Everyone is a little gay

I sat on the edge of the couch, heart pounding as Mia’s challenge echoed in the room. “Your move. Do you accept Mia’s challenge and do it in front of the group?”

My face burned. I crossed my arms over my chest and shook my head quickly. “No way. This is too much. I’m not just going to masturbate in front of everyone like it’s nothing. Can we please change the dare or something? I’ll do shots, I’ll answer more truths, anything but this.”

Jake laughed. “Come on, it’s hot. Don’t be shy.”

I kept stalling, shifting in my seat. “I’m not even into that kind of public stuff. It feels weird. I’m straight, okay? This whole thing is pushing it. I don’t need to prove anything by playing with myself while you all stare.”

Jake leaned forward, grinning. “Exactly. I don’t watch quote unquote straight porn because I don’t want to see some dude fucking. I watch solo women and lesbo porn only.”I shook my head fast. “It’s not homophobic or anything. I just am not turned on by women like that. Can we drop it?”

Sarah rolled her eyes and smirked. “Bullshit. Everyone, especially Jake, is a little gay. If you’re all so sure, then we’re watching a lesbian porn together right now. No one is allowed to get aroused. First one to fail gets teased by everyone else. Deal?”Mia immediately agreed, loving the new twist. Tyler shrugged like it was no big deal. Jake looked confident. I tried one last time to stall. “Wait, this is still crazy. Can we at least make the stakes lower? Or turn the lights off?”

“No,” Sarah said firmly, already queuing up a full-length lesbian scene on the TV. “Rules are set. Hands where we can see them. No touching yourselves until someone breaks.”

The video started. Two beautiful women on screen, kissing deeply, hands roaming over each other’s bodies. Soft moans filled the room as they peeled off clothes, revealing perfect tits and smooth skin. One woman pushed the other onto the bed and started sucking on her nipples, licking and biting gently.I pressed my thighs together tight, trying to ignore the warmth building between my legs. I was determined not to be the first to fail. My nipples hardened under my thin top anyway. I kept my hands on my knees, breathing slowly.

Beside me, Sarah was watching intently, biting her lip. Jake had his usual cocky expression, but I noticed his shorts starting to tent a little. Tyler sat back, legs spread, trying to look casual.On screen the action heated up. One woman spread her legs wide, showing her wet pink pussy to the camera while the other dove in, licking her clit with long, slow strokes. Wet sounds and loud moans poured from the TV. The woman getting eaten out arched her back and grabbed her own breasts, pinching her nipples.I felt myself getting wet. My pussy throbbed, begging for attention. I shifted again, squeezing my thighs harder. Don’t get wet. Don’t get wet. But I could already feel my panties soaking through.

Mia was breathing faster, her cheeks flushed. Sarah’s hand rested on her own thigh, gripping it. Jake’s erection was now obvious, straining against his shorts.

Then Tyler shifted. He tried to adjust himself discreetly, but it was too late. His cock was rock hard, the outline clear as day in his sweatpants. A small wet spot had even formed at the tip where he was leaking.Sarah noticed first. “Oh my god, Tyler! You failed already!”

Everyone turned to look. Tyler’s face went red but his dick didn’t soften. “It’s just the video, it’s hot, okay? Doesn’t mean anything.”

I let out a breath of relief that it wasn’t me, but the teasing started immediately.Mia laughed. “Look how hard he is. Poor Tyler couldn’t even last five minutes of lesbian porn.”Jake piled on. “Mr. Casual over here popping a massive boner to girls eating pussy. I thought you were tougher than that, man.”Sarah grinned wickedly. “Teasing time. Pants off, Tyler. Let’s see that hard cock you couldn’t control.”Tyler protested but the group pressure won. He stood up and dropped his sweatpants. His cock sprang free, thick and veiny, the head shiny with precum. It bobbed in the air as the girls on screen kept moaning louder, now in a hot sixty-nine position.

My own arousal spiked seeing him exposed like that. My clit ached. I was dripping, but I hadn’t touched myself yet, so I was still safe.The teasing escalated. Sarah made Tyler stroke himself slowly while we all watched both him and the porn. “Nice and slow. Show us how turned on girl on girl makes you.”Tyler groaned but obeyed, his hand sliding up and down his shaft. Precum dripped freely now.Mia turned to me. “You’re still good? Because you look flushed.”

I nodded, lying through my teeth. My pussy was throbbing so hard it was distracting. Watching Tyler jerk off while the lesbian scene continued was pushing me close to the edge without even touching.The women on screen started using toys. A thick dildo sliding in and out of one while she ate the other’s ass. The moans were filthy and loud.Tyler’s stroking sped up. He was breathing heavy, eyes glued to the screen.Sarah noticed me squirming. “I think our girl here is struggling too. But Tyler failed first, so he gets the full tease. Get on your knees, Tyler. Stroke faster for us.”

Tyler dropped to his knees in the center of the room, cock pointing straight up, hand flying. The rest of us watched him, the porn still playing in the background.I couldn’t hold back anymore. My hand slipped between my thighs, pressing against my soaked shorts. Just a little pressure. No one noticed at first.Tyler moaned loudly. “Fuck, this is embarrassing.”Mia laughed. “That’s the point. Keep going. Don’t stop until you cum for us like the little lesbian porn addict you are.”

His hand pumped faster. The wet sounds mixed with the video. I rubbed myself harder over my clothes, biting my lip to stay quiet.Sarah caught me. “Oh? Looks like someone else is failing now.”But the focus stayed on Tyler. He thrust into his fist, groaning, until he finally exploded. Thick ropes of cum shot out across the floor as he came hard, body shaking. The girls on screen came at the same time in a screaming mutual orgasm.

Tyler knelt there, spent and panting, cum still dripping from his cock.The group cheered and teased him more. “Tyler’s our first loser. Now he has to stay naked for the rest of the night.”My own pussy was soaked and desperate. Since Tyler had already failed, the rules loosened. Mia looked at me with hungry eyes. “Your turn to show us how wet that made you. Shorts off. Now.”

I stood on shaky legs and peeled my soaked shorts and panties down. My smooth pussy was visibly dripping, lips swollen and shiny. Everyone stared.Tyler, still naked and half-hard again, watched as I sat back down and spread my legs.Sarah moved closer. “Good girl. Touch yourself while we put on another scene. This time you don’t have to hold back.”

I slid two fingers inside my aching cunt right away, moaning loudly. The relief was instant. I fucked myself openly while the group watched, Tyler’s spent cock twitching back to life at the sight.The night spiraled from there into more dares, more touching, and plenty of explicit play. Tyler’s early failure set the tone, turning the whole group into a horny, teasing mess with me riding my fingers to a shaking orgasm while they all cheered me on.