Fuck Natalie

Aaron sighed, looking apologetically at Allie.

"If I get stuck in there, can you pull me out?"

Allie nodded.

"Not if I eat you first!" Natalie drawled, clearly salivating.

Without anything to hold onto and not wanting to fuse Natalie to his hand, Aaron grabbed the only thing he could think of. As he came back into the bedroom holding the original physical potato, Natalie began babbling in a terror that was clearly feigned.

"Oh no! Not that! Oh my god, that's so fucked up! Don't put me back in there! I might disappear completely! Your sister is still trapped in here and you're going to **** us bo-"

Her cries were cut off as Aaron attached the backside of Natalie's pussy to the vegetable, instead crying out suggestively before finally settling down.

"You know," she said. "It's actually not that bad in here. Kinda familiar, you know?"

"No," Aaron said, picking up the potato like a flesh-light and holding Natalie's mouth against his flaccid cock.

Natalie's tongue immediately snaked out to a surprising length, twirling around Aaron and pulling him into her where she began rhythmically squeezing him.

Aaron hissed as his body responded, despite his ****. It wasn't long until he found himself at full mast and gently raising and lower Natalie along his cock while she made delighted squealing sounds.

It was clear from the strength and speed of her sucking that Natalie wanted him to cum inside her, but he was having trouble getting himself into the right headspace. He found himself wondering idly how he was able to pull Natalie all the way down to the base of his cock when the potato was barely two thirds as big as he was.

"Allie?" Aaron said.

"Mm?"

"Can you do this for me?"

Allie shuffled next to Aaron, taking Natalie from his hand and began gliding it up and down his cock. At a silent gesture, she leant towards him and pressed her lips against his.

Aaron's cock leapt and he heard Natalie squeak in humiliated joy. Allie wasn't much of a kisser, or at least didn't have the will to be one, but her vacant trusting eyes gave Aaron a perverse kick that brought him quickly to orgasm.

Natalie hungrily drank Aaron's cum, and he felt the now dreaded current tugging at his soul.