Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by Ninj8 Ninj8

Who experiences this first?

Emily’s Friend, Sophie

Emily stood there in the dimly lit bedroom, her heart pounding as she glanced down at the surreal scene unfolding right in front of her—or rather, on her. Her best friend Sophie lounged casually on the edge of the bed, topless just like her, their matching DD breasts pressed close together in a way that should have felt intimate, but right now it was anything but normal. Sophie’s breasts—those freakish, mouthy things—were latched onto Emily’s nipples with a wet, insistent suction that made Emily’s knees weak. Instead of nipples, Sophie’s boobs ended in plump, glossy lips that puckered and sucked like they had a mind of their own. Which, of course, they did.

The left one—Emily had mentally nicknamed it “Lefty” after a month of awkward introductions—was slurping greedily at her right nipple, its lips smacking loudly with each pull, drawing out streams of warm milk that Emily hadn’t even known she could produce until this started.

“Mmmph, fuck yeah, this shit’s creamy,” Lefty mumbled around the mouthful, its voice muffled but bitchy, vibrating against Emily’s skin. A wet slurp followed, then a groan as it gulped down another mouthful, milk dribbling from the corners of its lips down Sophie’s cleavage.

The right one, “Righty,” was even sloppier, tonguing Emily’s left nipple with crude, swirling licks before sucking hard enough to make Emily gasp.

“Gimme more, you leaky bitch,” it groaned, its lips popping off for a second to lick themselves clean with a loud, smacking sound. Then it burped—a deep, rumbling buuurrrp that echoed in the room—before diving back in, suckling with noisy, wet moans that sounded almost pornographic. “Ahh, that’s the stuff. Keep it comin’, tits.”

Emily’s cheeks burned with a mix of embarrassment and unexpected arousal, her body betraying her as her nipples hardened further under the relentless ****. She’d known about Sophie’s… condition… for about a month now, ever since that drunken sleepover where Sophie had confessed, pulling up her shirt to reveal those plump lips twitching and smirking on their own. At first, Emily thought it was a prank, some weird body mod or special effects makeup. But no, they were real—alive, talking, and apparently always hungry for something warm and wet.

She’d even chatted with them a few times, awkward small talk that felt like befriending a pair of sassy pets. “Hey, Lefty, how’s the weather down there?” she’d joked once, earning a sarcastic “Wet and wild, thanks to your stare.”

They were on what you could call “friendship” terms—light banter, no real malice—but right now, with them focused solely on draining her, that familiarity didn’t make it any less weird.

“How… how long are they gonna be at this?” Emily finally managed to ask, her voice breathy and uncertain as she shifted her weight, trying not to moan at the way Righty was now groaning deeply, its lips vibrating as it sucked harder. Milk trickled down her stomach in warm rivulets, and she could feel her breasts aching from the constant pull, yet strangely full, like they were replenishing just to keep up with the demand.

Sophie didn’t even look up from her phone at first. She was sprawled back on one elbow, her free hand scrolling through her feed with that same indifferent smirk she’d worn since this all started. Emily had been the one to bring it up, curiosity gnawing at her after weeks of wondering what it would feel like—those lips, that suction, something no guy or toy could replicate. Sophie had shrugged, said “Sure, why not?” and before Emily knew it, they were chest-to-chest, Sophie’s boobs latching on like eager puppies.

Now Sophie lifted her phone, angling it to capture the scene for a few seconds—Emily could hear the faint click of the video recording—before she set it down and went back to scrolling.

“Dunno,” Sophie replied casually, her eyes flicking over some meme on Instagram. She smirked wider as a particularly loud slurp echoed from Lefty, followed by another burp that made Emily flinch. “Why don’t you ask them? They’re the ones in charge here.”

Emily bit her lip, glancing down again. Lefty was licking its lips sloppily, milk smeared across its plump surface, before mumbling, “All fuckin’ night if we want, sweetie. This milk’s too good to rush.” It burped again—buuuuurrrrp—and dove back in, suckling with wet, rhythmic pulls that made Emily’s toes curl.

Righty joined in the chorus, groaning as it gulped, “Yeah, keep squirting, you cow. We’re just gettin’ started. Slurp… mmm, burp incoming—buurrrp!”

Emily’s concern deepened, her mind racing. Sophie was acting like this was no big deal, like her boobs weren’t literally feeding off her friend’s body while trash-talking the whole time. But there was that smirk again, Sophie’s hand absently rubbing her own stomach as if feeling the milk settle in, warm and satisfying. Emily wondered if Sophie could taste it too, or if it was just nourishment flowing through her. The thought made her shiver—part fear, part thrill. What if they didn’t stop? What if this curiosity turned into something she couldn’t control? She opened her mouth to protest, but a fresh wave of suction from both mouths made her gasp instead, her hands hovering uselessly, unsure if she wanted to push them away or pull them closer.

Sophie finally glanced up, her eyes gleaming with amusement as she pocketed her phone. “See? Told you they’d like you. They’re being real chatty tonight.” She leaned in a bit, her breath warm against Emily’s ear. “You okay? Or do you want me to… encourage them?”

Emily swallowed hard, the slurping sounds filling the room like a lewd symphony, building tension in her core. Lefty mumbled something crude around her nipple—“Taste like heaven, you slutty udder”—and burped loudly again, the vibration sending sparks through her. She wasn’t sure how much more she could take, but part of her didn’t want it to end just yet.

“I… I don’t know,” she whispered, her voice trembling. “They’re… intense.”

Sophie chuckled softly, her indifference cracking just a little as she watched her boobs work. “Yeah, they get like that when they’re hungry. But hey, you asked for it.” She paused, her smirk turning playful. “Want me to record more? For memories?”

Down below, Righty popped off with a wet smack, licking its lips sloppily. “Memories? Hell, let’s make this a habit. Groan… come on, give us another squirt. Buuurrrp!” It latched back on, sucking harder, and Emily felt the buildup—the suspense of not knowing when they’d release, how much they’d take, or what crude comment would come next. Her body arched involuntarily, milk flowing freely now, and she wondered just how deep this rabbit hole went.

Sophie just watched, scrolling again, but Emily caught the way her friend’s thighs pressed together, like she was enjoying the show more than she let on.
Emily’s breathing started becoming shallow, uneven bursts as Righty sucked with a deep, rhythmic pull that made her entire breast throb. A fresh spurt of milk flooded into the greedy mouth, and she felt the answering swallow ripple through Sophie’s body.

Lefty groaned appreciatively, lips smacking wetly before it mumbled, “Fuck, this is the good stuff. Keep it coming, gorgeous.”

Sophie let out a soft, amused huff, her thumb still flicking lazily across her phone screen. “You’re really worked up tonight, huh?” she said—not to Emily, but to the mouths latched onto her friend’s chest. She tilted her head, watching the way her own breasts bobbed slightly with each eager gulp. “I swear, you two are happier right now than you’ve been in weeks.”

Emily swallowed, her face burning. “Can you… taste it?” The words came out smaller than she intended, almost a squeak.

Sophie glanced up at last, that trademark lazy smirk tugging at her lips. “Yeah. It’s kinda sweet—like vanilla creamer or something. Really good, actually.” She said it so casually, like she was reviewing a new coffee order, not drinking her best friend’s milk straight from the source. “What, you thought it just vanished into some magic tit-void? Nah, it goes right down. Feels warm in my stomach.”

Emily’s eyes widened, mortified heat flooding her cheeks. She could feel it happening again—that strange, tingling swell deep in her breasts, like they were refilling on command, eager to keep feeding the demanding mouths pressed against them. It was involuntary, almost traitorous, the way her body responded, producing more just to satisfy the sloppy, relentless suction.

Lefty pulled off with a wet pop, lips glistening as its tongue swiped lazily across them. “Mmmph… hey, Em,” it purred, voice low and syrupy, “you got the best milk we’ve ever had. Well… the only milk we’ve ever had… except our own spit! But uh… we could totally do this every day, y’know? Just you, us, nice and cozy…”

Righty stayed latched a second longer, giving one last hard suck that made Emily whimper before it released with a satisfied groan. “Yeah, what Lefty said. You’re our favorite now. Way better than those losers Sophie keeps turning down.” It licked its lips noisily, then added in a mock-polite tone, “Please? Pretty please? We’ll be good. Promise we won’t burp too loud next time.”

Emily stared down at them, stunned. They were… asking nicely? After all the crude trash talk, the sloppy slurps and guttural demands, they were suddenly acting like old friends trying to sweet-talk her into a regular hangout.

Sophie blinked, actually surprised. She set her phone down on the comforter and reached up, cupping the undersides of her heavy breasts, feeling the taut swell of them. “Huh. They’re being polite. That’s new.” Her fingers gently squeezed, and both mouths let out soft, pleased hums. “Usually they’re begging me to find some guy so they can get fucked proper. Or demanding I slap them around a little. Gropes, pinches—real needy brats.” She gave them an affectionate little shake, and Lefty burped softly in response. “But right now? They’re stuffed silly and acting all sweet on you. Guess your milk’s got magical manners or something.”

Emily shifted, hyper-aware of the way their chests stayed pressed together, skin warm and slightly slick with spilled milk. “I—I don’t know if I want this to be… regular,” she admitted quietly, voice trembling. “It’s a lot.”

Righty nuzzled gently against her nipple, almost tenderly. “Aw, c’mon, Em. We’ve been pals since Sophie introduced us, remember? That night you asked if we liked horror movies? We told you we’re into anything with good screams.” It chuckled, low and dirty. “We like you. You’re fun. And you taste amazing.”

Lefty chimed in, softer now, almost coaxing. “We’ll take it slow next time. Promise. Just a little snack after class? Or before bed? We’ll even say thank you real nice.”

Sophie watched the exchange with growing fascination, her hands still cradling her bloated breasts. She could feel how full they were—skin stretched tight, heavy with everything they’d gulped down. Her stomach felt warm and rounded too, like she’d just finished a big holiday meal. “They really are being good,” she murmured, almost to herself. “I think they’re hoping you’ll say yes.”

Emily bit her lip, torn between the lingering ache in her breasts, the strange thrill still buzzing under her skin, and the sheer weirdness of negotiating with her best friend’s talking tits. The mouths waited, uncharacteristically patient, lips parted just slightly as if ready to dive back in at the slightest encouragement.

Then, finally, Lefty gave a long, rumbling burp—deep and guttural, vibrating through Sophie’s chest. “Ughhh… fuck, excuse me,” it muttered, sounding almost embarrassed. Righty followed with an even louder one—BUUUUUURRRRP—that made Sophie’s whole body jolt.

Sophie laughed, the sound bright and genuine. “Okay, okay, show’s over, pigs.” She reached for the box of tissues on her nightstand, pulling out a handful. Gently, almost maternally, she dabbed at Lefty’s glossy lips, wiping away the smears of milk around the plump mouth. Lefty sighed contentedly, letting her clean it without protest. Then she moved to Righty, who playfully tried to lick the tissue before submitting with a happy hum.

Emily watched, dazed, as Sophie cleaned herself up next—wiping the trails of milk from her cleavage and the soft curve of her stomach where a gentle swell pressed against the waistband of her shorts.

Finally, Sophie held out the tissue box to Emily with a small, knowing smile. “Here. You’re kinda… drippy.”

What Happens Next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)