Emily's Night (IV)

The elevator opened on the Master’s Suite, where Laura was still awake—one body reading on the sectional, legs tucked under, the other curled on the far end with a mug of tea balanced on the knee, the tea long cold but unspilled. The light was low, and a line of blue from the dusk-lit window cast both forms in doubled silhouette, but when Emily and Andy stepped in, two sets of eyes tracked them instantly, precise and focused. It was impossible not to feel that attention: like being seen in stereo, or observed by two versions of someone who had practiced this all their life and only recently discovered it was a gift.

Andy and Emily hadn’t spoken the whole way up. After the door on Grove Street closed behind them, Emily kept Andy’s hand in hers, but her body language said she was bracing for something—the way a kid braces for a rollercoaster, half thrilled, half convinced she might lose a shoe or a limb. Her hair, as ever, fell in such a way as to shroud her perfectly: not an inch of nipple, not a suggestion of pubic hair, even though she was otherwise completely nude and aware that Laura would catch every detail.

Emily hesitated, caught by the double gaze, then exhaled and let Andy’s hand go. She tucked a strand of hair behind her ear, more out of habit than modesty. Andy was the first to speak, as if on cue.

“We’re back,” he said, which was both obvious and necessary.

“Welcome back,” Laura said, both sets of lips shaping the words in perfect sync. She closed her book, marking the page with a finger, and rose in both bodies at once, stepping out of the well of light around the couch.

Laura crossed the room and one of her hugged Andy, quick and hard. The arms were strong, decisive, a little more squeeze than you’d expect. Her other body followed a second behind, looping its arms around Emily’s shoulders in a quick, almost professional hug, then withdrawing just as fast. Emily blinked at the contact but didn’t flinch; she seemed almost to expect it.

“Sit down,” Laura said. “Both of you. I want to hear everything.” She steered Andy to the chair across from the couch, then patted the cushion beside herself and looked at Emily until she sat.

Emily perched at the far edge of the sectional, legs crossed, one arm over her midriff in a way that suggested she’d spent a lot of time in chairs like this but never quite figured out where to put her hands.

“So?” Laura asked. “How was the city?”

Emily looked at Andy, as if for permission, then back at Laura. “It was…” She tried the word, then shook her head, starting over. “I didn’t know how much I missed it until I was back. It was weird at first. The elevator opened on Flatbush and I just—stopped. I couldn’t move. It was the same as I remembered. Like nothing had changed, except for me.” She smiled faintly. “The nudity took a little to get used to, even with the reality adjustment. It was weird, knowing I was completely naked, and yet no one seemed to notice.”

Laura’s eyes softened, both faces at once. “Did you see your apartment?”

Emily nodded, drawing a breath. “We walked there. There was a police seal on the door—NYPD, big sticker, with my name and Rachel’s name on it, and a case number in blue ink.” She paused, the memory rerunning in her face. “It said ‘MISSING PERSONS’ in huge letters.”

Laura went still, her attention doubled. “Missing persons? I thought at most, only a day or two passed during a season.”

Emily blinked, then looked at Laura. “Maybe, but I spent two years between seasons. I was gone three months. For them, I mean.”

“Did you go inside?” Laura’s voice was soft, but the question hung in the air.

Emily nodded and blushed. “I broke the sticker. The apartment was the same. My painting was still on the easel. Rachel’s jacket was on the hook.” She looked down at her hands. “I finished the drawing I started the night I left. The lines were still there, waiting.”

Laura’s hands found Emily’s, both sets at once, and held on. The gesture was warm, and Emily squeezed back.

Andy added, “She drew a woman running, but the face wasn’t there. It was supposed to be Rachel, but she couldn’t remember her face, only her haircut.” Andy said this without judgement; he seemed to see the utility in facts, even sad ones.

Emily picked up again, her voice more certain. “We went to an art gallery next. The show was between installations, but there was one painting at the back wall. I stood in front of it for a long time. Andy didn’t rush me.”

Laura asked, “What did it look like?”

Emily laced her fingers and squeezed them tight. “It was a figure, but not really a person. Like the body was trying to form out of the background, but the world kept eating it up. It made me think about coming back here, about trying to fit in when you don’t even know if your old shape exists anymore.” She glanced at Andy, then at Laura. “It was sad. But it was also beautiful.”

Andy added, “You said it made you want to paint again.”

Emily flushed, but nodded. “Yeah. It did.”

Laura let go of Emily’s hands, but only to bring her own up to her mouth, thinking. “Where did you go after?”

“Gatsby’s,” Emily said. “The bar where I used to work. We sat at the bar and watched the bartender do her thing. Frank was there at the end of the bar. He was a regular, when I bartended there. Bit sexist, but overall harmless. He didn’t recognize me, but that was fine. He was a fixture, not a person.”

Andy said, “She told me a story about every corner of the place. Every regular, every glass behind the bar. It was like you’d never left.”

Emily shrugged. “Maybe I never did. Maybe the me that left is still sitting there, somewhere.”

Laura smiled, but her eyes were damp. “And then?”

Emily smiled kept going. “After that, we walked the High Line. It was empty except for a few runners and some parents with strollers. I’d never been, believe it or not. Also, I wanted to see if it felt different, being… like this.” She gestured at her own body, hair perfectly in place. “It didn’t. The world just adjusted around me. People ignored it, like I was a ghost.”

Laura’s eyes flashed, a momentary indignation, but she held it back. “Was that good or bad?”

Emily considered. “Both. I didn’t get harassed, but sometimes you want someone to notice. Just to know you’re really there.” She looked at Andy again, then at Laura. “He noticed. That helped.”

They took a moment, the silence sitting between them. Laura didn’t fill it.

Emily looked down at her hands. “On the High Line, I called them. My parents.” She paused. “After the apartment, after seeing my name on that sticker—I kept thinking, three months. They’d been waiting three months.” She glanced at Andy. “I just needed to hear their voices. My mom picked up on the third ring.” A small, involuntary smile. “She always picks up on the third ring.”

“They asked us to dinner,” Emily continued. “I knew it wasn’t going to be the night I’d planned—I wanted to give Andy something fun, something easy. But I couldn’t say no.” She looked at Laura. “I hadn’t realized how much I missed them until I heard her voice and just—“ She stopped, pressing her lips together. “I missed them a lot.”

Andy picked up quietly. “We went. Emily rang the bell, and her mom came to the door and hugged her before she could even say hello.”

Emily swallowed, her voice thickening. “She didn’t even see me. Not really. She just hugged me, and I didn’t want to let go. She didn’t ask why I was naked, or why my hair was so long, or why I looked different. She just held on. Like she’d done it a million times and never wanted to stop.”

Laura looked down at her own hands. “What did she say?”

“She asked if I was safe,” Emily said, “and if anyone had hurt me, and if I was hungry. She made dinner, and I sat at the kitchen table and told her I’d been gone for a while, but I was okay.” She paused. “It helped, to have Andy there.”

Laura looked at Andy, both faces, then at Emily. “Was it hard?”

Emily smiled, just a little. “Yeah. But it was good, too. After dinner, she brought out the photo albums and we looked through every single page. I saw myself as a baby, as a kindergartener, as an art school dropout. I remembered things I thought I’d lost.”

They all sat with that for a while.

“Anything else?” Laura asked, not pushing but inviting.

Andy said, “We finished at the Green Lion. A bar in the Village. Emily wanted to do something date-like, she was worried she had spent all her time trying to reclaim her old self. I told her I was having fun, but…” He shrugged, then continued. “She told me—” He paused, as if checking that it was okay. Emily nodded. “—she told me she wanted to be my wife.”

The word hung in the air, a living thing.

Laura’s faces both went still. She looked at Andy first, then at Emily. “Wife,” she said, not as a question, not as a challenge, just as a fact.

Emily went pink, but she didn’t hide. “Yeah. I did.”

Laura was quiet for a long beat, hands in her lap, both faces unreadable. Then she put one hand—just one—on Emily’s knee, and said, “Good.” Her voice was flat, but the word was loaded, like a full deck of cards. “Did you cry when you said it?” she asked.

Emily shook her head. “No. I almost laughed.”

Laura’s eyes crinkled. “That’s how you know it’s real.” She reached out with both arms then, the gesture so sudden and unplanned it surprised even herself, and pulled Emily into a hug, strong and full. Andy watched, unsure if he should join, but Laura’s other body found his hand and squeezed it. When they separated, Emily was crying, and didn’t bother to hide it.

The three of them sat together, silent but warm. Andy stayed in his chair, but the distance was only physical.

It was Laura who started up again. “What made you pick ‘wife’ over ‘girlfriend’ or anything else?”

Emily considered. “I think… I spent all day looking for a way to connect the person I was with the person I am. Wife was the only word that fit both. Even if it’s just here, or just in my head, it feels right.”

Laura nodded, taking this in. “What did it feel like, sitting in your parents’ kitchen, with Andy beside you?”

Emily looked up at the ceiling, as if searching for the right word. “It felt like home,” she said. “I wasn’t hiding. Not from them, not from Andy, not from myself. I was just… there.”

Laura smiled, but it was a sad kind of smile. “That’s all anyone wants.”

The three of them sat with it. Outside, something moved in the trees, a bird or the wind, and then it was quiet again.

Emily was looking at her own hands. She turned them over once, then back, like she was reading something written there. “Can I ask you something?” she said, to Laura specifically.

Laura’s faces tilted toward her. “Yeah.”

“Does it ever feel strange?” Emily said. “Being two. Like—does one of you ever know something the other one doesn’t, even for a second?”

Laura considered this with the seriousness it deserved. “Not really,” she said, “I’m both. But sometimes I react differently between bodies, if I’m conflicted.”

Emily nodded slowly. “I’ve been thinking about that. About the things we carry that other people can’t see until we show them.” She looked at Andy, then back at Laura. “There’s something else I want to share with you, Laura.”

Laura turned to her, both faces attentive.

Emily’s throat bobbed, and for a moment she didn’t speak. Then: “There’s a transformation I have. I haven’t talked about it much, but I want you to know. I want you to know everything, before tonight.” She hesitated, then added, “And I want to know what you think.”

Laura nodded, once from each body, then again, slower.

Emily explained: “It’s called Eager to Please. If anyone gives me a suggestion or order—especially someone I care about—and I obey, I feel a physical… reward. I get off on it. If I really like the person, it’s stronger. Sometimes a lot stronger.” She rolled her lips in, then out, as if bracing for impact. “I hid it for a while, because… well. I worried people would think I was faking, or weak, or a joke. Or maybe they'd exploit it. But it’s real, and I wanted you to know, because—” She looked up, directly at Laura, both faces. “I don’t want you to be surprised.”

Laura absorbed this, her eyes sharp, considering. Then she asked, quietly, “Is it dangerous? Are you safe?”

Emily bit her lip, then smiled. “I am. The only times it was ever too much was in the first season. Now, it’s just… part of me.” She glanced at Andy, then back at Laura. “I like it, actually. If it’s with someone I trust. I just want to be clear: if you want me to do something, you can just say so, and I’ll probably enjoy it.”

Laura said, “You mean, sexually, or—?”

Emily shrugged. “Both. But especially sexually.”

There was a pause, and then Laura said, “Okay.” It was simple, but there was a subtle warmth behind it, as if she was cataloguing the information and tucking it away for later. “Thank you for telling me.”

Andy, watching all this, said, “I didn’t know at first either, but Emily’s always been honest about what she wants. And if she ever says stop, she means it.”

Laura looked at Emily again. “Do you want me to use it?” There was no hint of mockery, just a real, gentle question.

Emily blushed. “I want to be your equal, unless I say otherwise. If I ever want to be told what to do, I’ll make it obvious. But otherwise, treat me like you’d treat anyone.”

Laura nodded, both heads this time. “Understood. That's all I needed to know.”

Emily laughed, a snort escaping her. “That’s fair.”

Laura turned to Andy. “Are you okay with this?”

He smiled, a tiny smile. “It makes her happy. That’s enough for me.”

Laura’s other face smiled too, then looked at Emily. “I like you. I mean, I already did, but I like you even more now.” She reached out, this time with both bodies, and hugged Emily close, pulling her in between the two sets of arms. “You belong here, okay?”

Emily melted into the embrace, eyes wet but not from sadness.

When they separated, Laura wiped her own eyes and said, “Now that that’s out of the way, are you going to ask me to stay over, or should I invite myself?”

Emily looked at her, then at Andy, then back at Laura. “Stay over,” she said. “Please.”

Laura grinned, both faces at once. “Only if you say ‘please’ again.”

Emily’s smile grew, and she said, “Please, stay with us tonight.”

Andy stood, and so did Laura, both bodies moving in sync now, but with one arm always around Emily’s shoulders. They walked together toward the bedroom, the three of them a single, impossible shape in the low light.

The Master’s Suite bedroom was cooler and quieter than the living room, the only light coming from a salt lamp on the dresser, throwing the bedding and walls into a gradient of pinks and soft orange. There were no mirrors, and the bed itself was turned down, the sheets pulled crisp. The absence of noise made every breath and shuffle of feet sharp; it was as if the world wanted to see what they would do next.

Emily went in first. Her hair swung like a curtain behind her, barely brushing the tops of her thighs, and she stood at the edge of the bed, not hesitating or fidgeting. She looked at Andy, then at Laura, both faces, then back at Andy.

“I want to start,” she said. She did not whisper. “I want you both with me. At the same time.”

Andy smiled and crossed the room. He stopped close, close enough that Emily could smell the soap on his neck, the way his skin always radiated a warmth that was somehow steadier than anyone else’s. Laura’s two bodies moved in, one on each flank, the effect so strange it was almost like a dream.

Laura said nothing, but one of her arms rested on Emily’s lower back, the other body touching Emily’s shoulder, thumb stroking the bone there with a lightness that was pure comfort, not demand.

Andy was the one who broke the spell. “Sit,” he told Emily, voice so soft it nearly vanished into the bedsheet. She did, instantly, perching on the edge with her hands on her knees, the way she’d been taught to do in art school life drawing classes. Her thighs pressed together, her posture almost comically attentive.

“Now lie back,” Andy said, and as she did, he took her ankles and lifted them onto the bed, arranging her so her back was flat on the mattress, arms by her sides, hair fanned out behind her like a pillow. She could feel her own arousal, and the simple act of doing exactly as she was told lit her nerves up like a string of lights—sharp, clear, alive.

Laura’s two bodies positioned themselves, one kneeling at Emily’s side, the other on the opposite side of Andy, always in her periphery, present but not overwhelming.

Andy knelt on the bed. He ran his hands up her calves, over her knees, then stopped at her hips. “Stay just like this,” he said. “Don’t move unless I tell you.”

The command was ordinary, but in Emily’s nervous system it was anything but. She felt the order coil through her, a pulse of wanting that doubled every time she obeyed. She let her body go slack except for the smallest tremors, and watched Andy as he leaned over and kissed her, once on the lips, then along the line of her jaw. He paused to look at her face, waiting for a sign to stop or to go, but there was none—only the absolute stillness she gave him, a silence packed with anticipation.

Andy edged her first. He started by tracing a hand along her thighs, slow and then slower, not even brushing her center but getting so close she could feel the heat off his palm. Every time she thought he would touch her, he veered away, making her gasp and shiver. He pressed her knees apart, gently but with a steadiness that did not admit negotiation. Then he kissed her again, this time on the neck, on the breastbone, on the swell of her right breast.

Emily’s eyes fluttered. The pleasure was not just in the touch, but in the holding—of position, of command, of attention. She was trembling now, just a little, and Andy could see it, because he stopped and smiled and said, “You’re doing perfect. Don’t move.”

He took her left nipple into his mouth, not sucking hard, just holding it with his lips and using his tongue to tease at the tip, circling, then flicking, then circling again. His hand held her other breast, thumb rolling lightly over the nipple there, and she thought she might actually pass out from the restraint. Every instinct in her wanted to arch, to press up, to move, but the order not to was more satisfying than the movement itself.

It was not until she was whimpering, a high, quiet sound, that Andy said, “You can move now.”

She gasped, then let her hands shoot up and wrap around his head, pulling him closer, the surge of release so sweet it nearly made her cry. She held him to her breast, then moved one hand down his body, finding him already hard through the fabric, the evidence of his own wanting a relief as sharp as the permission to move.

But she did not take over. Instead, she slid her hands around his hips and looked at him, waiting for another order. The pleasure in her body was a feedback loop: the more she obeyed, the more she wanted, and the more she wanted, the more she waited.

Andy pulled off his shirt, then his pants. He moved over her, one knee on each side, his cock resting along the flat of her stomach. Emily’s eyes never left his, not for a second.

Laura’s two bodies were present throughout, but now they split the moment between them: the one on Andy’s left leaned in and kissed Andy’s shoulder, then his neck, then up along his jaw; the other stroked Emily’s hair, a calm, reassuring presence, never possessive, just grounding.

Andy said, “Use your hands,” and Emily gasped in pleasure as she complied, wrapping both palms around him with a gentle reverence. She began to stroke him, her motions slow and deliberate, a rhythm that was almost hypnotic. Her eyes were locked onto his face, drinking in every subtle twitch of his mouth, every hitch in his breath. She could feel him responding, his cock pulsing in her hands, the heat of him growing more intense.

She quickened her pace slightly, her grip tightening just a fraction, and Andy’s breath hitched more noticeably. His eyes fluttered closed, and his hips began to move in sync with her strokes. Emily could feel the tension building in him, his body coiling tighter and tighter. When he leaned forward, she moved with him seamlessly, their bodies aligning perfectly. His cock slid between her breasts, the head grazing her collarbone, leaving a trail of pre-cum that glistened on her skin.

Andy’s breath grew ragged, his hips moving faster now, almost desperately. Emily kept her pace steady, her hands working him expertly. She could feel his orgasm building, the way his cock swelled and hardened even more in her grasp. With a final, sharp intake of breath, Andy came undone, his release spilling over her hands, hot and thick.

Handjob! +3 VP

Emily didn’t stop there. She gently eased him down onto the bed, his cock still pulsing with the aftershocks of his orgasm. She leaned over him, her breasts pressing together as she took his cock between them. The sensation was incredible—his hot, slick length sliding between her soft flesh, the head of his cock peeking out from between her breasts with each thrust.

Andy groaned, his hands reaching up to cup her breasts, squeezing them gently around his cock. Emily moved slowly at first, letting him savor the sensation, then gradually increased her pace. She could feel him hardening again already and she knew that this was going to be an incredible experience for him—and for herself too. His hands were on either side of her body now as he guided himself deeper into the embrace of Emily’s cleavage, The friction built up until finally there came another explosion - this time from deep within Andy who cried out loud enough so everyone could hear how much pleasure he had just experienced at such close quarters.

She kept her hands on him, setting a rhythm, her fingers wrapping around his shaft with a gentle yet firm pressure. She leaned forward, her breath hot on his skin, and took him into her mouth. Her lips stretched around him, slowly taking in more of his length until he hit the back of her throat. Andy’s breath hitched, but he didn’t urge her faster. She pulled back, her tongue curling along the underside of his shaft, tracing the pulsing vein that ran along it. Her hands worked in concert with her mouth, twisting slightly at the base with each bob of her head.

She established a steady pace, her cheeks hollowing out as she took him deep, then releasing the suction as she pulled back. Her saliva coated his cock, making it glisten in the soft light of the room. She could feel every ridge, every contour of him against her tongue and lips. When she heard him groan—a low, guttural sound that seemed to rise from the depths of his chest—it sent a surge of heat between her legs, making her wetter than anything else could have.

Her movements became more deliberate, her head bobbing up and down as she took him deeper each time. The sounds of her mouth on him filled the room—the slick, wet noises that were primal and raw. She could feel his hips beginning to move in sync with her, his body responding to the rhythm she set. His hands found their way to her hair, gripping lightly but not guiding, just holding on as if she were his anchor.

She varied her pace, sometimes slowing down to tease him with long, languid licks from base to tip, then speeding up again, her head moving faster as she took him deeper. Her hands moved with her mouth, one at the base of his shaft, the other cupping his balls gently, rolling them between her fingers. She could feel the tension building in him, his thighs trembling slightly beneath her touch.

The room seemed to narrow down to just the two of them, every sensation heightened. The taste of him on her tongue was intoxicating; it was a mix of salt and something uniquely Andy. The scent of him filled her nostrils—musky and masculine—and it drove her wilder than any perfume ever could have done for anyone else. Every slight movement he made was amplified; every hitch in his breath sent waves through Emily’s own body; every time he groaned or gasped or whispered Emily’s name, it made her want to please Andy more and more and more. And when he came, she felt his cum flowing down her throat, and she swallowed hungrily, licking the rim of his cock for evey last drop.

The next shift in the bed was Laura. She made a conscious effort to break the mirroring of her bodies. One form slid to Andy’s right, winding around his chest, her lips finding his neck and her hands splayed across his chest, nails pressing just enough to leave tiny warnings. The other body stayed at Emily’s side, half-kneeling, hair tumbling down to form a privacy curtain; her hands traced Emily’s jaw, then her shoulder, and then simply held her, as if to say: you’re not alone. It was expert, how she did it—dividing herself so completely, her attention and her desire visible in the way one of her bit at Andy’s earlobe while the other gently combed through Emily’s hair, thumb stroking slow circles at the base of her skull.

Emily noticed. She arched into Laura’s touch, and at the same time reached for Andy, drawing him down so his mouth met hers, the taste of him mixing with the aftertaste of herself. She let her tongue flick against his, daring him to take over, but instead he pulled back and looked at her, face open and waiting.

“Do you want more?” he asked.

Emily nodded, and when she spoke, her voice was barely audible. “I want you to use your Command Gift.”

Andy paused, the world narrowing to a point. “You’re sure?”

“I want you to,” she said. “I want you to make me.”

He nodded, and the next words he spoke had a different weight, like they were written in something thicker than air.

“Emily, do not move unless I say so,” Andy said, and even as he spoke, he reached out for the subtle switch in his mind, the one that lit up when he issued a real order.

The effect was immediate. Emily’s breath caught, her whole body tensing as if a net had closed around her, but then her muscles melted into stillness. The need to move was replaced with something else: the deep, sharp satisfaction of doing exactly what she was told. She felt it as a pulse, in her chest, in her cunt, in the tips of her fingers. She was held, everywhere, by the order.

Andy touched her knees, parting her legs with a slow insistence, then lined himself up at her entrance. He let the head of his cock brush against her, teasing, waiting to see if she’d squirm, but she didn’t—she just watched him, eyes wide, face open, taking it in.

He slid into her in a single motion, slow and then all at once, filling her completely. Emily gasped, her back arched up, but she couldn’t move her hands from where he’d left them—flat on the bed, palms up, the way he’d positioned them at the start. The order was so perfect, so absolute, that she didn’t want to disobey even a little. Not that she could, even if she wanted. Every thrust, every withdrawal, was a reward.

One of Laura’s bodies stayed wrapped around Andy, her hands running down his back, nails scraping gentle lines, her mouth at his shoulder, biting when his rhythm changed. Her other body, still at Emily’s side, leaned over and kissed her cheek, then her jaw, then hovered by her ear, breathing with her, matching every exhale. She didn’t touch more than that, but the closeness was its own kind of support. Laura felt everything Emily felt, the Bond of Marriage running at full strength—the pleasure, the holding, the urge to be even closer—her face flushed with it.

Andy built the rhythm slowly, letting Emily’s body acclimate, adjusting his angle every so often to draw out the sensation for both of them. He never took his eyes off hers, except to glance at Laura’s faces, as if confirming they were all still together in this. When he felt Emily’s body tense, he slowed, waiting for her to ride it out. He wanted this to last, and he could feel that she did too.

Emily was trembling now, her breath coming in little half-sobs, but her body didn’t move. The only motion in her was involuntary—the clench of her cunt around him, the flutter in her thigh, the way her jaw flexed as she tried to hold still.

Laura, from Andy’s side, spoke first. “You’re amazing, Em,” she said, voice dark and low, almost a growl. “You’re perfect.”

The words landed like a hit of something pure. Emily made a sound, the beginning of a sob, and then she came—hard, all at once, her entire body vibrating with the effort of holding still. She didn’t thrash or buck, she just let the pleasure burn through her, frozen and wracked, eyes open and full of light.

Andy didn’t stop. He let her ride it out, then slowed to a halt, and only then did he say, “You can move now.”

Four-Way Combo (Handjob, Titjob, Blowjob, Penetration)! +5 VP
First! x2

Emily’s arms shot up and wrapped around his neck, pulling him down and into her, and her legs locked around his hips, holding him deep. She kissed him, frantic and wild, then rolled her head back and gasped for air.

“Again,” she said. “Don’t stop. Please.”

Andy picked up the rhythm, this time harder, and Emily rocked with him, her whole body **** to make up for the seconds she’d spent under the Command. She moaned, and the sound turned into a string of broken, happy curses. Laura's body beside her stroked her hair and murmured praise, and Emily turned her face into Andy's neck and held on.

The second orgasm hit Emily even harder. She went rigid, then slack, and after she came she just held onto Andy, arms and legs wrapped tight, as if letting go would break the world.

Andy kept going, but he was close now—he could feel the edge approaching, the inevitability of it. Laura’s body beside him found his hand and squeezed it, and the other Laura kissed his jaw, then his mouth, then his ear, whispering, “Let go, if you want to.”

He did.

He came with a deep groan, all the tension spilling out in a single, hot rush, his body shaking. Emily squeezed him tight, then slumped back, arms flung wide on the sheets, hair splayed out like a halo.

For a long minute, none of them moved. The only sound was their breathing, rough and layered, until the stillness started to feel like another kind of holding.

5-Time Combo! +3 VP

Emily laughed, a sound low in her chest, then rolled onto her side and pressed her face against his shoulder. She stayed there, catching her breath, until the world started to resolve into shapes again.

Laura’s two bodies closed in, one on either side, arms around both Andy and Emily, her heads pressed close so all three of their faces were together. Emily reached up and ran her hands through both of Laura’s sets of hair, laughing again, tears drying on her cheeks.

For a long time, none of them said anything. The room had the hush of a museum at night: something holy had just happened, and the air was slow to return. Andy was on his back, hair wild, Emily’s arm flung across his chest, one leg tangled in the sheets, her breath rising and falling in ragged, sleepy bursts. Laura’s two bodies bracketed them, one curled at Andy’s far side, hand across his stomach, the other behind Emily, knees drawn up, head propped on an arm. Four eyes, half-lidded, watched the ceiling as if expecting a shooting star.

It could have ended there. It almost did. But after a while, Emily turned to Andy, found his hand, and squeezed it once.

“Can I ask for something?” she said.

Andy blinked, then smiled. “Anything.”

Emily looked over her shoulder, caught both of Laura’s faces at once. “I want to see you both. I want you to bring Andi into the room. At the same time as you.”

Andy propped himself up, searching her face for hesitation, but she gave him none. Laura watched, motionless, and then—when it was clear this was not a rhetorical request—smiled with both mouths.

Andy closed his eyes, and when he opened them, Andi was there, sitting cross-legged at the foot of the bed. Her hair was longer than Andy’s, her body lean but distinctly hers, every motion precise and purposeful. It was a strange sight, seeing them both at once—the same person, two versions, but the air in the room barely changed.

Emily didn’t hesitate. She pushed herself upright, hair in a wild halo, and leaned in to kiss Andi. She did not go for the mouth first—her hands went to Andi’s face, tracing the line of jaw, the corner of her lips, then cradled her chin before bringing her in. The first kiss was not cautious, but exploratory—a series of soft collisions, lips parting and meeting again, Emily’s hands traveling to the base of Andi’s neck, then down over the shoulders, mapping the new topography as if she’d practiced on Andy a thousand times and now needed to confirm it was true for this version, too.

Kissed the Master’s soft lips! Who knew? +1 VP

Andi was taller, and Emily liked that; she could stretch up and feel the musculature flex under her fingers, the slight vibration in the throat when Andi swallowed or moaned against her mouth. It was a careful strength, deliberate and contained—Andi’s hands never pressed, never pulled, just landed on Emily’s waist, then hips, then sides, always waiting for invitation. When Emily deepened the kiss, Andi responded by gently squeezing her waist and drawing her in, slow enough that Emily could have stopped it at any moment but would never want to.

At the same time, Laura’s two bodies had converged on Andy, one behind him, hands across his chest, mouth at the base of his neck, the other kneeling beside him, her hair falling in a black sheet over his shoulder, her hands finding their way down his abdomen with incremental, almost scientific precision. It was not lost on anyone that Laura was not splitting attention equally: both bodies were laser-focused on Andy, as if the presence of another version of him in the room made her need to double her investment.

Laura’s left hand (from the body behind) reached down and cupped Andy’s cock, already thick and getting harder, her grip careful at first, then firmer. The Laura beside him pressed her breasts against his bicep, her mouth on his cheek, then his jaw, her right hand guiding his own to her chest, making it clear that she wanted to be touched as much as she wanted to do the touching. When Andy gasped at the sensation of two sets of hands, two mouths working in tandem, both Lauras grinned, the desire real and multiplied.

Andy, lost in it, reached back with his own hand and found the Laura behind him, pulling her closer so that her breasts pressed into his shoulder blades, then tilted his head to let her mouth get at his neck. He kept his other hand on the Laura in front, his thumb stroking her nipple, feeling the way it stiffened under his touch. Laura’s bodies were, of course, perfectly coordinated: one hand rolled his balls, the other stroked his cock, her movements so perfectly in sync that Andy knew she was feeling the same sensation twice, once for each body.

For Emily, meanwhile, the world had narrowed to Andi’s mouth, Andi’s hands, the press of her body into Emily’s own. When Andi kissed down from her lips to her collarbone, Emily shuddered, the anticipation so intense it felt like static in her veins. She let Andi lower her onto the bed, the sheets cool against her bare skin, and then lay back, her hair fanned out as a curtain, only her nipples just barely peeking through the part. Andi’s mouth moved from Emily’s collarbone down to the swell of her left breast, and with a deliberate slowness, Andi kissed around the areola before drawing the nipple into her mouth.

Emily’s back arched at the sensation, and she grabbed Andi’s head, holding her in place. The texture of Andi’s tongue against her nipple, the heat of her mouth, was so good that Emily nearly sobbed. She felt herself getting wetter with every passing second, the arousal a direct current from breast to core. Andi alternated: she suckled for a moment, then traced the underside of Emily’s nipple with the flat of her tongue, then flicked the tip until Emily’s legs kicked against the mattress, involuntary and wild.

Andi’s hands were on her waist now, holding her steady, and when Andi switched to the other breast, she repeated the process—first the perimeter, then the full mouth, then the teasing flicks, always paying attention to how Emily shuddered or gasped, adjusting pressure and rhythm accordingly.

By now, both of Laura’s bodies had pushed Andy onto his back, one straddling his hips, the other curled against his right side, arms coiled around him like a human shield. The Laura on top angled her entrance over Andy’s cock, using one hand to line him up while the other pressed against his chest, nails digging lightly into the skin.

“Do you want this?” she asked, both voices at once, and Andy nearly lost it just from the sound. He nodded, and the Laura above lowered herself onto him in one smooth motion, taking all of him at once, her eyes rolling back for a second before she grinned down at him, triumphant.

The other Laura, pressed to his side, started kissing him—first his mouth, then his ear, then down his neck, her tongue tracing the vein that ran along the side. She stroked his balls with a gentleness that was almost reverent, then let her hand wander up to cup the breast of the Laura above, kneading and rolling it, pinching the nipple and making both bodies gasp in perfect unison.

The sensation of two bodies, both connected to the same mind, made Laura’s experience doubly intense. She felt every inch of Andy inside her, but also every touch on her own skin as if from a third party, an overlay of sensation that blurred the line between giving and receiving, and on top of it, she could feel Andi’s hands and kisses on Emily’s body as if she were playing with Laura’s own. The Laura riding Andy ground her hips in small circles, maximizing the friction, while the Laura beside him clung to him, possessive and hungry.

Back on the other side of the bed, Emily had shifted focus: after several minutes of Andi working her breasts, she reached down and found Andi’s hand, then guided it between her own legs. Andi got the hint immediately, letting her fingers slip through Emily’s folds, finding her clit with a touch that was at first feather-light, then firmer as Emily pushed up against the hand.

Emily’s legs were splayed now, one knee up, the other resting against Andi’s hip. She was moaning openly, her arousal too strong to care about restraint or embarrassment. She wrapped one arm around Andi’s neck and pulled her in for a kiss, while the other hand guided Andi’s fingers in the exact rhythm she wanted—short, tight circles, then a slower press, then back to the circles.

Andi kept her eyes open, watching Emily’s face for every reaction, every twitch of pleasure, adjusting her motions to match. When she slipped two fingers inside, Emily gasped and held her breath, her whole body going rigid for a second before melting into the mattress. Andi kept the pressure up, curling her fingers just right, while her thumb kept working Emily’s clit. It didn’t take long: Emily came, hard, her muscles clenching around Andi’s hand, a rush of heat and wetness that surprised them both.

But Andi didn’t stop. She slowed her pace, letting Emily ride the aftershocks, then started building again, the fingers inside her pressing up and in, the thumb teasing in a rhythm that was now perfectly tuned to Emily’s wants. Within a minute, Emily was panting again, her nails digging into Andi’s back, her hips bucking to meet every thrust.

When she came the second time, it was even bigger—Emily nearly sobbed with the intensity, her body shaking so hard it made the bed rattle. She was vaguely aware of the sounds coming from the other side of the room—Laura’s gasps, Andy’s groans—but her entire world was the sensation of Andi’s hand, Andi’s mouth, the way the two worked together to undo her.

As she caught her breath, Andi kissed down her torso, then settled between Emily’s legs, her hair tickling the inside of Emily’s thigh. Andi licked her once, just a taste, then again, slower, then started eating her out in earnest. The first pass was slow, as if Andi was learning her taste and texture; then the tongue pressed flat, the pace increased, the pressure and angle perfectly adjusted to Emily’s body.

Emily’s hands flew to Andi’s head, holding her in place, not to guide or correct, but to anchor herself against the torrent of pleasure. Andi’s hands were on Emily’s thighs, pressing them open, thumbs digging into the soft skin, keeping her from closing around Andi’s ears. Every lap of the tongue sent a jolt up Emily’s spine, the sensation multiplied by the way Andi alternated patterns—sometimes circling the clit, sometimes flicking, sometimes a slow, deliberate pressure with the whole tongue.

On the other side of the bed, the Laura straddling Andy had picked up the pace, riding him harder now, her hands planted on his chest, fingers splayed. Andy’s hands were on her hips, guiding her, his face a mask of concentration and pleasure. The Laura at his side was now kissing down his body, finding every sensitive spot, sometimes sucking on his nipple, sometimes biting his neck, never letting go.

Both Lauras were now so close to orgasm that it was almost funny: when one tensed, the other did too; when one let out a moan, the other harmonized. The climax, when it came, hit both bodies at once—an electric wave that made both of them shudder, their backs arching, their mouths open in a silent scream. Andy was caught in the middle, the sensation of Laura’s cunt squeezing him so intense that he came at the same time, his hips bucking up into her, spilling deep inside.

But they didn’t stop. The Laura beside Andy climbed on top of him too, the two Lauras now bracketing him, one kissing his mouth, the other impaling herself on his cock again, the momentum relentless. Every thrust, every slap of skin, was echoed in both of Laura’s bodies, the pleasure a closed loop that only got stronger with repetition.

Meanwhile, Emily had recovered enough to want more. She pulled Andi up for a kiss, tasting herself on Andi’s lips, then rolled over, pinning Andi to the bed with a suddenness that surprised them both. She straddled Andi’s hips, breasts pressed against Andi’s chest, and kissed her hard, then started to kiss down her body, slow and deliberate.

She spent extra time on Andi’s breasts, just as Andi had done to her—taking a nipple into her mouth, sucking gently, then licking around the areola, then switching to the other side, not in any hurry, letting the anticipation build. Andi’s breathing changed, became rougher, her hands digging into Emily’s hips, but she didn’t try to flip Emily or take control.

Played with Master’s boobs! Who knew? +2 VP

When Emily got down to Andi’s thighs, she paused, then kissed up the inside, slow and careful, letting her breath wash over the skin. She settled between Andi’s legs and found her already wet, more than ready. Emily licked a slow line up, then circled the clit with her tongue, then pressed in, her mouth soft and enveloping.

Andi gasped, her hands in Emily’s hair, holding her close. Emily used her hands to spread Andi open, thumbs pressing on either side, then licked again, this time with more ****, more focus. She alternated patterns, paying attention to Andi’s every twitch and moan, using the feedback to zero in on exactly what worked.

Within minutes, Andi was shaking, her legs clamped around Emily’s head, her voice a litany of ****, whispered encouragements: “Don’t stop, please, don’t stop, just like that, fuck, yes, just like that—” The orgasm hit Andi so hard she almost bucked Emily off, but Emily held her down, kept going, licking and sucking until the tremors faded and Andi collapsed into the mattress, spent.

Master brought to orgasm! Who knew? +2 VP

But Emily wasn’t done. She crawled up Andi’s body, kissed her again, then shifted so her knees straddled Andi’s face, lining up for a 69. Andi needed no prompting: she pulled Emily down, her tongue immediately finding Emily’s clit, sucking and lapping with a hunger that made Emily’s whole body tense. Emily, in turn, went down on Andi again, the taste and texture now as familiar as her own.

They set a rhythm, both of them working each other with growing intensity, hands gripping thighs and hips, the sound of slick and breath and need filling the room. It was a competition, but one neither of them wanted to win; every time Emily felt Andi getting close, she redoubled her efforts, and Andi did the same, each trying to outlast the other and failing, gloriously.

Emily came first, a wave that hit her so hard she almost screamed into Andi’s cunt, her hips grinding down, muscles tensed. But Andi kept going, kept licking, kept sucking, so the orgasm didn’t stop but rolled into a second, and then a third, each one stacked on top of the last. When Andi came again, it was with a moan that vibrated through Emily’s whole body, her hands squeezing Emily’s ass so tight it left marks.

69’d the Master! Who knew? +3 VP
First! x2
Had Sex with the Mistress! Who knew? +4 VP
First! x2

For a minute, neither of them moved. They just lay there, tangled together, sweat cooling on their skin, the taste of each other in their mouths, the aftershocks of pleasure still rippling through them.

Across the room, Andy and Laura had finished as well: Andy flat on his back, chest heaving, Laura’s two bodies curled up on either side of him, both faces flushed, both hands tracing lazy patterns on his arms and chest.

Slowly, as if by gravity, the three of them, five bodies in total, gathered in the center of the bed. Emily lay between Andy and Andi, one arm flung over Andy’s chest, the other around Andi’s waist. Laura’s two bodies spooned from either side, her hands draped over all of them at once, fingers interlaced wherever possible.

For a long time, no one spoke. The silence was complete, the air thick with the scent of sex and the feeling of having crossed some boundary that could never be reversed.

Eventually, Andy propped himself up on one elbow and looked at all of them, his eyes soft. “Is everyone okay?” he asked, voice rough.

Emily giggled, then nodded, then snuggled closer, burying her face in Andy’s chest.

Laura’s two voices answered as one: “Pretty sure we’re all good.”

Andy looked down at the tangle of bodies, the arms and legs, the impossible geometry of the four of them together. He let out a slow breath. Eventually, Andi dissolved back into Andy, the transition so smooth it felt like a slow fadeout in a movie. Laura’s bodies shifted until both were spooning Andy from either side, and Emily was cradled between his arms, her face peaceful and open in the dark.

For a while, all three of them—Emily, Andy, and both of Laura’s bodies—lay together, limbs knotted, heads close, the slick of sex drying on their skin and none of them minding. The air was spent and sweet, a silence like nothing Emily had known before: the quiet after pleasure, after secrets told, after nothing left to hide.

Andy, center of the tangle, had Emily pulled half onto his chest, her arm draped over his heart, her thigh pinning his hips in place. One of Laura’s bodies spooned Andy from behind, arm slung across his stomach, cheek pressed to the slope of his shoulder; the other Laura curled at Emily’s back, a hand splayed against the curve of her side, the line of their bodies an unbroken brace from heel to crown. Sometimes the two Lauras would shift, one body mirroring the other’s motion, always returning to this anchor: Andy in the middle, Emily clinging to him, both Lauras holding them together like a living parenthesis.

For a long while no one said anything. Emily let herself listen to Andy’s heartbeat, the faint double rhythm of breath—his, hers, and the odd, matched-inhale of the two Lauras, which, even in repose, were never out of sync. She ran her fingers along Andy’s chest, tracing old scars and faint hairs, stopping to count each beat as if this was her new religion. Every now and then one of Laura’s hands would brush Emily’s arm or nape, just a touch, as if to say: yes, we’re still here, this is not a dream.

Eventually, Emily spoke. She did not lift her head from Andy’s chest, but the words came out clear, aimed at the ceiling, or at whatever god might be listening through the salt lamp glow.

“I want to say something,” she said.

No one interrupted. The weight of her voice gathered them.

Emily said, “I realized tonight what I want the shape of this to be.” She kept her hand on Andy’s chest, fingers splayed wide. “I want to be your wife, Andy. I want to be your partner in every way that matters, not just the fun or sexy ways, but—real. I want to be there for you. I want to be your equal, your friend, your home. Like Laura, like Erin, Claire, Dawn, or Emi.”

She paused. Andy’s hand found hers, held it, but did not squeeze or urge her to go on.

Emily breathed in, felt the heat of Laura’s hand at her hip, the slow and steady pressure. “But inside the bedroom—” She hesitated, then started again. “With you, and with Laura, I want to belong. I want you to lead, both of you. I want to be the thing you both want, the thing you both can use however you need to. And I want to do it because it’s what I want, not just because I was made to.”

She turned her face into Andy’s chest, hiding in the bone and muscle. “I know that sounds like a contradiction. But for me, it’s not.”

Andy spoke first. His voice was low, rumbled through his ribs into her ear. “It’s not a contradiction, Em. I want both those things, too.”

Emily nodded, a tear running into Andy’s skin and vanishing there.

There was a rustle, and Laura’s two bodies both lifted their heads. They spoke together, in perfect sync—so close that the sound was a single voice from two throats.

“I want to say something, too,” said Laura.

Emily shifted, so she could see both Lauras, their faces haloed in blue shadow.

Laura said, “You belong here,” Laura said. Both voices, quiet. “With me, not just with Andy. I want you to know that." She held Emily's face in both sets of hands. “Look, what I feel for you isn't what I feel for him. It never will be. I’m not attracted to women. Well, except Andi, I guess. But tonight was mine too. Being there, that was real. That counts.” She paused. “I don't think that's a problem. I think that's just us.” Laura's hands came up and held Emily's face, both sets at once. “So if that works for you, whatever you want this to be — I'm in. That's a promise.”

Emily felt a laugh building in her chest, not funny but glad, so glad she had to let it out. She rolled her head back and let the feeling take her, then let the tears come, too, not sad at all. Andy hugged her tighter, and both of Laura’s bodies pressed in from either side, the four of them a tangle that could not be unknotted by anything short of morning.

She wiped her nose with the back of her hand, then said, “I'm not asking for the same thing,” she said. “I just want to be part of what you already have. Both of you. Whatever shape that takes.”

Laura’s mouths twitched, maybe a smile, maybe a mirror. “Deal.”

They laughed, all three, and even Andy joined, though his laughter was more the sound of relief than of amusement.

The silence came back, but it was new, cleaner. Emily felt Laura’s hand find hers, their fingers twining with Andy’s, the three of them locked together. She closed her eyes, let herself float in it, and in the final moment before she dropped into sleep, she thought:

This is what it’s supposed to feel like.

She did not dream, or if she did, it was only of hands, and warmth, and the knowledge that she would never again be alone in the dark.

Emily: Threesome (Instigator) +5 VP