Finishing the Game

At this point, nobody knew whose turn it was, but we didn’t really care anymore. Stella went for the second time in a row. “I haven’t tried Danny’s cock yet and I need my pussy filled now!” She said, crawling over to Danny. She rolled over in the puddle of her own squirt, completely soaking her back, and lifted her legs, inviting Danny to slide into her with ease. He grabbed her legs and started fucking her on the floor in front of us, and my cock got hard again even though I just came.

Caroline then got next to Stella and gave her a long kiss before laying down next to her in the squirt puddle and lifting her legs up as well. “Come on Barry, I need some cock too!” I raced over and lined my cock up with her cunt. I’d known Caroline for a while, so this motion was very familiar to me, and the warmth of her pussy around my sensitive cock made me moan. I grabbed a handful of her titties, which were a little bit larger than Stella’s and Anna’s, and I started moving myself further inside of her.

Anna and Josh joined us last, getting right next to me and Caroline. Josh was a childhood friend of ours, and he had always been especially close to my sister. When we started high school, they practiced kissing each other under the bleachers so that they would be prepared, and after a few days it became a daily tradition for them. Eventually this evolved and they tried all sorts of other things that I would sometimes hear them talk about.

Caroline writhed under me, in between Stella and Anna, and occasionally turning to kiss them both. My eyes went over her body over and over again, from her beautiful face, to her great tits, down to her sexy thighs. Caroline wasn’t chubby, but she did have a bit more body fat than the other two girls, and it gave her body a wonderful shape. Her legs wrapped around me while I fucked her, and I ran my hands up her sides, causing her to shiver.

I glanced to my side to see Stella, moaning and screaming while she got reamed by Danny. She kept yelling, “Harder, Harder!” as she was already being fucked impossibly fast. She was absolutely insatiable, and Danny had a hard time keeping up. Her tits bounced and her whole body moved while her pussy was pounded.

I looked to my other side to my sister, who was currently sucking on Josh’s thumb while he fucked her. She held her hand on top of Josh’s while they both rubbed her pussy, right above where his dick was gliding into her. I watched him slide another finger into her mouth, making her stifled moans even more adorable while she sucked with enthusiasm. My eyes wandered back to my sister’s pussy, which looked incredibly hot as it took in Josh’s cock. I obviously got horny watching it, but there was a second emotion that I wasn’t expecting: jealousy. I usually didn’t mind hearing about their practice kissing, or fingering, or blowjobs, but actually watching my sister get fucked gave me so much more envy than I expected. I needed to fuck my sister badly. The innocuous kissing and touching that had started over the past couple days seemed good at first, but I couldn’t handle it for much longer. I couldn’t stop imagining how hot it would be if it was me fucking her instead. If it was my cock gliding into her tight pussy instead of Josh’s

Josh seemed to notice my staring, and joked, “Eyes on your own paper, buddy.”

I chuckled and returned my focus to Caroline. After all, her cunt felt wonderful, and she didn’t deserve me being distracted. I increased my pace and went down to kiss her.

Suddenly, Danny started loudly moaning, and announced that he was cumming. He pushed deep into Stella, and I watched as he pulled out of my girlfriend, his cum leaking out of her.

“God damn, that was good. She’s a keeper, Barry,” he said and relaxed after such an intense fucking.

Josh came a few seconds before me, and grunted as he released his load inside my sister. I couldn’t help myself from thinking about my own cum filling up her pussy, and it brought me to orgasm right after him. I gazed into Caroline’s eyes as I came, and I let seed go loose inside of her. She squirmed with pleasure as I filled her up, and I groped her tits as I pulled out.

We all sat on the couch, still naked, and pretty exhausted from the fun game. The girls sat together and played with the cum that was flowing down their legs, making sure to get little tastes of all three of them.

“I love getting creampied,” Caroline said as my cum oozed out of her. Stella scooped up some of the dripping cum from Caroline’s pussy and scooped it back into her mouth. The three girls kissed and swapped the cum back and forth while us guys watched. After a little while, Stella spit my cum onto Anna’s pussy folds to spread it around more.

After that, we were all pretty worn out, except for Stella who was somehow still masturbating, so we just relaxed for a while in the living room before everyone had to leave.