Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by Alostsoul Alostsoul

What’s your punishment?

Froatting and a competition

“So I thought about it, and I think you two need to learn some self control.” Amy says pacing around the two of you.

“So I have devised a little competition to help both of you learn a little bit of discipline.”

Amy goes into her dresser again getting some more rope, and some sort of plastic object. She then kneels down, holding the plastic object in front of your faces so you can get a good look. The object is pink, small, and a bit phalic shaped yet your still unsure of what exactly it is. Ava however seems to instantly recognize what the strange item is as her eyes immediately go wide upon seeing it.

“This is a chastity cage, you every heard of that Doug?” Amy asks a small smirk on her face.

Hearing the name jogs your memory, and you remember hearing about what a chastity cage was from a forum you read once. To see one in real life though felt kinda of surreal.

“Y-yeah I think I know what that is.”

“Okay then you should know that you should try to avoid getting put in one right...?” Amy teases.

“Right...” You think you know where this is going.

“Unfortunately that’s what’s going to happen to the loser of this little competition.”

“That’s okay with you right Harper?” Amy asks looking back at Haper who is lounging on the couch.

“Yeah that’s fine only important parts I need of her is her asshole an her mouth.” Harper says waving a hand to give Amy the go ahead.

“H-hey!” Ava pouts, a bit insulted at her dick being considered “unimportant”.

“So then what exactly IS this competition?” You ask.

“Glad you asked Doug!”

Amy then begins to maneuver the two of yours bodies. She tilts you and Ava on your sides having your front pointed slightly towards each other. Ava is trying her best not look at you while this happens. She committing her self to keeping a stiff upper lip, really attempting to conceal any hint of emotions she might be giving off.

“So what I’m gonna do is I’m gonna touch, stroke, and jerk both of your unruly dicks...”

A rope is then looped around both yours and Ava’s waist by Amy. Amy then tightens the loop, forcing your crotches to press up against each other.

To finish things off Amy takes off her hair tie letting her pony tail down. Her hair in the front now covering more of her right side though leaving enough of her face free to see. She then puts the hair tie around the base of both of your cocks, leaving them bound to one another.

“... and who ever spurts first loses.” Amy says reaching a hand down and tapping two fingers on the heads of yours and Ava’s cock.

“And just to make everything fair I will be testing the two of you at the same time, so no complaints about me going easier or harder on one and not the other got it?”

Now you understand why Amy had you two bound like this. With your cocks tied together Amy is able to easily grab on to both of your dicks at once.

“Heh, nice...” Haper says watching.

“Oooooo that’s smart.” Riley says, impressed by Amy’s resourcefulness.

Despite her best attempt to keep her self stolid whole situation makes Ava go red as a tomato. Both you, and Ava in the nude. The other girls watching. Having to look at each other, with your penises in a loving “embrace”. It’s all just to much for her to keep her **** body suppressed. Heck, it even seems as though part of her doesn’t think this is so bad, as you can feel her cock start swell against your own. Almost as if she can feel your gaze on her, Ava squeezes her eyes shut and grits her trying her best to pretend this isn’t happening. This doesn’t last long as her eyes quickly pop back open, and she gives you a glare.

“Stop starting!” She squeaks angrily at you, before returning to looking off to the side.

“Aha S-sorry.” You apologize looking away.

Even though your both tied up you’ve seen how unexpectedly strong, and wild Ava could be so you think it’s best not to piss her off. Besides it’s not like she’s going to be tied forever.

“Awww don’t be so cold Ava, the two of you look cute together.” Riley teases.

“Yeah they do look cute don’t they, hehe?” Amy says agreeing

Amy then grabs the lube from the bedside table, and squirts a big glop of it on to her hand. Again you can feel Ava’s cock growing hard as Amy sits down in front of both of you, a little bit of the lube falling onto your skin as she slowly reaches forward. As the lube drips on to you it makes you shiver the lube cool almost cold to the touch. Yet your whole body feels hot with anticipation. Your heart beat is racing as Amy’s hand comes closer and close to your cock.

Finally she makes contact, and her soft hand envelopes the heads of both yours and Ava cocks. Amy starts slow, the palm of her hand drifting over the underside of your penises all the way to your base.

“A-Ah.” Ava makes a little gasp as you mange to stifle your own.

Amy then at a crawling pace slides her hand back up, running a thumb over the tops of your dicks as she does. She’s only teasing the two of you right now, like a predatory playing with its prey. She then increases the strength of her grip, and begins to stroke you two at a painfully slow pace. It’s such crazy sensation to be stroked with some one else, the extra heat and feeling of Ava’s larger cock against yours is a blank experience. It does feels kind of good though, the constant contact of someone else dick as it’s squeezed against your own feels actually better then a normal hand job. Well it would be, if Amy wasn’t going so painful slow. Then almost sensing your desire for more stimulation Amy fully takes her hand off your cock.

“Ohhh...” Missing her touch you can’t help but groan and thrust upwards into the air, grinding against Ava’s cock as you do.

“Hey...ahhh..,stop that...,” Ava gasps as you rubbing your cock against her’s causes little tingles of pleasure.

This makes Ava **** start to thrust her own hips making her cock rub against yours. Both you lose yourself momentarily just thrusting your erections agains each other, addicted to the small sensations of pleasure, The girls all giggle as the two of you hump and squirm against each other like **** horny animals.

“Wow if I let you guys keep going like this your gonna cum without me even getting involved.” Amy laughs

She then has a dark glimmer in her eyes, and squeezes both of your cocks hard making it so thrusting is painful for you.

“But I’m not one who likes to take a backseat, so calm down and stay still you naughty brats.” Amy scolds.

You and Ava both relent holding still, and not making any further attempts to rub up against each other. Stastsfied with your submission Amy loosens her grip and starts to slowly stroking you again. Up and down, up and down, Amy pumps you at a snails pace. It’s a truly sweet ****, every move of her hand only makes you **** for her to go faster. You try to thrust your hips again, and Amy quickly removes her hand again.

“Baaaadddd booooyyyyyy........” Amy says in a low sing song voice.

She then gives your balls a quick flick
making you wince in pain.

“I did say this was a punishment as well as a competition Doug, so you need to get it though your head that your just gonna to have to endure what ever I give you alright.” Amy says a bit of sadism in her tone of voice.

It’s mean, it’s cruel, and yet it turns you on. Amy’s unkind words as well as the lasting tingle of pain in your balls, makes your dick twitch happily. You had never really thought of yourself as masochist, sure you didn’t really stop your younger sister Sahra when she would tease you. Or complain when your older sister Crystal would pin you down on the floor and tickle you till you begged for mercy, yet that wasn’t a sign of something underlining right? You don’t get to ponder the thought more though as Amy suddenly does something completely devious.

“Now then lets try this...” Amy then takes her hand, and palms yours and Ava’s cockheads.

The sensation is light, dull, and makes you clench up. Your whole spine is tingling, as you stiffen your body and try to suppress your urge to thrust again. You want more stimulation, while at the same time also wanting it to completely stop, the palming being more distressing then something enjoyable. Ava seem in the same site strains as you, as you can see her visible shaking under Amy palming. Though you don’t really need to as he body against yours you can actually FEEL her she’s trembling so much. Amy rubs, and rubs the tip of your cocks vigorously like she is trying to clean some unseen stain from them. The light touch is messing with your bodies, your both spazzing and shaking, and you feel like your about to pee yourself.

“Sttttooaapppp plllleeaassseeee.” You beg desperately.

“Awww don’t be such a baby Doug it’s not like I’m hurting you.” Amy says as she picks up the pace.

“Yeah don’t be a baby!” Harper jeers from the couch.

“Ughhhh nooo moreeee.” Ava also starts to beg, as she’s losing her self as well.

“Fine fine, I’ll let you whines off the hook this once.” Amy starts to slow down her pace till finally she fully stops.

You and Ava both breath a sigh of relief as that bit of **** is finally over. However Amy isn’t done with harassing the two of you, not till one of you cums. She then moves on to try out a new technique. Amy makes her fore finger and thumb into a tight O shape holding her other fingers out of the way. She then lowers the O on to your cocks, not giving any leeway as she squeezes your cocks past the O ring. Her hold is tight, an intense. The pressure very pleasing to feel as she starts to slide the ring up, and down the length of your cocks.

“This little hold I call “the pinch,” it’s meant to simulate the feeling of tight virgin asshole, oh though I guess you’ve never exactly felt what that’s like huh, Doug?” Amy teases.

She shakes her head chuckling, and gives you a wink.

“Maybe one day though, especially if you keep hanging with us.” Amy says in a joking tone, though something tells you she’s being sincere.

“Oh hell yeah we get into tons of wild shit.” Riley says still watching intently.

Amy then starts to increase the pace, going quite face now you can feel the pleasure building with in you.

“Oh, oh oh oh oh.” Ava too as you hear her make tiny moans under breath

“You know it doesn’t even look like they’re trying to compete here Amy.” Harper says

“Maybe they both want their cocks locked up?” Riley giggles.

Shoot, that’s right if you lose this little game you can say bye bye to your dick for however long Amy plans to keep it locked up. You squeeze you eyes shut, trying your best to ignore the pleasure of Amy’s “pinch”. It’s a difficult task though as the narrow hole drags feelings of pleasure though your entire shaft. The arosual forcefully drawn out from you, it’s a strange yet enticing feeling. Having your body being played with like some personal toy.... Maybe you were a masochist, or maybe Amy was just really good at getting you off.

“Aahhh...” You inhale sharply, then letting out a little gasp.

You feel like your resolves is wavering, as the need for release builds with in you. As you feel Ava’s own dick start to pulse you believe she’s reaching her limit as well.

“Heh okay guys, time to see who really can hold out the longest.” Amy says as she stops for a moment to wrap all of her fingers around both you’re cocks.

Then she stars pistioning her hand up and down, jerking you two at a dizzying speed. You an Ava both writhe in pleasure, as you almost in unison arch your backs off the ground. God your dick feels like it’s melting in pleasure. Your cock is so hard right now your precum mixing into the lube as dribbles down your tip. Ava pants next to you, you feel her dick throbbing against yours. This attack there’s no way you can hold out against it, all you can do is pray that Ava breaks before you do.

“Come on you guys gonna pop for, me come on now, shoot, shoot, shoot.” Amy speaks softly as she encourages you to orgasm.

“You guys should just cum already it will feel sooooooo good.” Riley says tempting you to cum as well.

“Yeah you two gonna pop, come on pop right here for all of us to see.” Harper says getting in on the action as well.

Your heart is racing now, your balls retracting upwards you aren’t even gonna last a minute longer. As if to put the finally nail in the coffin Amy takes her free and gently taps the underside of yours and Ava’s balls. The dull slightly painful contact is the last straw, as release takes you and you climax shooting your seed.

“Eghhheghhh egrahhhhhhhh.” You grunt as you pump ropes of cum up into the air only for it to fall back onto your belly.

“Aaaahggg aaaaaaahhhh.” At the same time Ava cries out and shoots her own respective load, it bigger and more powerful then your own, so much in fact that it ends up splattering onto your stomach as well as her’s.

“There we go, there we go just let it all out...” Amy encourages both you Ava softly, as she’d continues to jerk you with one hand and tap your balls with the other.

Both your do just that, orgasmic ecstasy making your bound bodies spasm and shake, as your minds turn into mush in the pleasure. No thoughts run through your heads only feeling, only white, only bliss. As you shoot again, and again, and again, your lower half feels like it’s melting, there is only release and the clenching of your own body. The dick tied to yours is almost red hot now as warm cum to flows from the tip, Ava’s own orgasm almost in sync with your own. In a weird way you can almost feel her pleasure as well. As strange connection of body and the soul. Of her being so close to you, of you feeling the same hand that made you both come.

The slowly the two of you start to calm down, as well as you cocks as well, the last drops of their cum dribbling out as the orgasmic trip ends. You, Ava both breathe deeply now, sucking in air as your heartbeats start to return to normal.

“There we go.” Amy coos softly as she takes her hand, and strokes gently over your and Ava’s abdomen, spreading the cum all over both of your bodies.

“Wow Amy you got a two for one.” Harper says sounding impressed.

“Yeah-but wait what happens now do they both lose then?” Riley asks

“Now that’s a good question didn’t think of that...” Amy pounders the thought for a moment as she grabs some more cum with her hand and starts spreading over Ava’s and yours nipples.

The cum starts to cool as it’s left your body, and tickles you slightly as Amy glides her hands over your chest. Then out of the corner of your eyes you, and Ava both exchange a worried glance. Hopefully whatever’s Amy decides here she is merciful with her decision. After such a great orgasm you couldn’t even conceive losing access to your cock.

So what’s Amy’s decision?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)