Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by JohnLocke4 JohnLocke4

Round 2? What About Anna and Brian?

Getting What You Paid For (HD)

A few minutes later, Kenny sat on the edge of the bed while Gwen showed. The teen was positively glowing, a dumb smile plastered on his face that refused to dip. "That was so fucking awesome. Gwen. Gwen Pace. Fuck, dude." He softly said to himself, scarcely believing she was his first girl, "I owe Brian big time." Kenny's smile dipped, "Shit, the bowling alley." He reached over for his phone and quickly dialed Brian's number.

Brian answered the phone after half a dozen rings, "H-Hello?"

"Hey, Bry, sorry I disappeared like that, but I don't think Gwen and I are making it down to the bowling alley tonight." Kenny explained only hearing some husky breaths from Brian in return, "Dude are you okay?"

"F-Fine, I'm just...fuck...really busy right now. Let me call you back tomorrow." Kenny raised his brow in confusion before his eyes suddenly flared as he made out the distant sounds of a girl moaning and the slaps of hips colliding.

"Wait! Are you still with Anna?! Brian, where are you?!" Kenny immediately exclaimed only for the line to cut as Brian hung up the phone leaving Kenny toiling.

Kenny tossed his phone back onto the end table and slid a hand through his hair, "What the fuck..." He whispered under his breath. No way. There is no way that Brian got with Anna like that. She's never been the type to hook up so easily. But...he knew how to get me, Gwen, maybe he knew a way to get her too. She did say she was trying to change from her days in high school. Maybe that's what she meant. I mean, who says no to Brian White? Kenny sulked, he could feel a strong mix of anger and envy pooling in his chest with even a touch of sadness. It had been a hell of a long time since he had a crush on Anna, and Brian certainly was open to him on how he felt about the girl, but even still, it stung like hell to know he fucked her. Kenny heard the bathroom door, looking up he found Gwen walking towards him wrapped only in a towel, "Oh, Gwen. Hey."

"You alright?" Gwen sweetly asked as she sat down next to the teen, swiping her damp hair from her face, "You're making a face. Having regrets?"

"Huh? Oh, N-No!" Kenny exclaimed, immediately putting on a large smile, "This was the best night of my life, Gwen! I don't regret a thing!"

Gwen let out a murmuring laugh, enjoying Kenny's nervously loud assurances. "You know you did fine, for your first time with a girl. And..." Kenny sucked in a surprised inhale as Gwen's hand reached over and cupped his crotch. "You're fucking big. And I mean really big. I never knew you'd be packing such a big thing all this time. I'm happy I was the first to enjoy it." Kenny let out a soft exhale as Gwen's squeezing hand continued to grope him over his briefs. With grace, Gwen slid off the bed and knelt between Kenny's legs, "Why don't I help you experience something else tonight."

"G-Gwen you don't have t-to if you --" Kenny cut himself off as Gwen tugged at his briefs, pulling them down, and letting his cock spring free.

"I don't really like to do this, but for you...I think you've earned a special treat." Gwen took hold of Kenny's dick and leaned in, dragging her tongue up his base, letting it flick off at his tip, "Just make sure you don't **** me with this monster." Kenny's eyes were quickly turning dazed and he lazily nodded back, tensing as he felt Gwen's small pink tongue licking his cock once again.

Wrapping both her hands at the base of Kenny's cock, Gwen opened wide and sucked in the teen's tip. Kenny immediately fell back, staring up at the seeing while letting out low, groaning moans at the feeling of the first hot wet mouth he'd ever felt around his dick. Normally, Gwen never did this for guys, it always felt so one-sided, they'd end up forcing her head down, and most of the time she hated the taste of their bitter cum. But, seeing how eager Kenny was to please her earlier, going down without so much as a hint from her, Gwen figured he'd earned this.

Unfortunately, that also meant she had to learn on the fly how to handle a tool as big as Kenny had. Gwen's lips almost ached from how far they were **** to stretch around his bulbous tip and rivers of drool were running down over her hands. Still, even though she figured she was doing a shitty job, Kenny's loud moans were saying otherwise. Then, she felt his hand on her head, and the brunette flinched, ready to resist a hard push down. Yet, to her surprise, she only felt a very tender pet as Kenny's fingers slid through her damp hair.

Her green eyes flicked up as she felt her hair pulled away from her face and they locked on Kenny's. The teen let out a few heavy pants as he intently watched her, marveling at the sight of the beautiful party girl sucking him off. "God...you're so fucking beautiful." Kenny's absently let slip and Gwen felt a little twist inside her stomach. That wasn't the first time she'd heard that but there was definitely a difference in tone, something about Kenny's compliment sounded almost completely disconnected from what was happening right now.

With a slurp, Gwen pulled off Kenny's cock, and rolled her lower jaw. With a quick wipe of her chin, she got to her feet. "Fuck this, let's go again," Kenny's brow jumped up and he eagerly nodded his head. Gwen sucked in a very long breath, her cheeks went ever so slightly pink and she reached for her towel, letting it fall to the floor. The slim girl pivoted her waist, unconsciously doing what she could to take attention away from her chest, though Kenny's ogling eyes seemed well intent on exploring every last inch of her bare body. "Ken," Gwen snapped her fingers a few times, "Sex?"

"R-Right!" Kenny shook out of his trance and jumped up. Gwen moved to the and crawled on, sitting on her hands and knees, hanging her perfect ass off the bed, "Oh, like this?"

"Yeah, I wouldn't want to deny you a good view," Gwen gave her ass a teasing shake, "Come on, put it back in. I want to feel you stretch me out again." Kenny moved behind Gwen and rested a hand on her ass. Wrapping the other around his cock he spread her cheeks and now, with a hint more confidence than last time, brought his cock back to her slit.

With an equally pleased, exhaling moan, Kenny's cock slid into Gwen's cunt, her wetness rushing out to meet him, slathering down his length. Kenny's fingers dug into Gwen's ass and he let out a low groan, "God, Gwen, it feels even better than last time..." Gwen let out a gasp as Kenny started to thrust, his cock working its way in and out in sharper, more abrupt pumps.

"Fuck...so fucking good," Gwen mewed under her breath. Gwen eased her upper half down, keeping her back arched so her ass still stuck up high, "Fuck, Kenny, just like that." Kenny's pace picked up and his thighs clapped against Gwen's as he worked his cock tip to base with each thrust. With each hilt, he groaned and Gwen gasped, tensing her cunt around him. His second hand found its way to Gwen's ass, sliding along to her hip and gripping it tight.

A lewd wet sloshing filled Kenny's ears as each of his pumps was only making Gwen's cunt wetter and wetter. He couldn't help but look down, drinking in the sight of Gwen's squirming body and eventually watching the way her ass jiggled as his cock slid out of sight and their hips collided. "K-Kenny," Gwen suddenly moaned out, bringing his attention back to her head which was now cocked, her eyes lustfully glaring back at him. "My ass -- oh fuck -- s-slap my ass."

The simple plead was more than enough to drive Kenny's lustful mind right over the edge, his thrusting immediately turned rougher. With a panting breath, Kenny gripped Gwen with one hand and with the second brought a hand up and then swung it down. The smack was rather weak and very careful, "No, harder! Do it harder!" Gwen immediately cried out. Kenny swallowed the worry he had in screwing this up and did as told, swinging his hand again and this time connecting with a sharp, stinging smack, "Aah! Yes, fuck, Ken, just like that!"

Kenny bit on his bottom lip as Gwen's cunt unexpectedly spasmed around his pumping shaft, it was like heaven. Gwen's cries of passion grew louder and Kenny's breath became huskier as their fucking grew in intensity. Kenny gave an occasional smack when he felt like he needed it and every time he was rewarded with a joyous moan from Gwen and a tightening hold on his cock. However, this was still only Kenny's second time, and unsurprisingly this intensity was doing little to help hold him together. "I-I'm close!"

"Me too! Oh, I'm right there!" Gwen whined back, her voice almost pleading with him not to stop, "One more, do it one more time, please!" Kenny brought his hand up and swung down one final time, sending a jiggly shock wave through Gwen's right cheek. Gwen's head flew up and she let out a cry of ecstasy, cumming around Kenny's cock. At the very same moment, Kenny ground his hips against Gwen's and gritted his teeth, hissing out a growl as he pumped out a second, but even larger load into the brunette. The pair collapsed into panting bliss.


Thirty minutes later Kenny was lazily strolling back to his apartment with a smile glued to his face. He ended up feeling even grateful for the fact that his walk was going to be a little extended, enjoying the time to bask in the afterglow. The teenager pulled out his phone, looking down at the screen in victory. I got her number, she said she wanted to do it again. Gwen Pace wants to do that with me again. God damn, I have to be dreaming. I can't believe this fucking happened tonight. I'm not a virgin anymore! This has got to be the best night of my life!

Kenny slid the phone back into his pocket and continued to stroll with a hum. His carefree mindset didn't last very long, however. Anna never texted...not once. Kenny felt his smile drifting away. And Brian...when I called him he was...I know I heard him with someone. They were moaning. Anna didn't text and Brian was hooking up with someone. Kenny knew he shouldn't have felt jealous, it wasn't fair to either Brian or Anna but he couldn't help it. He didn't like thinking that Anna would sleep with him so easily.

Kenny checked his watch and slowed to a crawl on his walk. It's late but...I could go to her apartment, check-in, and see if Brian is there. Maybe I'm wrong and she wasn't with Brian, but I'd know for sure. And I could at least apologize for leaving her to go with Gwen while I'm there. Kenny felt himself hesitate and let out a groan. God, that's pathetic and petty. I'm only thinking this because I don't want to see her with Brian...I shouldn't do this. If she's with him that's her choice, I can't decide that. Kenny tapped his foot a few quick times, weighing the choice out.

Kenny Head Home Or To Anna?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)