Chapter 169
by
Samus1001
What's next?
Fairies in the Garden part 5
Marilyn grunted as she rammed her strap-on into Coach Katie’s snatch. Katie’s lips formed a tight seal around her nipple as she sucked hard.
Marilyn whimpered, “Crap Coach, are you trying to give my nipple a hickey?”
With a loud pop Katie released her and said, “Fuck yes! Gods that feels so fucking good! Fuck me harder Marilyn! If you keep that up you’re gonna make me cum!”
Marilyn redoubled her efforts. This was both the most sex she’d ever had, and the most fun. She could hear several other women grunting, moaning, or shouting in orgasm nearby.
To her left, on the other side of the flowerbed they lay beside, an old black woman with massive tits named Lottie was getting absolutely wrecked by Hazel, her fiancé Tina, and an Asian woman named Lu. The three pixies had the green winged fairy air tight as they fucked her in all her holes.
Tina lay on her back with Lottie riding her while Tina sucked her nipples. Lu was behind Lottie ramming her ass with another strap-on, while Hazel stood above them all fucking Lottie's face with a third strap-on. Marilyn's own cunt felt sadly empty as she watched.
She continued to fuck Katie, but her attention was focused on the old black lady. She wasn't just taking it, she threw her ass back at the two strap-ons filling her. Meanwhile she had one arm wrapped around Hazel, pulling Hazel's strap-on down her throat while the fingers of that hand dug into Hazel's butt. All the while, the fingers of her other hand were hammering into Hazel's cunt. Hazel was holding on to Lottie's head as if for dear life as she creamed Lottie's fingers.
When Hazel crumpled to the ground after her orgasm, Lottie reached over and unsnapped Hazel's strap-on. She got a naughty grin on her face as she rose off the two rubber cocks inside her. She looked down at the two women and said, "It's my turn now," as she donned Hazel's toy.
Katie muttered, "Damn, I gotta get me some of that."
Marilyn looked down at her and saw that her focus was also on Lottie. Marilyn looked back over as she slowly, lazily fucked Katie. Lottie had Tina flip over onto her hands and knees. She got behind her and teased her ass with Hazel's spit soaked rubber dick. Lottie grabbed Tina by the hips and eased the rubber cock up Tina's ass. Once she was fully embedded, she turned to Lu and said, "Well, what are you waiting for? Get that dick back up my ass. I ain't done with you yet either.
As Marilyn watched the three women fuck she came to the realization that if the strap-ons they wore were not as big as Caleb's cock she doubted what they were doing would be possible. Lottie was practically laying on top of Tina as she drove the big rudder dick up her ass. Lu had a harder time fucking Lottie, partially due to the size of Lottie's big butt, and partially due to the rhythm and pace Lottie set.
It didn't take long before Tina was crying out in both pleasure and pain. Her feet kicked the ground as she hollered, but Lottie didn't ease up the ass pounding for a second. After her massive orgasm Tina simply lay on the floor unmoving. Lottie turned Tina's head and said, "You and Hazel are gonna need to work on your stamina honey. One orgasm, even one that big, shouldn't leave you unable to continue. What's gonna happen when Caleb goes with you on your honeymoon? You gonna have to call in some help? Or are you going to give him the fucking of his life?"
She looked over and saw Hazel rubbing her clit. "You too honey. You're his sister, you need to be able to fuck for as long as he does. You need to spend more time getting fucked, and less time doing the fuckin."
Lottie looked over at Marilyn and Katie and hollered, "Hey you two! Why don't you come over here and help me fuck these three? I'll take Lu here and you can have the two 'brides to be'."
Katie and Marilyn looked at each other and both smiled at the same time.
Caleb sipped his 'Jack and Coke' and ate some food as he listened to the women sitting around him in the pool lounge talking and laughing about the orgy. The sun had gone down and there was not enough light in the gardens to continue. His history teacher, Elena Garcia, and her wife were laughing as they told the story about the fucking he gave them. Martha, Elena's wife, had never been with a man before. She had been scared when she first saw the size of his cock, and insisted that he fuck her wife first just to prove it really wouldn't hurt her.
Caleb smiled at the memory. Elena had been a firecracker, cumming hard and often. In contrast, Martha was a needy lover, begging for each orgasm as if she'd never have another. Hearing Elena whisper in his ear, pleading with him to pump a baby into her wife had lit a fire inside him. Unfortunately, Martha hadn't wanted to be bred. It was just as well. Having both women pregnant at the same time would definitely put them both under strain being nine months along at the same time. If Martha asked for a breeding in a few months, Caleb would be only too happy to do them both again.
Kathy and Lottie were also laughing about their own experiences. Caleb had not run into Lottie at all. Hearing her tales, he felt like he missed out. She had managed to collect eleven pixie flowers, which was a bit shocking considering her age. He was glad to see her with a glass of honey wine. He had seen her daughter with a drink as well, which meant they would be spending the night. He might get to fuck her and play with her gigantic titties yet. He wanted another threesome with her and Kathy, if not today, then soon. He was going to insist upon it.
His mother and Heather walked in from the gardens with the last two women still inside. They hadn't thought to come up with a signal to let everyone know when the orgy was over, so several of the harem members had gone to look. Chloe and April were doing another head count to make sure everyone was present. April gave him a thumbs up, so he stood and walked over to the stage. He saw Kathy get up and walk over to join him.
He kissed her when she reached him, then turned to the women scattered around the lounge. "Okay everyone, that concludes our Fairies in the Garden orgy. I wanna thank you all for attending. I am happy to see that no one is still wearing blue wings, so hopefully you've all been cured of whatever ails you. For those of you still wearing green or purple, don't worry, you will get invited back. We have a pool party set for Saturday, and we will probably have another planned orgy in a week or two. There will be a couple of guys invited to the pool party, so it wont be a full blown orgy. But if you attend, I will try to take care of you then. Keep in mind there are going to be more women seeking my services then too, but I promise I will get around to taking care of you eventually, even if I miss you again on Saturday."
Kathy stepped forward and called out, "The harem and I want to thank everyone as well. I'm pleased beyond belief to see so many women wearing pixie wings. Caleb did a wonderful job fucking so many of you, and feeding you his cum. This has been an incredibly wonderful orgy, and all of you, not just the ones that didn't catch Caleb, will get invited back."
She had to stop as applause and cheering broke out around the lounge. When she was able to get them to quiet down she continued, "Let me finish please. We are going to space out the invitations so not everyone will get invited back to the next one. June, my Mom, and I will contact you with dates for our future orgies so that you can let us know which you can attend. There are a lot of women that didn't get to attend tonight that want Caleb's services, so it might take a while to get you all back over, but you will all get to come back. I hope you all a ton of orgasms. I know I did."
More happy cheers rang out around the pool lounge, so Kathy again waited for them to die down.
"Now, the harem has finished counting all the flowers and we are ready to announce the winner of our game. The winner is being given a choice between two prizes actually, mainly because we couldn't decide which one was better. One choice is to move into the mansion and stay with us for 30 days. That means you'll get to attend every orgy during that time and have Caleb's cum with every meal. You will also get to share his bed with him and whichever harem members he chooses at least one night each week. The rest of your nights will be spent in bed with a different harem member of your choice each night, as long as that member is not with Caleb."
She waited a moment to let that sink in then said, "The second choice is to attend every planned orgy we host for the next year. We guarantee you will get fucked by Caleb once at each orgy. In addition, you will get to invite a different woman to each orgy where she will also be serviced by Caleb."
Chloe came up and handed her an envelope. She opened it and pulled out the little yellow card inside. "The winner, with fourteen flowers with her name on them is... Rhonda Harrison! Stand up Rhonda!"
Caleb recognized her as one of the women that gave him a blowjob early in the orgy. He remembered intentionally cumming on her wedding ring when he blew his load all over her and Lottie's daughter Brianna's faces. Caleb listened to the women clap and congratulate her. She was roughly his mother's age, with smallish breasts but a nice hourglass figure. Not as pretty as the women in his harem, but that hardly meant anything. She was clearly an enthusiastic lover to have given out at least fourteen orgasms. There was no telling how many she received herself.
Chloe handed Kathy another envelope as she said, "Think it over Rhonda, and let my mom know when you decide. Okay, we didn't tell anyone, but we had a couple of secret challenges for some more secret prizes. Chloe and the Fairy Queens kept track of a few things for us during the orgy. The next prize is going to the woman that collected the most sex toys. You all get to keep the toys you collected, but the winner will get to spend one night with the harem member of her choice. It says here that the winner teamed up with a couple other pixies, and not only did she collect quite a bit of fairy honey, but a lot of pixie honey as well. That winner, with four vibrators, a set of nipple clamps, a butt plug, two dildos, and a strap-on is... Lu Zhao, one of the maids! Stand up Lu!"
"I choose you!" she cried out as she stood. Laughter joined the applause she received.
Kathy laughed and said, "Just let me know when you want me, but not tonight. My kitty is a bit sore."
More laughter spread around the lounge. Chloe handed the next envelope to Kathy and she continued, "Next we have the first woman that gave all the Fairy Queens an orgasm. Our Fairy Queens asked me to thank you all for the orgasms you gave them, especially since they were neither fairies nor pixies. Our winner will get to spend one night being serviced by all four of them and Caleb. She will be in charge the entire night, whatever she wants, they will do to her. And the winner is... Bonnie McDougal! Bonnie is a member of our school newspaper. Stand up Bonnie!"
Bonnie stood while blushing a bright red. She quickly sat back down before the applause had quieted even a little.
Chloe handed Kathy one last envelope and whispered in her ear. Kathy's eyes widened and she said, "Well, this is a happy turn of events. It seems our last prize is a tie. They are the only women that gave every single member of the harem, and Caleb's mom and sister, an orgasm. They will each get to go out on a date with Caleb and be the next candidates for joining the harem. And the winners are... Lottie Martin and Marilyn Stockton! Stand up ladies! Lottie is the second women whose breasts were blessed by Caleb, and Marilyn is the Student Council Vice President and Caleb's new secretary. Please give them a hand."
Kathy waited for the applause to die down before she spoke again. "Once again, I want to thank everyone for attending. The party will continue for a couple more hours and you are all welcome to stay as long as you like. If you have been drinking, we are not letting you leave without a sober driver. There are only twenty beds, and aside from the harem and house staff, there are forty-two women here. Depending on how many choose to spend the night, some people will have to double or triple up."
"Having said all that, Caleb and I will be taking pictures and I would like to get at least one shot with everyone around Caleb and his cock. After that we will go around the lounge and get individual shots with each of you. For those of you that decide not to spend the night, we have some gift bags for everyone so make sure you get yours before you go. Each gift bag contains a small vial of Caleb's cum, and a dildo Sonia made that is modeled on his cock, along with some other little gifts."
Chloe hurried up to Kathy carrying a camera on a tripod and whispered something in her ear. Kathy's smile grew huge and she loudly said, "That's all I have for everyone. I'd like you all to get together now so we can take a picture really quick, because I have something I have to go do. Actually, lets take two. One as you are now and another topless with everyone holding their breasts."
She turned to Caleb and said, "Caleb my love, I'd like you in the middle with everyone arrayed around you. Let's put the Fairy Queens on either side of you and I will be in front, and we can put Hazel next to me, the two of us holding your cock."
For the first time in her life, Kathy made sure the camera captured a clear view of her breasts. She knew guys would jerk themselves off to the pictures, but they would never get to touch them. Only Caleb would ever get that privilege. It never crossed her mind that women would be masturbating to the sight of her naked body as well.
"Holy shit. Do you see Kathy's tits? Those gigantic things are fucking real? Fuck! I want Caleb to cum cover me if I can get tits that look that damn good," Alex, one of the cheerleaders exclaimed as she drove a dildo into her snatch. A half dozen of the cheerleaders were hanging out at Wanda's house. They picked her house because her big brother was home from work, and they all liked to tease him by flashing him their naughty bits.
Ludmilla rubbed her clit as all the cheerleaders present looked through their phones at the pictures that Kathy just posted to her social media accounts. She grumped, "Anyone else notice Kesha isn't in any of them?"
Sally and Sharon, two more of the cheerleaders both said, "Yes," at the same time.
Sally added, "I bet she got her dumb ass arrested."
Seeing the looks the other cheerleaders gave her she went on, "Oh please, we were all thinking it, I just had the balls to say it. She hasn't called anyone, and she isn't in the orgy pictures. If she didn't get her ass arrested, then where the hell is she?"
Wanda thought for a moment. It was unlike Kesha to not hang out with them, or at least answer her phone. But all of their calls were going straight to voicemail. If she had been arrested, someone would have heard something by now. Sharon's dad worked at the police station and Kesha knew it. Sharon's dad had gotten them out of trouble more than once.
If Wanda was being honest, it was really the only reason Sharon was on the squad. She wasn't very pretty, and she had one of the least sexy bodies among them. She was also a hypocritical entitled bitch that thought she could get away with anything just because her dad was a cop.
"Cora, what are you doing here honey? You should be at college. Please don't tell me you dropped out!" Mary said as she kissed and groped her eldest daughter. Caleb felt his cock harden as he watched their gigantic breasts mash together. Mary was only wearing her semi-transparent silver nightgown. She hadn't even put on panties or a bra yet. Cora was wearing jeans and a sweatshirt that did a poor job of hiding her massive mammaries.
Kathy stepped up beside him and said, "Surprise. My big sis came to see us. I hope you don't mind, she'll be staying till Sunday."
Kathy pulled Caleb over to her sister as Cora exclaimed, "MoOom. I didn't drop out. I'll take the rest of my classes online for the week. I came home because I just broke up with my boyfriend. I wanted to spend time with my family and get my head on straight. Besides, I have to make sure my favorite sister hasn't gotten herself in any more trouble since she became the most famous woman in the world, AND got knocked up in the same week."
She turned to Kathy and pulled her into her own kiss and grope. Their kiss was more passionate than the one Cora shared with her mother, and Caleb remembered Kathy mentioning that she and her eldest sister grew very close over the last few years.
Cora ended her kiss but kept her arms around her baby sister. She looked over at the newest Stretcher King and her panties went from damp to flooded. He looked even more handsome in person. She tried desperately not to glace down at the prominent bulge in his shorts, but she saw enough in her peripheral vision to make her wet pussy feel very empty all of a sudden.
Her baby sister's boyfriend had been all she could think about the entire drive here. Him and his harem, and her baby sister and mother. All of them living in the same house, sleeping with him and each other. Kathy called her every day, telling tales of all the sexy fun they'd been having. She had no reason to think the stories weren't true, and desperately hoped she'd soon find out, personally.
She awkwardly held out her hand and said, "Uh, Hi. You must be Caleb, Kathy's boyfriend. It's nice to finally meet you. She talks about you all the time."
Kathy sidestepped out of Cora's arms and pushed her into Caleb saying, "We don't shake hands around here. We are a hugging family Cora. You can even kiss him if you'd like. Once we are married, he's going to own you too, so you might as well get used to it."
Mary stammered, "Kathy, you shouldn't push them to be too familiar. They just met. I don-"
Mary cut her sentence off when Caleb pulled Cora into his arms, wrapped them around her body, grabbed her ass, and kissed her square on the lips. He pressed his crotch against her as he lightly swiped his tongue across her lips. Cora pressed her huge tits into his chest as she opened her mouth and danced her tongue with his.
Kathy grinned and said, "You see Mom. They are getting along great already. Don't worry, I'm sure Cora will fit in perfect with the harem once Caleb claims her, and puts a baby in her belly."
Mary nodded her head. Seeing her oldest daughter kissing the man she loved wasn't causing the reaction Mary expected. She'd spoken out because she still felt she should warn her daughter about the harem effect, but seeing them kiss caused that desire to collapse. Ever since Caleb added Mary to his harem, she'd begun seeing the world in a new light. Cora belonged with them, in his harem. Loving and being made love to, by all of them.
Cora didn't pay attention to whatever her mothers response was. Her heart beat hard and rapidly as she made out with the hunk in her arms. Kathy made it sound like she was certain he would claim her. Cora wanted him to do so very badly, but she pulled away before she began ripping their clothes off.
She looked into his eyes as he grinned down at her. She could lose herself in those eyes. She released him and said, "Hey Kat, Um. It was a long drive. You mind if I get something to eat?"
Kathy smiled and took her sister's hand saying, "Yeah, come this way. We have a bunch of guests in the house right now. You simply have to meet everyone. You just missed our first official orgy by the way. It was awesome. I'll tell you all about it while you eat."
Kathy led her sister away, giddy that she had arrived. Sonia said the sisterhood successfully slipped some of Caleb's cum into Cora's coffee a few days prior. Kathy was worried her harem effect wouldn't be able to affect her sister at such a large distance, but having her consume Caleb's cum had helped. Sonia said it would, and Kathy trusted her.
Cora broke up with her boyfriend the same day, and called Kathy in tears. When Cora suggested visiting, Kathy nearly leaped with joy. It was a struggle to keep her elation out of her voice. Cora easily agreed when Kathy suggested not telling their mother to make it a surprise.
Now that Cora was close by, Kathy was certain she wouldn't leave before Caleb fucked her. He might even add her to his harem on this visit. Kathy hoped so, very much. She was one step closer to her ultimate fantasy, sharing both her sisters and their mother with the man she loved. All four of them in bed with him, loving him and each other.
All the women Kathy loved most would share her future husband. Along with her family she would have June, Hazel, Angie, Chris, Gabbie, Katie, Lori, Emily, all the girls in the Denizens, her favorite teachers, and even more women. Chloe, Tina, Amanda, Melissa, April and her team, Sonia, Amelia, Marilyn, Holly, and maybe even Lottie.
Kathy led Cora into the kitchen where she greeted Zuri the cook. Kathy hid a grin as she explained the difference between the blue and pink platters of food, unconcerned that Cora chose food from the blue platters that didn't contain any of Caleb's cum. Her big sister had already eaten some, and was already heavily under the influence of the harem effect.
Kesha opened her eyes as the bag over her head was removed. She found herself completely naked and tied to a chair. She lifted her head and saw three women in sisterhood robes seated on the other side of a metal table from her. The one that removed the bag took it and stood by the door.
The one seated in the middle, who looked to be the eldest, spoke harshly. "I want you to know that the easy way to do this is you answer our questions quickly and honestly. If you do so, you will feel very little pain. If you lie to us, well, let's just say you won't enjoy what we do to you."
She gestured to the side. Kesha looked in the direction she indicated and her eyes widened at the sight of the tools arrayed on the table against the wall. She recognized some of them. Among the tools was a couple of scalpels, a set of plyers, a big battery and some wires, and a hammer. The thing that scared her the most though, was the blowtorch.
Writing takes energy and coffee provides energy. If you like the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
The Normality Dial
Changing reality with a word
This story is based off a branch of Murakami's Normality found here. https://chyoa.com/chapter/Introduction.174576 In this story, our hero Caleb Anders, finds a watch that allows him to change reality, with certain rules based on the time the watch is set at. A special thanks to BiBiComte and CrossC for allowing me to reprint their own chapters here. I have credited them for each of their chapters at the start of those chapters. I may have made a few minor changes and grammatical corrections, though I am by no means perfect myself.
Updated on Jun 11, 2026
by Samus1001
Created on Jul 20, 2025
by Samus1001
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments
