Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by Tnaisawesome Tnaisawesome

Who do you choose to fuck first?

Eve

When Eve realizes you've picked her, she beams with joy, rises to her knees on the bed and meets you as you approach. The blonde embraces you with her lithe, athletic body and your rock hard cock presses against her abs. Her wet, hungry kiss is all the dialogue you need and you nudge her backwards. She shakes her head and pushes you firmly onto your back, then begins to kiss her way down from your neck to your chest and then further down.

You run your hands through her blonde, straight hair as she approaches her destination. Your dick is still hard as steel and you groan as she kisses the head before forming a tight hole with her red lips and sliding it down over the bulbous, purple tip, like a tight pussy.

"Fuck!" you groan, and Riley giggles.

In the corner of your eye you spot Chloe and Tatiana making out. Soft, female moans fills the room, and you're loving it. You put your hands behind your head and enjoy the view of the luscious blonde bobbing on your dick. Only able to fit the first two inches, she uses her hands on the shaft, like a pro. She looks up at you and smiles when you groan. It would seem like she’s enjoying almost as much as you.

A few minutes later, though, Eve decides that her new toy is well enough lubricated, and moves up to straddle you. With a trained hand she grabs your rod, positions it just where she wants it and sits down.

"Oooh!" she moans, her vagina struggling to accept your girth. "Damn, I didn't- oh God!"

She lifts herself up, slides down again, and you grab her nice, round ass to assist.

"Fffuuu-ck!" she moans, working two-three inches inside before she stops moving.

"Sorry, it’s just… I have to get used to having this inside," she apologizes.

Nodding, you reach out and slide your hand over her slit, getting it nice and wet. You rub her clit gently, or actually, around it in circles.

"Mmm, that's so good," she purrs, grinding ever so slightly on your groin.

Rocking back and forth, she gradually sinks deeper and her breaths become shallow.

"Oh god, John," she utters, "you're so much bigger than all my exes... I've never had any cock so big inside my little vag!"

You do your best to hide your grin. You feel so fucking alpha as the blonde compares you with her former lovers.

"I had no idea it could feel this fucking good!" she moans, now slowly riding you.

Of your wife's friends, Eve is the one you probably like the most, and you'd often fantasized about fucking her. You can't believe it actually happened, and not only that, she's loving it. You watch as the slim, fit blonde bounces on your thick meat, her puffy lips stretched around it, and the blonde patch of hair glistening with her wetness. You let your hands slide up over her ass and back and grab her small tits with both hands. Her nipples are short, but hard, and she moans when you rub them.

It seems the girls are so horny that they can't keep their hands off each other when you are busy. You lean over and give Tatiana a wet kiss. The voluptuous blonde is lying next to you on her back, squirming as your wife softly eats her out, with her own ass in the air. Behind her, Chloe is standing, two of her fingers buried inside Riley's vagina, and another one rubbing the clit. The spontaneous lesbian orgy pleases you, and you focus on Eve again.

The blonde has a gotten into a good rhythm, grinding on your pelvis with most of your fat cock buried inside her hot box now. Instinctively you match her thrusts, her lovely pussy massaging your dick with every bounce. You grab her round ass and grind her harder against yourself, and her moans get louder.

"Fffuck! I'm gonna cum!" she soon cries out.

"Ah, ah, ah, aaaaah, aaahahahaaaa..."

Her moans turns into light laughter as her orgasm takes control of her body and she collapses on your chest. You kiss her and grin, then grab her ass and quickly flip the two of you over, your cock still buried inside her. Her eyes open wide in surprise. Without pause, you start to fuck her deep and hard.

"Oh my God! John! Nnngh!" Eve moans as you surprise her.

You usually love the cowgirl position, but the urge in you to be the dominant one is so much stronger since you wore the ring. You had felt an agression build up inside you as you let her ride, but now you have to get release. Her pussy is still calming down from the first orgasm, but you can already feel her hot secretions oozing out from her glands onto your massive member.

"Yes, take me hard!" Eve moans in your ear, "Fuck me, you fucking stud, you!”

Your balls feels heavy as they slap against her smooth ass cheeks, but there's still no pressure building up, just a great feeling. You relentlessly pound the hot blonde, your large cock sliding easily in and out of the slick, but tight pussy. You just now you’re hitting all the right spots. She puts her hands around you and squeeze you hard against her body, and you kiss her again.

"My exes never fucked me like this," she whispers in your ear, "and it feels soooo good!"

"Yeah, you like that big cock?" you whisper back.

"Mhm, it's so thick!" she replies. "Do you like my little pussy?"

"I love it," you reply, "especially when you cum for me!"

"Then keep fucking me just like that!" she says. True enough, not long later, her face flushes red and she begins to trash and buck underneath you.

"Fuck, fuck, fuck!" she cries. "Oh my god, ohmygod, ooooohhhhh!"

Her second orgasm is stronger than the first. Like a vice grip, her pussy clamps down on your big cock, trying to milk your cum out and failing.

When you pull out, Eve goes limp on the bed, exhausted by the waves of pleasure. “Oh my god, that was amazing, John!” she says.

{if Tat_fucked=false}You grin and turn your head to Tatiana.{endif}

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)