Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by jj0445 jj0445

What's next?

Finish with the girls

At some point the energy shifts again.

Not calmer.

Just slower.

The kind of late-night exhaustion where nobody has enough energy left to stay fully chaotic, but everybody’s still way too wrapped up in each other to stop.

Kenzie ends up sprawled halfway across your chest while Lexi lays beside both of you still talking nonstop about absolutely nothing.

“You know what?” Lexi says suddenly.

“What?” Kenzie asks tiredly.

“We’re ridiculously hot together.”

Kenzie immediately starts laughing again.

“You are actually obsessed with yourself.”

“I’m obsessed with ALL of us,” Lexi corrects proudly.

Then Lexi suddenly grabs Kenzie’s face dramatically and kisses her.

Not seriously.

Not romantically.

Just drunk chaotic energy mixed with the very obvious fact that both of them know you’re watching.

Kenzie laughs into it immediately at first.

Then kisses her back anyway.

And fuck.

The sight alone nearly destroys your ability to think straight again.

Messy blonde hair.

Soft laughs between kisses.

Both girls pressed together while clearly dragging it out longer on purpose now.

Lexi even glances toward you briefly mid-kiss just to check your reaction.

Then smirks.

“Oh my god,” she laughs against Kenzie’s mouth. “Look at him.”

Kenzie finally pulls back just enough to glance toward you too.

And the second she sees your expression?

She immediately starts laughing harder.

“He looks so offended,” Kenzie says breathlessly.

“I AM offended,” you reply.

Lexi grins proudly afterward.

“Awww,” she teases. “You feel left out?”

“Yes.”

“Good.”

Kenzie completely loses it laughing again.

Then eventually both girls shift toward you at the exact same time afterward like they planned it without speaking.

Kenzie settles against one side of you while Lexi drapes herself against the other, both of them still warm and flushed from everything earlier.

And suddenly you’re trapped between two drunk blonde disasters.

Neither of whom seems interested in giving you personal space anymore.

Kenzie presses closer first, lips brushing slowly along one side of your neck while Lexi immediately starts kissing the other side at nearly the same time.

The sensation hits all at once.

Soft kisses.

Warm breaths against your skin.

Both girls crowding against you from opposite sides while laughing quietly every time you react.

A sharp breath escapes you before you can stop it.

Lexi notices instantly.

“Ohhhhh,” she says dramatically against your neck. “Sensitive.”

Kenzie laughs softly afterward while still kissing slowly along your neck.

Then her hand slides lower.

And the second she wraps her hand around the obvious bulge in your lap—

your entire body tenses immediately.

“There it is,” Kenzie whispers smugly against your skin.

Then instead of stopping, her hand starts moving slowly against your shaft while she keeps kissing your neck.

The reaction hits immediately.

“Oh my god,” Lexi laughs breathlessly from the other side of you. “He is STRUGGLING struggling.”

“Shut up.”

“No.”

Kenzie keeps stroking lazily while Lexi continues kissing slowly along the opposite side of your neck.

And somehow the combination only gets worse once Lexi starts getting impatient too.

Eventually she slides her own hand lower as well before laughing quietly the second she feels how hard you are already.

“Oh wow,” Lexi whispers dramatically. “Yeah okay.”

Kenzie immediately starts laughing against your neck.

“Told you.”

Then both girls start taking turns teasing you while still kissing along your neck between breathless laughs and whispered comments.

Kenzie slower and more deliberate.

Lexi more playful and chaotic.

Every time one of them pulls back laughing, the other immediately takes over again.

At one point both girls crowd closer at the same time, kissing opposite sides of your neck while their hands overlap briefly against your lap together.

The combined sensation nearly destroys your ability to think straight.

A rough groan escapes you before you can stop it.

Lexi immediately reacts louder than anybody else.

“OHHHH there it is.”

Kenzie starts laughing softly against your neck again.

“He’s actually dying.”

Neither girl gives you even half a second to recover either.

Kenzie keeps moving slower and more teasing against you while Lexi constantly reacts to every sound you make like it’s the funniest thing she’s ever heard.

At one point Lexi whispers directly into your ear:

“You are struggling SO bad right now.”

Kenzie immediately laughs softly afterward against the other side of your neck.

“He really is.”

You groan quietly while both girls keep crowding closer against you.

Neither of them giving you even half a second to recover.

Kenzie eventually pulls back just enough to look at you with flushed cheeks and messy hair falling around her face.

Then she smiles.

Not teasing this time.

Not performative.

Just warm.

“You’re fun,” she says softly.

The comment catches you off guard enough that you blink once.

Lexi immediately points dramatically.

“OH MY GOD.”

Kenzie groans instantly.

“Don’t make it weird.”

“You LIKE him.”

“I know I like him,” Kenzie says while laughing. “That’s why he’s here.”

Lexi falls sideways laughing afterward while you stare at Kenzie for another second.

And weirdly enough?

That somehow hits harder than half the physical stuff tonight.

Because underneath all the chaos and flirting and terrible decisions—

she actually means it.

The longer both girls keep crowding against you, the harder it becomes to stay composed at all.

Kenzie notices first.

Mostly because she’s still pressed close against your neck when your breathing suddenly changes again.

She pulls back just enough to look at you.

But her hand never stops moving slowly against your lap while she studies your expression.

Then she immediately starts laughing.

“Oh my god,” she says breathlessly. “You are fighting for your LIFE right now.”

Lexi instantly reacts from the other side.

“WAIT,” she says dramatically. “Is he actually close?”

You let out a rough groan immediately.

Which apparently answers the question.

Both girls instantly lose it laughing.

“No WAY,” Lexi says while collapsing sideways dramatically.

Meanwhile Kenzie keeps stroking lazily against you the entire time, clearly enjoying the reaction way too much now that she knows exactly what she’s doing to you.

“Lexi,” you mutter.

“What?” Lexi says proudly while shifting back closer again. “I’m taking it as a compliment.”

Kenzie laughs harder afterward while her hand keeps moving slowly against your lap.

Then she glances toward Lexi with the exact same dangerous smile she gets whenever she’s about to make another reckless decision.

“Oh no,” Lexi says immediately after seeing it. “That look means chaos.”

Kenzie ignores her.

Instead she looks back toward you and says:

“Okay wait.”

The tone alone immediately makes Lexi sit back up again.

“Oh this is important.”

Kenzie bites her lip slightly afterward while still clearly trying not to laugh.

Then while still slowly teasing you with her hand, she casually says:

“So where are we putting this problem?”

“Oh my GOD,” you groan loudly.

Lexi completely loses composure beside both of you.

“HE’S SO STRESSED,” she yells laughing.

“You two are unbelievable.”

“We’re planning ahead,” Lexi argues proudly.

Kenzie nods seriously while still stroking teasingly against your lap.

“Very responsibly.”

Neither of them can even pretend to keep straight faces saying it.

The entire conversation somehow becomes even worse because neither girl stops touching you through any of it.

Lexi eventually slides closer again afterward before grinning mischievously.

“Okay but seriously,” she says. “On our tits?”

Kenzie immediately laughs.

“Oh my god.”

Lexi keeps going anyway.

“On our asses?”

Kenzie groans loudly while laughing harder now.

“You are INSANE.”

Lexi points dramatically.

“In our mouths?”

“Oh my GOD,” you groan again while Kenzie’s hand keeps moving teasingly against your lap.

Both girls completely lose it again.

Kenzie nearly folds forward laughing while her hand still keeps moving slowly the entire time like she forgot to stop.

Lexi falls sideways against your shoulder laughing breathlessly afterward.

“He is NOT surviving this.”

“You think?” Kenzie replies immediately.

Then eventually Kenzie shifts closer toward you again afterward, still smiling softly while brushing messy blonde hair back from her face.

Her teasing slows slightly this time.

Less chaotic.

More deliberate.

Then quieter now, with way less joking behind it, she says:

“You’re cute when you get flustered.”

That somehow hits harder than the entire conversation before it.

Lexi immediately notices the change in your expression too.

“Ohhhhh,” she says dramatically. “That one got him.”

Kenzie laughs softly again afterward while both girls settle back against you, still warm and breathless and completely wrapped up in the ridiculousness of the night.

Kenzie stays close against you afterward while Lexi sprawls beside both of you still laughing under her breath every few seconds.

Neither girl seems remotely interested in calming down anymore.

Especially not once Kenzie’s hand slides fully around your dick again.

Slow.

Lazy.

Her fingers stroking teasingly while she watches every reaction cross your face.

Just enough to keep making your entire body tense every few seconds.

Lexi notices immediately.

“Oh my god,” she says while laughing breathlessly. “He’s STILL struggling.”

“You two are the worst.”

“No,” Lexi says proudly while shifting beside both of you again. “We’re the BEST.”

Then, completely unprompted, Lexi glances downward before dramatically grabbing at her own chest.

“Personally,” she says while squeezing her boobs together proudly, “I think these deserve recognition.”

Kenzie immediately bursts out laughing.

“Oh my GOD.”

Lexi keeps going anyway.

“I’m just saying.”

“You are unbelievable.”

“I know.”

Meanwhile Kenzie can barely stop laughing long enough to stay serious anymore.

Especially once Lexi starts dramatically showing off even harder just to make both of you react.

At one point Lexi catches you looking again and immediately grins.

“There it is.”

“Lexi,” Kenzie groans while laughing.

“What?” Lexi says proudly. “I’m helping.”

Kenzie shakes her head smiling afterward before finally looking back toward you again.

Then her expression shifts slightly.

Still playful.

Still flushed and messy and completely reckless.

But more focused now.

Her hand slows teasingly around your dick while she studies your face for another second.

Then she says:

“Okay.”

Lexi immediately points dramatically.

“Oh this is IMPORTANT important.”

Kenzie ignores her completely.

Instead she bites her lip slightly before asking:

“So which one do you want?”

You blink once.

Kenzie smirks softly at your expression.

“The options,” she says while counting casually on her fingers. “Tits.”

Lexi immediately lifts hers proudly.

“Strong option.”

Kenzie laughs under her breath before continuing.

“Asses.”

Lexi immediately grins afterward before turning around onto all fours beside both of you with absolutely zero hesitation.

“Oh this one wins,” she says proudly.

Then she starts shaking her ass back teasingly toward you almost immediately, clearly showing off on purpose now that she knows you’re watching.

Kenzie completely loses it laughing.

“You are SUCH a whore.”

“Thank you,” Lexi replies confidently while still twerking backward dramatically.

The sight nearly destroys your ability to think straight again.

Lexi looking back over her shoulder grinning while moving her hips slowly side to side.

Completely shameless.

Completely loving the attention.

At one point she even reaches backward to spread her own ass slightly while wiggling teasingly again.

“Oh my GOD,” Kenzie laughs breathlessly beside you.

“What?” Lexi says proudly. “I’m making my case.”

Kenzie completely loses composure for half a second before recovering again.

Then quieter this time—

while still slowly stroking you—

she says:

“Or mouths.”

The room goes quiet for exactly one second afterward.

Mostly because both girls are watching your reaction way too closely now.

Lexi still absently playing with her chest while grinning beside both of you.

Kenzie still staring directly at you with that same dangerous dance-floor confidence she’s had all night long.

And somehow the fact they’re both clearly waiting for your answer makes the entire moment feel even hotter than the question itself.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)