thick inch of him. Fuck, you look so sexy like this~"

Once Anna was fully seated, Carly leaned in close, her breath hot against the girl's ear. "How does it feel, having your crush's dick splitting you open? Bet it's even better than you imagined in all your dirty little fantasies, huh?"

Anna nodded quickly, taking deep breaths as she tried to steady herself. Her inner walls fluttered and clenched around Matthew's thickness, drawing a blissful moan from the young man below her. She could feel every ridge and vein of his shaft pulsing inside her, setting her nerve endings on fire!

"It's... it's amazing!" Anna panted, her hips starting to roll experimentally. "Even better than I dreamed. Mattie... You don't know how long I've wanted to do this..."

"Me too, Anna," he replied, his smile and tone almost reverent from his lips. Despite his excitement to finally be with the brilliant beauty, he was a lot more sexually experienced than her, making it easy for Anna to see the sincerity in his eyes. "I didn't think you wanted me, but I've wanted you a long time..."

Emboldened by their words and the incredible sensations, Anna began to move more forcefully. She lifted herself up until just the tip remained inside, then crashed back down with a wail of pleasure. Matthew bucked up to meet her, his dazed state gone as he experienced a moment he had been fantasizing of for years.

Carly's eyes darkened with lust as she watched Anna start to ride Matthew with increasing confidence. She licked her lips hungrily, feeling her own arousal spike at the erotic display.

"Fuck yes, just like that!" Carly growled appreciatively, her hand slipping inside her shorts. "Bounce on that dick, baby. Show him what a wild girl you really are!"

Anna started to ride Matthew harder and faster, her huge tits bouncing with each downward slam of her hips. Her fears and shame forgotten, Anna pulled her bra over her head, fully exposing herself to the two pairs of admiring eyes.

"Fuck... Fuck...! Mattie...!" she gasped with each crash of their hips. She took his hands and held them against her bouncing tits, pushing her closer to her breaking point.

Anna threw her head back with a desperate cry as she chased her rapidly building peak. She was still sensitive from her first release, and the feeling of a man inside her was still too new. Her hands went to her hair, holding her head because she felt like the pleasure was making her lose her mind!

"I'm gonna cum! Mattie, I can't hold it! It feels too goooood!~"

Carly's fingers worked harder, rubbing herself furiously as she watched Anna's impending orgasm build. The sight of the usually shy girl lost in such uncontrollable lust, claiming her longtime crush so fiercely, was every bit as exciting for her.

"Yessss, do it Anna!" Carly demanded, her voice strained with her own approaching climax. "Don't hold back. Fucking soak him! Take him!"

With a final, brutal slam of her hips, Anna came undone. Her pussy clamped down HARD on Matthew's pistoning cock as waves of ecstasy crashed over her.

"M-MATTIE!!!~" A scream of pure ecstasy tore from her throat, her eyes rolling back in sheer bliss. She gushed out around his shaft, splattering everywhere as she squirted from the force of her release. She fell forward, holding Matt's chest for dear life as the aftershocks shook her with delightful savagery.

Matthew, on the other hand, had far more experience and endurance. He could see that Anna was spent, but he sure as hell wasn't. The boxer held Anna close as he rolled them over, positioning her beneath him and kissing her softly before he rose above her and started thrusting again.

Carly moaned in sympathy as she watched Anna's explosive orgasm, only to see Matthew flip their positions, now looming over Anna with a look of pure male dominance. The change in dynamic sent a fresh surge of arousal through Carly, and she licked her lips hungrily as she watched Matthew start to pound into Anna's sensitive, spasming cunt with renewed vigor.

"Fuck yes, Mattie! Wreck that tight little pussy!" Carly called out, her voice raspy with desire. She'd seen both of them in control, and the way it had gone back and forth was driving her wild.

Anna could only moan weakly as Matthew started to rail into her oversensitive hole, her body still quivering from the aftershocks of her earth-shattering orgasm. Each powerful thrust sent jolts of pleasure and pain through her nerves, pushing her towards another peak embarrassingly fast.

"Ah ah ahhh! M-Mattieeee~!" she wailed, her nails gripping at the mats. She was no longer the one in control, but she couldn't bring herself to care as his experienced dick tore up her insides.

Carly crawled closer, drinking in the sight of Matthew's cock plunging in and out of Anna's overflowing pussy. The wet slap of sex filled her ears, mingling with their moans and cries. Unable to resist, Carly leaned down and captured Anna's lips in a searing kiss, swallowing the girl's desperate moans. When she pulled away, she turned to Matthew and kissed him too.

"That's it, Matt," she panted against his lips, "Fuck her stupid. Fuck her big brains out!"

Matthew growled into the kiss with Carly, doubling his efforts as he chased his own release. His hips snapped forward with punishing force, desperate to cum inside her.

"T-too much... soooo good... too much... don't stooooop..." Anna whimpered as Matthew used her like a ragdoll, his powerful thrusts forcing the smaller girl up the mat with each crash of his hips. She was limp and drooling, begging for him to stop and keep going all at once until neither could hold back anymore.

"Ah...AAAAHHHH!!!~"

With a roar of completion, Matthew buried himself to the hilt one last time, his cock exploding deep inside her as he emptied himself, his hips jerking erratically with each pulse of his release.

Anna moaned in broken ecstasy, her eyes rolling back as her own orgasm crashed over her once more at the feeling of Matt's eruption inside her.

Inches away, Carly felt a rush of her own. She threw her head back, her powerful thighs clamping together as wave after wave of pleasure surged through her until all three were completely spent.

As one, they all could only think of one thing to say, moaning it in unison.

"Fuuuuck..."