Fivesome Part 2: Exploring Entries and Exits

Buttholes.

To be fair, your attention wasn’t entirely on buttholes, it was just sort of distracted by one specific butthole that was staring back at you.

Namely, Maeve’s.

The five of you had shifted to the bedroom, and Maeve had knelt on the edge of the bed and wiggled her deliciously soft ass at you and said. “Come fuck my pussy,” in that British accent of hers and then leaned her head down low, arching her back and presenting herself fully. She’d already been riding Sabrina’s strap-on before so it wasn’t much of a problem for you to step up, drag the head of your cock through her pretty, slick labia and then ease into her in one long, slow thrust. And then it didn’t take long for her to be bouncing her ass back at you hard enough that it was clapping against your pelvis as you met her by thrusting forward.

You were both groaning, but you felt a little lost with your hands - with Gemma or Sabrina, you would have grabbed their waist, leaned over them, or gotten a handful of hair near their scalp. Or, if it was Sabrina and she was getting close, pinching her sides the way she liked. But Maeve had specifically told you not to get anywhere near holding her down, so you weren’t really sure what to do.

That left you with one particularly nice option, so you grabbed her ass cheeks and started massaging them. Maeve’s entire body was soft, from her thighs to her stomach to her tits, and her ass was no exception. It was possible the only parts of her that weren’t soft were her sharp jawline and her penetrating gaze. Her ass cheeks were no different and were gloriously squishy and jiggly as you manipulated, squeezed, smacked and wiggled them. Which all then led to you looking at the aforementioned butthole every time you spread her cheeks apart. It was… well, it was super fuckable. Her anal ring was a little more prominent than the women you’d been with before, centred in a little divot between her cheeks but puckering out like a perfect little wrinkly doughnut or bagel with a tight little hole in the centre.

Meanwhile, the other three girls in the sexcapade you were participating in were engaged just up the bed from you. Sabrina and Gemma had gotten Amanda onto her back on the bed, her feet pointed mostly towards you and Maeve which gave you a perfect view of the pretty pussy that had already ridden your cock, along with the way her giant tits fell on her chest when she laid back. Sabrina was kneeling on one side of her, feeding the strap-on dildo she was wearing to Amanda. Gemma had put on the other strap-on and knelt to the side of her, and both your girlfriends were grinning and chuckling as Amanda used a hand on each dildo to jack them off as she switched back and forth sucking on them. That activity left your girlfriends free to let their hands wander, teasing Amanda’s breasts with groping, little slaps and pinching her nipples, and even reaching down to tease over her stomach or sides before sliding fingers across her labia. The laughing and moaning from the trio just added to the auditory delights of the room.

“Maeve,” you grunted, pulling out and halting your thrusts - she bounced back on you a couple more times before raising up to her elbows and looking back at you while she continued to rock back and forth on your cock, just a little more lightly. Her gaze was lusty, and the way her lips parted as she took deep breaths was utterly hot. “Are you good if I start playing with your ass, get you ready for later?” you asked.

She nodded, almost urgently. “Do it,” she said.

You leaned forward, trying not to get too low or press down on her as per her request, and she saw what you were doing and opened her mouth to let you feed her two of your fingers which she sucked on and then swirled her tongue around. Then she sucked your thumb for good measure too.

“Now finger my ass while you fuck me,” she pretty much ordered you.

There wasn’t a shot that you would deny that order/request.

First, since it was easiest, you used your thumb and wedged it into that little doughnut hole at the same time as you pressed your cock back into her deeply. She moaned deep in her chest at that, and you wiggled your thumb in deeper until it was up the first knuckle. Her ass was tight, maybe the tightest you’d felt with a finger other than Sabrina, but she also didn’t give any sign of being uncomfortable and accepted the digit fairly easily.

You gave her ass a smack with your other hand, and then the two of you started fucking properly again with just a little less forceful vigour than before.

Gemma and Sabrina had shifted a little, Sabrina sliding down to practically snuggle up to Amanda as they both were sucking on Gemma’s strap-on. Of course, your little sexual dynamo had let her hands wander as she made out with Amanda around the tip of the dildo and she had two fingers in the other girl, sawing them in and out of her quickly. Amanda’s gasps and moans were short and quiet, but you saw the same telltale signs that she might have been having those ‘small orgasms’ that she’d had while riding you.

Your thumb got swapped out for a finger, which made you slow your thrusts a bit more but got a much louder response from Maeve as she moaned and started to rotate her hips as you fucked her. A little wiggling of the finger and you ended slowly working it in and out of her ass at a different speed than your thrusts.

Then you started to press a second one in and she came. It wasn’t a loud explosion like you’d kind of been expecting - it more felt like Maeve lost all muscle control and she went limp, including the clenching of her pussy and anal ring. It only lasted for a split second, but she slumped forward with a wordless “Uungh,” and pretty much went face-first into the mattress. Then her ass and pussy both sprang back into action, clenching down, and she pushed herself back up onto her elbows.

“Good?” you asked, more if she was good than if it was.

“Very,” she said, looking over her shoulder as she tossed her curly hair a bit. “Now get that second finger in me.”

I popped it past her anal ring and her eye twitched as her lips parted in a gasp. “Like that?”

“Little rougher,” she groaned. “In and out. And don’t stop fucking my pussy.”

You pulled your fingers out of her, dropped a wad of spit onto her asshole, and then **** your fingers back in.

“Yes!” she groaned. “Just like that.”

Breakthebar erotica is powered by Patreon, where OFG chapters are now releasing 5+ chapters ahead. PM if interested in making a Commission.