Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by IronLacedCarbon IronLacedCarbon

What's next?

Fucking the twins.

Laying flat on her back in the shower, Amy shivered and giggled as Alyssa’s face was buried in her crotch, licking and slurping the blonde’s pussy with enthusiastic glee on all-fours.

“Not bad, but…” Amy began, perching herself up on her elbows as she teased her nipples. “It’s like this is the first time you’ve eaten me out before.”

With a long and slow lick, Alyssa came up to look at her from between her sister’s toned runner’s thighs.

“That’s because it is.” She giggled as water from the shower streamed across her pretty face. “Dave used the bone on you, remember?”

“I just remember you being way better at this, is all I’m saying.”

Alyssa rolled her eyes and looked back, watching as Dave got down on his knees behind her and let his girthy cock land between her soft cheeks like an oversized hotdog.

Dave gave her round butt a sharp smack, causing the raven-haired emo to gasp, moan, and bite down on her bottom lip as she wiggled her hips.

He couldn’t help but take a second to admire her wet ass and the plump lips of her freshly-shaved pussy as they poked out from between her closed thighs.

“I can’t tell you how long I’ve wanted to do this.” He growled, giving her ass another smack, turning the left cheek a shade of pink. “It’s a good thing your holes are elastic, or else this might do some damage.”

The wishbone throbbed in Dave’s right hand.

“Wait, how did you know-…” Alyssa began to say, but then giggled. “Oh, right.”

“Less talking, more licking.” Amy said, reaching forward to guide her twin’s face right back down to her cunt, and Alyssa resumed her climate felatio. “Mm, much better.”

Dave smirked as he backed up slightly to line his meaty cock up with Alyssa’s pussy, then pushed the head against her folds. Despite how wet she was, it took a bit of pressure for him to enter, but once he did, it felt as though her twitching cunt was pulling him into her. Alyssa started off with soft moans, but those muffled moans turned into muffled wails as Dave continued deeper and deeper, feeling the walls of her incredibly tight and hot pussy stretch to accommodate his size.

“This is so fucking hot…” Amy said with a wicked smile, holding her sisters twitching head firmly against her own pussy as she watched her brother penetrate her. “We should’ve let you join us a long time ago, Dave.”

“Better late than never.” Dave chuckled and grunted as he completely bottomed out inside of Alyssa, his cock thumping inside of her as she squeezed him tight. “God, Aly. You feel so fucking good that I almost don’t want to pull out… Almost.”

Dave backed up and slid his length almost completely out of her, then rammed it all back inside, causing the young girl to scream into Amy’s cunt.

He started with a slow pace, but thanks to his giant overflowing balls, Dave could already feel himself reaching a climax. In just a few short moments, he was pounding away at Alyssa’s trembling rump. If he were in better shape, he’d probably be fucking her harder, but he was giving enough **** for the slaps of his crotch against her cheeks to echo all throughout the bathroom.

Before he realized it, his big cock began pumping out a fresh load. Since he was in the process off pulling back, the powerful torrent of cum pushed his rubbery meat out of her and began spraying both girls like a miniature firehose. Dave grabbed his cock and began feverishly stroking it as he just kept cumming and cumming, much to Amy’s perverted delight. The eager blonde giggle-moaned with her mouth wide open, trying to catch any of his spunk that was being flung around the shower. After about half-a-minute, his orgasm began to subside, and the post-nut hyper-sensitivity in his cock only lasted for the briefest of moments as he could actually feel his balls refilling with another fresh batch.

As he rested his cock back atop Alyssa’s butt, Dave did his best to catch his breath.

Mentally, he was used to cumming that much on a daily basis, and couldn’t imagine a world where he came and needed a recharge period like a normal person. However, in his false memories, the drains in his house were always clogged up with his cum, which didn’t appear to be the case since both the water from the shower and his cum seemed to flow down with ease for now. The wishbone sure was cool, Dave thought to himself when he stood up from behind Alyssa, who looked as though she was barely conscious as she quietly mumbled and moaned into Amy’s pussy.

Still holding onto Alyssa’s head, she pulled it up and away from her crotch to look into her sister’s glassy eyes.

“Did you cum?”

“Uh huh…” Alyssa said, her mouth hanging open and panting. “F-Few times…”

“Well, that makes one of us.” Amy sighed, the released her head and let it fall onto the shower floor with a gentle splash before looking up into her brother’s grinning face. “My turn.”

“If you insist.” Dave shrugged, giving his hard cock a playful slap. “How do you want me?”

“Flat on your back.”

Dave didn’t need to be told twice. He got down onto the shower floor and laid next to Alyssa, who was still face-down on the shower floor with her ass still perched in the air. As he did so, Amy was standing up and stepped over to where he lay.

She was soon standing over him with her feet planted beside of his hips.

Amy knelt down and grabbed his throbbing cock, getting just low enough to line it up with her juicy pussy.

Dave crossed his hands behind his head, toying with the wishbone. He was tempted to make her pussy stretchy and more accommodating like Alyssa’s, but since Amy was the one in control this time, he thought it’d be nice to see just how much of his cock the former she could take. However, he did have another wish in mind as the fit blond lowered herself onto him

“I hope those big fake tits of yours don’t slow you down. I’m sure they’re as heavy as they look.” Dave said, and the bone pulsed.

In less than a second, two perfectly-round orbs ballooned from the blonde’s chest, her small nipples expanded from dimes to the size of quarters. They weren’t as big as their mom’s, more comparable to cantaloupes than volleyballs. The sudden downward pull of gravity knocked Amy off balance and caused her to lose her footing and slip.

Amy let out a yelp of surprise as the head of his thick cock pushed into the folds of her pussy.

“Oh, f-fuck!” She growled through grit teeth, her expression flashing back and forth between distraught and pleasure. Instead of trying to pull off of him, Amy remained where she was for a long moment, looking down at her big fake tits in mild confusion before lowering herself further onto him.

As Amy’s moans grew more frequent and higher-pitched, Dave relished the strangely familiar sensation of her uber-tight pussy stretching seamlessly around his cock, just as Alyssa’s did.

It didn’t take long for the busty blonde to completely bottom out on his cock, now straddling his midsection as her eyes fluttered and rolled back.

“H-Holy shit, Dave…” She stammered, reaching up to grope, rub, and squeeze her extra-firm tits. “Y-You’re so f-fucking big!”

As she slowly began to grind back and forth against his crotch, Dave wondered how she was able to take it so easily.

Noticing movement out of the corner of his eye, he turned to see Alyssa rolling from her position on the shower floor to sit up next to the pair.

The raven-haired cutie’s face was dreamy and vacant, as if still dazed. That was immediately shaken off when she saw her sister’s new tits, though. Her eyes went wide, and she quickly got up on her knees and scooted closer to the pairing.”

“Oh my God…” She whispered in awe, reaching out to feel one of Amy’s fake tits with both hands. “They’re so hard!” She giggled, turning towards Dave where he lay on the floor. “Are they implants?”

“Duh, stupid.” Amy said, scrunching up her face. “It was your idea for me to get these things.”

The girls exchanged confused expressions, while Amy’s was a bit more twisted with pleasure from grinding on Dave’s cock.

The look only lasted a moment though, and they each said:

“The bone.”

“Your magic thing is really c-confusing.” Amy said to Dave. “It’d be nice if you could just make it so that our memories aren’t g-getting fucked up when you use it.”

“I probably could.” Dave said, reaching up and giving one of her bimbo tits a hard slap, causing them to bounce and wobble around on her chest, but they didn’t jiggle at all. “But this is way hotter.”

The bone pulsed.

“Mmf.” Amy moaned with a smile that looked like it was coming from someone who’s mind was melting while her entire body shuddered and vibrated. “I guess you’ve g-got a point.”

Alyssa snickered as she gave Amy’s tit one last squeeze before pulling away and lying back down next to Dave.

The young man was caught off-guard when she leaned in and began making out with her brother, sending his cock into a throbbing fit inside of Amy from the proverbial “cherry on top” on the taboo nature of their actions.

After that, Amy gripped Dave’s slender stomach and slowly began to bounce on his twitching dick. Her mindless squeaks and moans from before quickly transitioned into full-blown wails of raw pleasure. She squeezed him tighter as she came, but she didn’t stop or slow down at all.

Dave lost himself, his cock was being milked and his tongue danced around with Alyssa’s in their mouths. One of his hands had reached up to hang onto Amy’s big tits while the other was exploring Alyssa’s smooth wet back. This was easily the most amazing moment of his life, Dave faintly thought to himself.

His upcoming orgasm caught him by surprise again, and Amy firmly planted herself down on his crotch and screamed as was pumped full of an obscene amount of hot baby gravy.

Amy slowly collapsed on top of him, her big firm tits pressing into his chest she was still impaled on his fat cock.

“Oh fuck… Fuck… I-I… I can’t feel my legs...”

“Feels good, doesn’t it.” Alyssa giggled after breaking the kiss with Dave. “Mine still feel like jelly too.”

“I feel great.” Dave said with a relaxed sigh. “You guys need to step up your game.”

Amy raised her head just so she and Alyssa could give him an annoyed look.

With the hot water quickly running out, everyone soon washed up and resisted fucking each other for the next couple of minutes.

Dave would’ve continued regardless, but he hadn’t eaten yet, and the thought of his naked mom cooking spaghetti made his stomach growl.

What’s next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)