Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by mysteriopark mysteriopark

What secret?

Finishing Secrets

Collin's eyes were shut tight trying to focus on lasting a bit longer but her lusty and coy voice was edging him further, "What?"

"That girl you fingered is Tori."

Shocked he looked over in disbelief only to find Tori on the floor looking back at them biting her lip. She was fingering her asshole while she rode a stranger and looked at him and smiled. Her pert bubble butt was facing him again and he had a perfect view of her pussy being stuffed.

"Aw fuck!" Collin cursed feeling his hold on his upcoming climax loosening.

Please log in to view the image

Athena wasn't planning on slowing down, savoring his slow deep strokes and looking him dead in the eye, "She told me she had the hots for you but I didn't want you guys to date so I never told you...look how she watches you while she's fucking that guy. Bet you she's wishing it was you baby."

Collin groaned and rapidly pulled out bursting all over the blonde's crotch head becoming faint. Athena was loudly laughing and moaning feeling his hot load on her.

Finally looking down she just had sinful victory written all over her face wearing a load between her thighs above her pussy, some leaking down over it. "Mhmmm that was hot."

Collin's balance was totally fucked and just smiled affectionately at her. She responded with a dirty but loving smile back. "Fuck that was the best orgasm I've ever had Athena..."

Athena coated her fingers in his cum and brought them to her fingers eyeing it hungrily, "You gave me like- a ton of bests over and over, sir." She then casually slipped her fingers in her mouth and rolled her eyes at the taste shuddering. "Speaking of..."

"Did you mean it?" Collin collapsed on the couch beside her trying to turn to the girls still enthusiastically fucking.

Athena turned to him slightly but kept her legs apart to give him the view and allow access for more of her new favorite treat. "Mean what?"

"That Tori likes me?"

Athena slipped her fingers from her mouth too quickly, some of his cum dripping on her chin, "Oh! She doesn't like you baby. She fucking wants you. Big difference. She want's your big dick to take her." Athena cleaned off her chin with a sly smile, "I mean she thinks your cool and cute and whatever but it's a big 'I wanna fuck Collin' vibe. She might like you though."

Collin moaned and his half hard cock throbbed making eye contact with Tori while she was on her knees jerking the man off, cum dripping down her lips and chin. She just let it drip, slowly jerking the meat in her face, eyes never leaving his.

Please log in to view the image

"Holy shit!"

Athena looked and waved lazily just getting a smile from her facialized friend in return. "Just a heads up though big boy. She's....freaky. Like really fucking freaky. I've never really thought about fucking my best friend before but I'm so down to fuck her with you." Athena's expression changed to amusement, "But like I said make sure you can handle her because I've heard stories and she's a lot."

Collin nodded and swallowed. She was still looking at him now alone on her knees coated in cum. The stranger grabbing his clothes. "I want her. Like to add her."

"Harem?"

"I mean she's your best friend. I guarantee the three of us will be fucking all the time. She's hot as you are and somehow dirtier. Your love and passion and shes..." Collin watched her rub the cum across her chest. "Naughty and...just straight fucking naughty."

The music was coming to a close and Collin got up. Athena took the cue and jumped up enthusiastically, "Well let's go and take her then, while we are all sated for a bit."

Collin grabbed his clothes and handed them to her, "Wait. I wanna try something." Collin closed his eyes and hoped, "I am a complete stud to women, a total sexual fantasy and I am impossible to resist if I flirt or make a move in any way. I am a sex god and able to recover incredibly quickly to keep up with the harem i'm making. If I invite a woman I fucked to my harem and they are satisfied, they can't refuse."

The music died out and Collin stabilized himself, legs still a bit weak he guessed. Athena ran up and held his arm, "Baby you okay? Why are you saying all that?"

"What do you mean?"

"I mean why are you bragging about yourself? We get it. You're amazing." Athena laughed waving Tori over. "If you're so excited about recruiting then let's start,"

Collin couldn't believe his luck. It must have worked! Both of them noticed his raging hard on and bulging balls at the same time and Collin turned to Karlee. "I need to take care of something first."

Walking away from his partner he ignored Tori approaching and made his way to the now naked Karlee who was enthusiastically blowing the investor. Without warning he kneeled behind her and stick his dick in her feeling her soaking wet pussy and laughing at her guttural moan, her mouth letting go of his dick. He placed a hand on her ass and admired her body from behind. She was so tight!

Karlee turned to look at him her eyes lidded in lust and he smiled at her. "You like this fat cock?"

She couldn't say a word and just nodded lost in pleasure. The investor in front of her tried to place his dick in front of her face impatiently. "Bitch you were doing something?"

Frowning at his sentence he pulled her hair back towards him. "Look up at him. Look up at him!"

She lost in the haze, her hips naturally thrusting back at him looked the investor in the eyes her mouth wide open her eyes glazed.

"This man is giving you money so you can be slutty right?" She nodded not looking away from the investor's eyes and reaching for his dick with her hand, mouth still open. "Well tell this man I own you and you're my property."

Karlee groaned feeling herself be fully full and drool dropped from her chin. "Uhhhhgh! He own's me sir! I'm his property like he said. His to own! God he feels so good!"

Collin smiled at the idea, "Tell him how I feel inside you."

Please log in to view the image

Karlee shuddered and her eyes watered, afraid to blink. "He's so fucking good! I can't describe it other than heaven on earth. He's so much fucking better than you!" Karlee blinked and realized her words for a second then moaned when Collin thrust into her again eyes glazing over again. "You were good too though. Just not as-you know."

Collin then looked at the shocked investor who was reddening in rage, "So I'd prefer you not to be so rude to my property do you understand? Fuck away and continue empowering her slutty behavior. But never **** her. Only I can do that!"

The investor muttered and nodded getting up and grabbing his clothes before grabbing his wallet and dropping a thousand dollars in cash on a nearby seat. Collin smiled and pulled her hair a bit harder. Instantly her pussy leaked down their legs and she began shaking wildly.

Letting go she collapsed on the floor in front of him letting him get up and admire her sexy body. "Did you mean it?" her voice softly vibrated from the floorboards.

Smiling he rubbed her back and looked at the girls patiently waiting in the distance clothing. "Yeah. I'm making a harem and your one of the first sluts to join. You're my sex pet and you do what I say and only fuck who I allow. Now get up and get dressed we need to figure out where we are staying."

Karlee was clearly loopy, her eyes unable to focus as she slid over and grabbed at her clothes, "Staying?"

"Can't stay at my place, parents might get a little confused about a group of girls barely dressed and loudly fucking in the house." Collin waited and smiled admiring Karlee as she struggled to put on her upside down skirt and lost her underwear and lost patience buttoning her shirt after two buttons leaving massive cleavage on display.

"Well Tori lives with her mom and sister, why don't you work your magic and we can stay there?" Karlee cooed sliding her socks on and pushing her shoes away, "If it ain't heels I ain't wearing it."

Collin smiled looking back at Tori. "You'd just offer your schoolmate's family on a platter for me so we'd have a house to fuck in?"

Finally 'dressed' the once religious schoolgirl rose on unsteady feet and he smiled at her. She had a bulging chest, open shirt and a skirt hiked up her waist that was inverted looking like she was having a walk of shame. He couldn't think of any look more fitting for her. The voluptuous brunette snapping back to it looked at him with confidence and pride, "It's a harem master, you're going to convert someone. Might as well be girls that are useful for something. Plus..." She began walking to the other girls strutting dramatically to flash her ass as she walked, "I'm the biggest slut there is."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)