Finger her ass while you fuck her

Ignoring her wavering warning, you gently press your index finger just past the opening of her anus. It quivers and clenches, but it relents to your efforts and soon your finger is completely inside of her.

"Oh fuck," she cries, "you're fingering my ass."

"And I don't plan to stop," you respond as you twist it inside of her. This causes another moan to escape her and you can feel the muscles of her body relax as she succumbs to her fate.

You set a steady pace of thrusting your cock into her pussy while pulling your finger almost out of her ass. Then you reverse it, pulling your cock out slightly as you jam your finger into her lubed asshole. Despite the chill in the apartment, you feel both of your bodies getting warm and sweat starts to pool in the small of her back. You wipe a bead of sweat from your forehead with your free hand and then smack Anna on the ass.

"Yes!" she shouts, "fuck my pussy, finger my ass and smack it! Oh god, fuck me hard, Phil."

You can feel a stirring in your balls as you begin to pound her pussy even harder. The sounds of your sex fills the apartment, punctuated by moans of pleasure from both of you. In a moment you know you're going to explode.

"I'm, I'm gonna cum," you manage to squeak out.

"Good," she says, as she reaches back and grabs your hips. It's clear she wants you to cum inside her pussy, even though she never allowed it without a condom while you were dating. You've already fucked up by banging your ex-girlfriend, do you really want to go a step further and cum inside her without protection?