Fetishes

John recalled the one episode where Max dressed up as a maid for Halloween. He knew that the girls had been transported in with their wallets and credit cards, so...

He went over to Max first.

"Max, you don't know why you are here or how you got here, and you do not know why. All you know is that you want to be my sexy French maid. Being a French maid has been a big fetish of yours, and acting like a French maid for a stranger makes you horny. You will buy a sexy French maid outfit. You also have no respect for Caroline and believe her fetish for acting like a cat is weird."

Next, Caroline. "You don't know why you are here or how you got here, and you do not know why. All you know is that you want to be my sexy kitty. Being a kitty has always been a fetish of yours, and acting like a kitty for a stranger makes you horny. You will buy a sexy kitty outfit. You have no respect for Max and think her fetish of acting like a maid is weird."