Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 26 by not me not me

What's next?

Getting rid of the thorn in your eyes

Back at home, you are lying down on the couch, watching tv when Judy returns home. She looks tired but her eyes light up as soon as she notices you. She angrily stomps the ground. "Hmmp!"

"Are you angry at me?" You get up and approach Judy. She takes a step back to avoid you.

"You know what you've done!"

"Are you angry that I flirted with the other girls?" You chuckle when you see Judy act grumpily.

"Flirting with others is fine. I already agreed with Melissa to let you vent yourself a little bit. But, why are you giving away so many invaluable gifts? In just an hour, you gave away so many unique gifts. Melissa and I are your friends with benefits but even us have never received anything like that... You even let that random stranger you met for not even one minute drink your piss!"

"Oh? Then, do you want to drink it now?"

Judy frowns and pushes you away. "John, you know that's disgusting. I am not ready for that sort of play."

You smile and let Judy walk into the kitchen to get herself a drink. You are already used to the contradictory arguments of your girls. Your ability is not omnipotent and the girls still maintain their personalities and taste unless you explicitly put it in your rewards.

You feel happy that Judy is being possessive about you. In a way, it shows that she cares for you. It would be perfect if you could get rid of Ryan. That guy is the only obstacle between you and Judy. But to put him out of the picture, you might end up hurting Judy and you need more time.

Although you found a way to push more **** actions onto your girls, you still need to refine the method. It is one week later that you finally decide to take action. You choose to do so because tonight, Melissa is going out with a couple of friends. Your girls still have their own life outside of your relationship and you do not stop them from interacting with other girls. You are nervous and at the same time a little bit ashamed and sad that you have to use this method to obtain Judy completely.

The beautiful blonde has already calmed down from her previous anger. She just finished cooking her meals for the week and puts a plate in front of you in the dining room.

"Thank you, Judy." You reply hesitantly.

"What is it? You are weird today." Judy questions you. After living together for close to a month, she became familiar with your habits.

"I... I just want to thank you for this meal and I want to repay you properly." You say, the words get stuck in your throat.

Judy's expression instantly brightens. As usual, with the mentions of thanks and rewards, any girl around you gets excited.

"I have a contract here that I will give you the opportunity to sign. You will agree to the clauses and respect them." You point at the piece of paper on the table. Half of the top of the page is covered by a towel, completely hiding the content of the contract but at the bottom, there is your signature and an empty space for Judy's.

"Signing a contract? What is it about?" Judy asks happily.

"I would like to keep it a secret until you sign. You should trust me. You know how great the gifts I give as repayment are. I am certain you will like it." You say, hesitantly. You feel a nauseous as you are about to trick Judy and cause her to feel a lot of pain.

"Mmm, that's true! I cannot miss such a great opportunity!" Judy grabs the pen on the table and immediately puts down her signature. "All done! So, can you reveal the content of the contract now?"

You pause and meet Judy's eyes. You feel guilty. "Don't you already know?" You mutter quietly and instantly, Judy's expression change.

She is torn between sadness and joy. Her face is distorted; it is the first time you see this kind of expression. She is still widely smiling and yet, tears fill her eyes. "I know."

She takes out her phone and starts dialling a number. Her fingers and lips are trembling.

"Hello? Ryan?" She speaks on the phone, sounding still confident but the rest of her body is shaking uncontrollably.

You cannot hear the person speaking on the other side; all you can do is watch Judy go through the painful process.

"Yes, I know it is still 5:00 am where you are and I am sorry to wake you up but I have something important to tell you..." She wipes off her eyes.

"Let's breakup. I have been given a huge opportunity by John Doe and I have already accepted."

"No Ryan. I am not joking. I am sorry but we can no longer be together."

"No, I was not threatened or anything. In fact, I am very happy right now. You went away for so long..."

"I am sorry."

She cuts the call and turns off her phone. The next second, she crouches on the ground and looks down, not wanting to meet your eyes. She wraps her arms around her legs and then sobs uncontrollably.

Please log in to view the image

You feel a heart wrenching pain inside when you see Judy crying, especially since you are the one responsible for her pain. You grab the towel on top of the contract and hand it to her. By doing so, you expose the content of the contract:


This Agreement (“Agreement”) is made between [Judy McMiller] ("Judy”) and [John Doe] ("John”) on [August 08, 2020]. This Agreement will become effective after the signature of both parties and will remain into effect indefinitely, even after destruction of the contract.

Judy agrees to break up with her boyfriend known as Ryan and cut all ties with him indefinitely. Judy agrees to get into a serious relationship with John and become his girlfriend and in the future, his queen. Both parties acknowledge their obligations as a couple. The previous verbal agreement between the two parties about being friends with benefits shall remain effective.


You wrap your hands around Judy and holds her tight against your chest. She leans against you instinctively and wet your shirt. You do not stop her and let her cry to her heart's content.

"I am sorry John. I must be a horrible girlfriend to cry about my ex right in front of my boyfriend."

"Shhh, don't blame yourself. I am at fault too." You try to calm her down but seeing her like that makes you feel so guilty. And yet, it was a necessary step. You did not want that Ryan to steal away Judy.

You stay in this position, allowing Judy to use your body as a pillow against the cold hard ground. It is the least you can do after causing her so much pain.

"I am happy..." Judy blurts out unconvincingly.

Eventually, Judy calms down and you bring her to the bathroom. You know a hot shower will help her calm down. You stay by her side the whole time to help her. Even though she is completely exposed and defenceless in front of you, you do not take advantage of her; you cock does not even react.

Judy is no longer crying, having probably already cried out all the tears from her body. You help her dry herself and brings her to the living room. "Stay here. Let me make you some tea. You need something to warm yourself." You try to comfort her and after making sure that Judy has calmed down, you go to the kitchen to put some water to boil in the kettle and search for the tea leaves.

The water is still boiling and you decide to check on Judy. You made the right choice as you see her standing up in the living room.

Please log in to view the image

Half-naked, she looks absolutely stunning. The air around her only adds to her beauty. She is staring blankly at the floor for a moment until she finally notices you. Her eyelashes tremble. She does not say a word but you already know what she wants. You approach her and pull her into your arms. Your body responds naturally. Right now, the only thing Judy wants is to forget. She is not as aggressive as usual and instead, lets you take the lead. The kettle in the kitchen has long been forgotten.

You feel guilty but suppresses that feeling down in your heart. You swear to yourself that it is the first and last time that you will deliberately hurt one of your girls. To make up for it, you will realise her dream; you shall make her a queen, your queen.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)