Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by calx86 calx86

Which Story Do You Choose?

Drew and his sister's Lily Doll Collection.

(Note: This is an extended version of my "Drew and his sister's Barbee Doll Collection")

It had been four weeks since Drew had been excommunicated from his home and kicked out of the local witches and wizards’ academy. His family was never too keen on him practicing magic in the first place, but he was born with natural talent and wanted to explore his gifts. He had been in the academy four years and while he wasn’t exactly a master, he was beginning to be fairly efficient at basic spells. He could levitate, create healing potions, and even charm some of the animals in the wild. Of course, joining the academy late in life put him behind everyone else his age, which was embarrassing considering he was twenty years old in a room full of preteens. None of that mattered, however, as he unpacked his suitcase in his new dorm at the local university.

Drew sighed, recounting the events that happened over the past month. “It’s Caleb’s fault. I should have listened to my family. If not for him and that stupid spell book I’d still be at the academy”, Drew thought to himself as he recounted the events prior to the incident.

---One Month Prior---

“Drew, you’re next,” said Professor McGuire. It was his last day of finals and his task was to successfully charm a wild creature in the local enchanted forest. He stepped forward among his classmates, revealing a vial from his shirt pocket, and knelt down to the ground, pouring the content into a small circle.

“Ah, that’s a fun one, Mr. Ricci, if you’ve concocted the potion correctly,” the professor said as she raised an eyebrow. He understood her skepticism as the particular charm he chose was advanced for his level, but he always had a fascination for pixies and couldn’t think of anything else he’d rather charm. Several minutes went by when suddenly he heard tiny giggling in the distance. His younger classmates gasped in awe when they saw the glowing orb fly toward his circle. Suddenly, the light faded to reveal a tiny, beautiful girl with black hair and the most dazzling green eyes. She flicked her short hair backward as she stared Drew down. She looked at the circle and then looked at Drew.

“Hmmph,” the pixie muttered as she smirked, just before blowing red dust in his face.

“Hey, what the…” Drew was cut off as his cloak came to life and forcefully pulled itself off of him, sending him backward onto the ground. The pixie giggled while pointing at him, just before flying away. All of his classmates burst into laughter as Drew picked himself up off the ground.

“Okay, okay, that’s enough,” Professor McGuire said as she zapped the cloak with her wand, sending it lifeless back to the ground. Drew sheepishly walked toward the professor as she put a hand on his shoulder.

“Chin up boy. That wasn’t a bad attempt. Pixies are finicky creatures after all. If you don’t get the potion to their liking they can be quite devilish,” she said giving him a warm reassuring smile.

“I failed didn’t I?” Drew asked looking down at the ground.

“Nah, it wasn’t perfect but nowhere near a fail. I’m curious though, why attempt a pixie charm? It’s far advanced from anything you learned from my class,” she crossed her arms as Drew looked up.

“I just think they’re beautiful and fascinating,” he stated trying to mask his blushing expression.

“Indeed they are Mr. Ricci, but they are also very mischievous and don’t typically care for humans, although if you ever earn one’s trust, they are the most loyal companions you’ll ever have,” she gave him a reassuring look just before motioning for the next student to step forward.

Drew made his way toward the school courtyard when he saw his cousin Caleb beckoning him from behind a tree.

“Drew, get your ass over here,” Caleb whispered. Drew huffed and made his way to the tree.

“What?” He asked rolling his eyes.

“I have something for you,” Caleb said handing him a book.

“Selene’s Book of Shadows? This is a magical book of the Fae. Why are you giving it to me?” Drew whispered.

“Do you want to keep making potions and trinkets or do you want a taste of real magic?” Caleb smirked.

“I...I don’t know. I don’t think I’m ready for something like this. Wait… that marking on your forehead… you’re a cobra member now? Drew asked, astonished as he saw the cobra tattoo.

“Yeah, just got accepted last week. They’re sending me on my first mission in a few days. Some older witch died and her grandson is having an estate sale. She has some interesting magical items that could be dangerous in the wrong hands. Anyway, I have to report to Professor Adams. Keep that book hidden until you leave campus. No one knows I have that,” Caleb said as he disappeared in a black cloud of smoke.

“Fuck me. What are you getting me into now?” Drew asked as he tucked the book into his bag.


Later that afternoon, Drew made it back home after barely passing his final and noticed that his room had been turned into an office. Since he technically didn’t live there anymore his parents saw fit to make better use of the space.

“Looks like I’m sharing rooms with Natalie,” he thought as he noticed a portable bed in the corner of the room. Natalie was his younger sister and had just turned eighteen a month prior. Not being too fond of Drew’s interest in magic, his parents seemed to favor Natalie the most. After all, she was your typical girl. She went to pageants, made prom queen, and even earned straight A’s. Drew was the awkward boy that didn’t have many friends and started developing magic, to their dismay. Knowing that they couldn’t persuade him against it, they begrudgingly agreed to allow him to join the academy as long as he didn’t practice magic when he came to visit.

“We don’t want people to get the wrong idea and think we’re weird”, he heard his mother say in his head.

He looked around the room and noticed the displays of Natalie’s dolls around the room. She may be a young adult, but was still a child at heart and loved collecting them. Some were still in packages while others were posed on the shelves. He also could help but notice some of the dolls were in custom, scantily clad clothing.

“God, if I were a male action figure I’d be in heaven right now,” he laughed to himself. Then he got an awful idea. He remembered that book Caleb handed off to him and fished it out of his bag. Selena’s Book of Shadows was renowned for its animation and enchantment spells. It was typically kept hidden in the head mistress’ office for its potential danger. He still couldn’t believe Caleb swiped it, much less gave it to him.

“A little magic for a fun fantasy won’t hurt anyone,” he said as he opened the book and thumbed through the pages until he found the animation spells.

“Let’s see, some of these are for specific tasks or simple ‘bring to life’ spells… here we go.” Drew stopped when he got to a spell specifically for animating dolls:

Carefully place the doll in a drawn circle on the ground and keep your mind focused on your intentions as you chant the following spell. An unclear mind can have unpredictable and disastrous results:

Breath life into this vessel I bless

Make its task the very best

So will It be

“Is this really a spell? It’s way too simple,” Drew thought as he grabbed the most beautiful doll from the top of Natalie’s dresser. She was pale white with glossy blue pigtails and dazzling green eyes, similar to the pixie he saw earlier that day. She stood about eleven inches, which was average doll height, and had the name Lily inscribed on her back under her clothing.

“Well Lily, you sure are cute. Might as well start with you,” Drew said while placing her in the drawn circle on the ground.

“Well, if this works I bring your friends to life as well,” he blushed as he got out his wand. “Here goes nothing”

Breath life into this vessel I bless

Make its task the very best

So will It be

Suddenly magical energy jumped from his wand and enveloped Lily. Within seconds, Drew gasped as the doll blinked her eyes, looking around the room just before turning her gaze toward him.

“Hey there stud. Are you blushing?” Lily giggled.

“Ho-holy shit it worked!” Drew exclaimed. Lily took hold of his wand and gave him a wink.

“Allow me,” she said as Drew had a lapse in judgment, allowing the enchantment doll to take his wand. Without chanting a word, Lily waved the wand in the air as magical energy jumped from his wand and began bouncing off each and every doll in the room. Within seconds the dolls began to blink and look at themselves. He glanced over at a box on the floor and noticed a couple of nude dolls, now anatomically correct with bouncing breasts, climbing out.

“Oh hell yeah.” He stared around the room in awe as miniature porn star models began to surround him.

“Now for the shrinking spell”, he stated with a noticeable bulge in his jeans.

“Nah, we like you as you are, naughty boy”, Lily said with her cute tiny voice.

Suddenly all the dolls in the room stripped of their clothes and began running toward Drew. Before he could react, several had already begun climbing up his legs.

“Come on girls, after all these years we finally have us a man to play with!” Lily exclaimed as she motioned toward the ones popping out of their packaging.

“Whoa wait, what are you…” is all he got out before falling backward on the bed. The dolls from the packages jumped from the shelves and landed on his chest. They stripped out of their clothes like the rest and winked at him as they began unbuttoning his shirt. It was a strange yet erotic sight to behold, watching countless tiny naked women struggle desperately to undress him. While some fought with his belt, a couple of others grew impatient and crawled in through his crotch zipper.

“Oh fuck,” he muttered as three dolls yanked his member through the zipper and began licking and rubbing their tits against his shaft. Ten or more dolls were now on his chest and stomach, licking and rubbing their bodies up and down.

“Hey, put that tongue of yours to use”, Lily said as she climbed on top of his mouth, spreading her legs for his tongue. He eagerly complied as she bit her lip, grinding her tiny pussy against the tip of his tongue.

After several minutes he moaned as he came, shooting semen into the air as the tiny women on top of him positioned themselves for the shower.

Just then he heard a gasp and a door slam, snapping Drew out of his post-orgasm stupor. He raised his head and saw Natalie horrified at the display in front of her.

“Oh my God, what the Fuck!” Natalie screamed.

Drew sat horrified as his sister stared him down with mouth agape.

“Hi Natalie,” the dolls said in unison as she turned to the door to escape.

“You are so fucked up Drew!” Natalie screamed as she attempted to open the door just as one of the dolls landed on her head and slid down her face.

“Hey there, you can’t leave yet. It’s time to play a little dress-up,” the doll grinned deviously as she slid down her pink tank top. Meanwhile, Drew felt some fabric wrap around both wrists and yank his arms backward.

“Hey what are you doing?” He asked as several dolls worked together to tie his hands to the bedpost.

“Oh don’t worry honey will be right back after we deal with your bitch of a sister,” one of the dolls said with a wink as they jumped to the ground where the spell-book had fallen. Another doll rolled Drew’s wand toward the book as they began to flip through the pages.

“Hey wait a minute, don’t…” Drew stopped as the dolls chanted a spell from the book, eliciting a response from the wand as magic danced from it and hit Natalie.

“Drew what the hell make them stop! I promise I won’t tell Mom and Dad anything if you change them back to normal right now!” Natalie pleaded as her shorts unbuttoned themselves and shimmied off her ass and down to her feet.

“I can’t without my wand. Everyone please leave her out of this and give me my wand back.” Drew begged as Lily shook her finger in response.

“Nuh-uh now. We were just given life and we want to enjoy it a little longer before you take it away,” she said as she jumped down to his crotch and began grinding up and down his manhood.

Natalie screamed once again as her tank top flipped up and **** itself over her head, leaving her in just a bra and panties. Before she could get her bearings her flip-flops **** themselves off her feet, causing her to fall on her ass as her shorts and tank top began to float and fill to her shape.

“Drew, please look away!” Natalie cried as she felt her bra unsnap behind her. In a **** attempt to keep what modesty she had left, she crossed her arms over her bra, just as its straps snaked around her wrists and pulled her arms above her head, leaving her C-cups on full display. Last but not least her panties pulled themselves down and escaped her feet.

“Drew you fucking pervert stop this right…” Natalie's protest turned to muffled screams as her panties flew into her mouth and gagged her. Drew couldn’t take his eyes away and sat there speechless as Lily giggled.

“Let’s go girls!”, the doll at the spell-book yelled as every doll in the room, save Lily, stormed toward Natalie and began climbing all over her body. Four dolls went straight for her breasts as they began squeezing and licking them relentlessly. As her nipples became erect from the attention, two other dolls jumped on top of each boob and began fucking themselves with her nipples.

“Mmmph,” Natalie moaned as she was reluctantly turned on. Just then, her floating tank top flew to her closet and some magic escaped from it to her sock drawer. The drawer cracked open as some black knee-highs slithered out and **** themselves onto Natalie's legs.

“Open sesame”, one of the dolls said with a giggle as the socks **** Natalie's legs apart. Her gagged scream became louder in anticipation as more dolls began to massage and lick her inner thighs. Then without warning, a doll swung from the curtains, yelling like Tarzan as she launched herself feet first into Natalie's glistening pussy. Natalie went cross-eyed at the sudden penetration as the tiny woman inside her licked her lips.

“Damn that was easier than I thought. I knew you fantasized about us you little whore. Is that why you kept some of us naked in a box?” The devious doll smirked as she began doing dips inside her pussy, fucking her with her entire body.

“Hey now, you can’t have all the fun,” another doll laughed as she laid across her navel and began licking and sucking on her clit. Natalie began bucking her hips as her orgasm quickly built within her.

“Oh fuck yeah”, said the doll inside her pussy as the walls began to close around her. As Natalie began rotating her hips a “Yee-haw” was heard from the doll licking her clit, as she grabbed Natalie's nether lips and began to ride her pelvis like a bull in a rodeo. The dolls on her breasts moaned in unison as they continued to take turns fucking her nipples and began to cum at the same time as Natalie.

“Oooh, someone’s already rock hard again. Does little Drew want to fuck his sister?” Lily teased.

“No, no”, Drew shook his head.

“I think someone is lying”, Lily bit her lip.

Stay Tuned

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)