Deflowering Lilith ♡♤

“Hey… Please, don’t do this… I’m fine, there is no need to give me any dares… We can have a third round if you want but I don’t want to be involved with it…” - Lilith begged her friends, but they didn’t listen to her, they were not going to follow her orders anymore. The catgirl desperately tried to resist, but since all of her friends were thinking the same thing, they all helped Faranne grab her, and carry her to the bed, where they would pin her down, and make sure she couldn’t escape. Itzel didn’t want to be part of this, but he did want to watch what they did to Lilith, so instead of helping them, he just sat on his stool, and witnessed how Zoey, Finn, the foxgirls, and even her own old sister were forcing Lilith for something she clearly didn’t want to do.

“No, sis… You have to play, it is in the rules… Don’t you want to have some fun??... Come on Zoey, give me a dare for my sister…” - Faranne asked teasingly to her little sister, after she helped her lie down on the bed, and asked all of her friends for help to come up with a nice dare for the cute catgirl. Neither the fox sisters or Finn could think of anything, and they actually started feeling a bit of regret, after seeing Lilith struggle to move, as Faranne held her in place on the bed. But since it was clear Lilith didn’t want to do this, they needed to convince her in other ways, and it seemed like only Zoey and Faranne were thinking of naughty ideas. The rest of them were afraid that they would indirectly participate in the sexual abuse of the catgirl, but thankfully, Zoey wasn’t that evil, and she came up with a very hot, and healthy dare.

“I don’t think she is willing to take any dares… So why don’t I dare you instead??... Faranne, I dare you to lick your little sister’s pussy…” - Zoey asked, to then dare Faranne, after she thought the best way to make Lilith play her own game was being the target of the dare, and not the person dared itself (kind of like Finn, or Itzel, who haven’t been dared to do anything). And because Zoey wanted something very naughty for Lilith, she felt like it would be better to let Faranne give her some pleasure, and she wouldn’t feel so scared then, since she would be with her loving, caring, and sometimes overprotective older sister. But even when Lilith trusted Faranne, and knew she wasn’t going to harm her, she just couldn’t believe she would do something so lewd to her, and she also looked very eager to do it, which only made it worse for her.

“With pleasure… I have seen it a couple times when we were younger, but I’m not sure if it might look the same… Come here Lilith, let me take care of you…” - Faranne replied, with a confident, sexy, but deceivingly sweet voice, as she kneeled in front of her scared little sister. For a second, Lilith thought Faranne was really going to help her out of this situation, but then, she not only remembered that the dare consisted in getting her pussy licked, but also that Faranne was seemingly into incest, because she didn’t waste time to go down on her own little sister. But right as everyone watched Faranne sensually lick Lilith’s thighs, and spread her legs a bit apart, the catgirl felt more anxious than ever, specially when she saw how her own sister was pulling her wet panties down.

“N-no!! S-stop!! I-... I don’t want t-to…” - Lilith cried, mainly embarrassed, but genuinely scared of what could happen next. Everyone saw her as a child, so as soon as she was vocal about her worries, all of her friends took a second to make sure she was okay. They all got scared, because it seemed like they were truly going to gang rape her now, but after looking at her face, they noticed that she was covering it with her hands, but not because she was crying, because she was flushing hard, probably because she knew Faranne was going to get a taste of her pussy anyways.

So after a bit of a concerning moment, everyone knew Lilith was just anxious for her first time, and they could all relate, so Faranne tried to calm her down, by revealing the small pussy lips between the catgirl’s legs, and using her fingers to spread them open, and show how everyone how aroused her little sister was at the moment. Everyone took a moment to admire Lilith’s sex, and even though she couldn’t see what they were doing, she knew that they were all gasping because they saw their most intimate parts, and she even felt a bit insecure, because she remembered she had a bit of hair growing down there. But since everyone was too amused to see the catgirl so wet, they didn’t even focus on the fact that she was a bit hairy, in fact, Faranne didn’t care, as she still proceeded to play with it, and get a taste of her own sister’s sex.

“Yea, it looks just like when you were a child… You have a young girl’s pussy… so cute, pink, and there’s even a bit of hair… It’s adorable… Mmm, and it tastes really sweet…” - Faranne whispered, with a very naughty smile, after she gave Lilith’s wet lips a few licks, just to taste the flavor of her lewd juices, before sharing her opinion with all of her friends. They all laughed, as they found it silly, but it was also insanely hot for each one of them, but Lilith didn’t want to see the horny expressions they all had on their faces, so she thought they were making fun of her.

But since it was clear Lilith was still not comfortable with her older sister licking her pussy, Faranne decided to get her used to it, by placing her small legs on top of her shoulders, pulling her cute ass closer to her face, and while grabbing her hips tightly, she proceeded to eat out her own little sister in front of everyone. Faranne used her tongue to pleasure her catgirl sister like never before, and she was great at it, since she was already getting some moans out of Lilith, even when she tried to cover with her hand. They all just continued watching, and some even felt more hot than ever, but Zoey realized they were not doing anything, and Faranne was getting all the fun with her catgirl sister, so she decided to take some incentive, and allow everyone to participate in this payback for Lilith’s wicked games.

“Katsumi, I dare you to get Lilith completely naked… Sayuri, I dare you to hold Lilith still… we don’t want her moving for what’s next…” - Zoey ordered both of the foxgirls, with an impressively authoratitative tone, which got both of them to do exactly what she asked for immediately. Zoey was trying to take charge here, because Faranne was getting distracted with her sister’s pussy, so while she had fun with the catgirl, there were a few things the rest of them could do for the next step.

Zoey was planning a lot of dares directed to Lilith, since she made all of them do so many naughty stuff, and she thought they shouldn’t be so extreme, but very meaningful. Finn could tell Zoey was planning something big, but he didn’t do, or say anything, and just let his girlfriend do whatever she wanted. He did wait for a dare, or some orders, but they never came, and since the foxgirl’s completed theirs, he thought there wasn’t much more to do, not yet. So after Katsumi stripped Lilith naked, by just taking off her top, and Sayuri grabbed both of the catgirl’s arms, and pinned her to the bed by the wrists, they had the catgirl completely exposed, and without being able to cover her mouth anymore, she was starting to moan more, because Faranne kept licking, kissing, and sucking her own little sister’s pussy. Zoey was also licking some lips, her own, as she had Lilith in the exact position she imagined, and it was the perfect time to move on to another dare.

“Enough of that Faranne... Your dare is done, you can stop licking your sister’s pussy… I have another dare for someone else…” - Zoey ordered Faranne, with a bit of a mischievous laugh, which only made everyone curious for what she had in her mind. Faranne wanted to follow Zoey’s plan, since she believed she could come up with some great, and highly erotic ideas for her little sister, but she also was enjoying eating out Lilith way too much, so she continued licking her cute pussy. But after Faranne had enough fun with her little sister, and almost got her to orgasm, from the intense stimulation she was giving her with her tongue, she was finally ready to follow Zoey’s orders, and see what her next dare could be.

“Aw, I was really enjoying that… I love pleasuring my little sister like that… I think I almost made her cum… Did you like it, Lilith?” - Faranne teasingly asked her little sister, who just lied on the bed, completely naked, panting, already exhausted, but afraid of what’s to come next. She knew Zoey was planning something big, it was obvious, but she didn’t know what it could be, which made it so terrifying. But while Faranne had stopped playing with her little sister’s pussy, Zoey continued thinking of what she was going to do for the next dare, but not hesitating on her idea, just trying to figure out who would be the best person to dare.

“Everyone knows you did, you were moaning like crazy… But it’s time for something else… You’ve been acting very naughty Lilith, you need to pay for all these dirty dares you made us do… And I think the best punishment for you is losing your virginity… Now, I just have to figure out who could take your innocent pussy… Hmm…” - Zoey finally announced, with a straight up malicious voice, as she tried to scare the catgirl more than ever, which she definitely succeeded at. But she also shocked all of her friends, because they were just expecting something mild, not taking away Lilith’s virginity. Although, it did make sense this would be the best way to punish her, because she was never innocent, so she deserves to have that innocence taken away from her, by doing the naughtiest thing possible.

“What?? No!! I’m not ready for that!! I can’t!! - Lilith screamed again, and this time, she really didn’t want to go through with this. She was fine with her older sister licking her pussy, even if it was incest, and very embarrassing, but she was really scared to have sex with a man, just because she thought it would hurt a lot. And her screams definitely showed that fear of hers, and it actually made the foxgirls feel a bit ashamed, and Finn very nervous, because he thought he could be the only one to take Lilith’s virginity.

He was annoyed at the fact that he wasn’t dared to do anything earlier, but now, he was really hoping he wouldn’t be the one that Zoey chose, which seemed like it would be the case, because she quickly turned her attention to him, and started giving her a very suggestive look, and even smiled at him. And while Finn thought there was no other option, and he would have to be the one to take Lilith’s virginity, he knew he would feel terrible if he had to, since it seemed like he would have to force himself on the catgirl, and he didn’t want to rape any of his friends, no matter how cute they are.

But as Finn was already starting to regret a choice he hasn’t made yet, apparently Zoey was only messing with him, because she didn’t want to choose him, she had someone else in mind. And it seemed like Faranne knew that was going to be the case, because she was the one to pick who to dare, since she should be the one to take this decision, she should be the one to choose the man who would take her little sister’s virginity, and it was unfortunately not Finn, so this meant it could only be...

“Itzel, would you do the honors??... I know you like Lilith, but she isn’t as innocent as she appears to be… So do you want to take her virginity??” - Faranne asked the halfling at the back, who was still just sitting on his stool, actually trying to ignore what was going on with Lilith, so he wouldn’t have to be part of her abuse. But after Faranne called his attention, everyone was shocked for a second, but then realized that it made sense, and it was probably the best option, specially because Itzel seemed like the perfect guy, with the perfect size for Lilith, and he deserved to take her virginity. And while Faranne had caught him so off guard, she had to take some time to convince him, which turned a little awkward, but apparently Itzel was more than eager to finally have sex with Lilith. He had dreamt of this moment for years, and he thought he would get to confess his love to her crush for the first time, in the most intimate, and erotic way possible. But while he was already running to the bed, with his small, but hard dick out, Finn was trying to assess the situation, he was just perplexed, and couldn’t understand what was happening, even when he didn’t have a reason to.

“I know you want to have some fun too Finn... but after what you did you are going to have to wait a little longer… Don’t worry, I have a good dare for you, so just be patient… and enjoy watching how my little sister gets deflowered…” - Faranne casually told Finn, with a sensuous, but oddly sincere smile, which calmed him down a little. He didn’t know why, but he still couldn’t believe his friends were going to take Lilith’s virginity, and even when it was predictable, he thought there could have been other ways to do this. He was at least glad that he didn’t have to do it, so he just watched as Itzel was getting in position to penetrate his crush.

Everyone gathered up around the bed, some were paying more attention than others, and some were very anxious for the experience, mainly Itzel, but most definitely Lilith, who didn’t even think she could end up losing her virginity to her halfling friend tonight. She really just wanted to have some fun with her friends, maybe get a bit naughty with the game, and that’s all, just some lighthearted fun. But now that this was really happening, she couldn’t help but get nervous, and she only focused on watching how Itzel stepped right in front of her, and looked very determined to take her virginity.

They all started cheering for Itzel, as he grabbed Lilith’s legs, and with the help of Faranne, he pulled her cute body towards him, so their sexes could brush against each other. He was trying to hide his nervousness behind a confident smile, but since he was about to achieve one of his dreams, he didn’t shy away at such an important moment in his life. Everyone was eager to see his small dick penetrate the catgirl’s equally small pussy, and they all had to get close, because Itzel’s member wasn’t particularly big, and it would be difficult to tell if there's any penetration.

But with both in position, Lilith being unable to do anything, not even talk, move, or make any noise, from being so anxious for this moment, she could only watch as Itzel’s small cock approached her entrance, at a very slow, but promising speed. It seemed like the penetration was imminent, and no one said a thing for a whole minute, it was just complete silence, with a bit of whimpering from the catgirl.

But after a lot of suspense, and arousal from Itzel, he finally got to poke Lilith’s lips with his dick, and soon enough, he pushed himself inside her, penetrating her for the first time, and successfully claiming her virgin pussy. But since his size only made it seem like he was just brushing his dick on Lilith’s sex, instead of the powerful thrusts Itzel thought he was doing, they were all slightly disappointed to see the outcome. It wasn’t so hot, and even Lilith expected more, but she was glad that Itzel wasn’t so big, because he didn’t hurt her, or caused her any pain (she actually couldn’t even feel it very well).

“Is it in?? Ohh, it wasn’t that bad… I thought it was going to be much worse… Thank you Itzel for being gentle with me, you can keep going if you want, I don’t mind… I actually can’t feel much…” - Lilith said in relief, after realizing that Itzel’s entire cock was inside of her, and his three inches were barely noticeable, as he only got to scrape her entrance, and nothing more. They all were confused for a moment, and felt like Lilith was lying, so she wouldn’t have to endure this any longer, but it seemed like she was telling the truth. The catgirl seemed completely fine, unbothered by the fact that Itzel penetrated her, and even happy the result, because she could take his small dick perfectly, and she was expecting him to being fucking her, but that’s what he was already doing, or at least he thought.

Everyone started laughing, after realizing Itzel’s small dick didn’t do anything for Lilith, and she almost couldn’t feel it. They didn’t try to be mean, but the halfling couldn’t help but feel humiliated, and he immediately pulled out, and put his clothes back on, to then hide his embarrassed face, and tried not to cry in front of all of his friends. He never felt so terrible, and he honestly felt like he was chosen on purpose, only to be mocked by everyone for his small penis size. He was already very insecure about it, but now, he really didn’t want to think about sex anymore, and just completely gave up on his chances to get a girlfriend, or just someone to love. But as everyone was so amused at the moment, Faranne was the only one to notice Itzel’s reaction, and she realized how bad it would make him feel, so she tried to cheer him up.

“Oh, that was it??... Oh no, Itzel is way too small for Lilith... I’m sorry, there’s no need to feel bad…At least you got to take Lilith’s virginity, so that’s something... I’m sure one day you’ll find a woman who is going to love you for your small penis… You are adorable, so keep your chin up, okay??” - Faranne said to Itzel, who seeked comfort in her, by going for a hug, which she gladly received, and even continued holding him, so he could feel loved. At that point, the rest of his friends realized he must have taken a huge hit on his self esteem, after such a poor performance, but they tried to comfort him. Sadly, Itzel didn’t feel like participating anymore, so he went back to sit on his tool, and even though he still felt bad for himself, he was happy to see Faranne support him, and tried to stay optimistic, by holding on to that promise she made him.

After Itzel returned to his stool, everyone checked on him, to make sure he was doing fine, and he seemed happy, so they didn’t worry too much. He was smiling at the fact that he was Lilith’s first, and there was no way to change that, so he could feel proud of taking her virginity. But now, that they couldn’t rely on the halfling to fuck Lilith, they needed someone else to fill in the role of Itzel. There was a small, awkward silence, where everyone just didn’t know what to do, and they felt like there wasn’t anything else left for tonight. Even Lilith was hoping for something more to happen, even though she was nervous for it, since her first time with Itzel wasn’t terrible, and quite pleasant actually.

But as things turned uncomfortable, Faranne took advantage of this moment, to lead into what seemed like the inevitable, which both her and Zoey didn’t want to try until the very end, but that seemed to be now, so there wasn’t anything else to do, no other option for this next dare they had in mind. Even though it seemed pretty obvious to everyone, the actual person for this final dare didn’t have a clue, so Faranne tried to hint at the next, and final dare, to slowly reveal what she wanted to do to her little sister, but it didn’t turn out as dramatic as she thought it would be.

“But what are we going to do now?? This game is ruined!! How are we going to find someone big enough for my sister?? There’s no one with that big of a penis, is there??” - Faranne asked out loud, to no one in particular, to force a moment of confusion, and desperation, even when it was clear she was faking it, just to mess with someone in specific. Zoey laughed at Faranne’s acting, but quickly tried to play along, and even though the foxgirls, and even Lilith knew who they were talking about, they were still able to confuse Finn a lot, before Faranne made the not so big, and very predictable revelation.

“Okay, I’m being too obvious… Finn, it is finally your turn… Do you want to play??” - Faranne asked playfully to Finn, who was instantly shocked to hear that he was finally going to be dared to do something in this game, even when he was already thinking about it, and he pretty much figured it out when Itzel couldn’t fuck Lilith properly. Everyone laughed at the way Faranne asked Finn to play with them, but while they were not sure if he would actually do it, he was already building up the courage to say yes.

He thought there wasn’t anything worse than taking Lilith’s virginity, so he wouldn’t feel bad for doing anything with the catgirl, and since he was already playing this game for more than an hour at this point, and it was finally his turn to be dared, he couldn’t turn down such a great opportunity. So with a very predictable surprised revealed, Finn didn’t hesitate any longer, and already had his answer in mind, but before he could completely accept Faranne’s offer, he was very curious to know what his dare was about, and he wasn’t afraid to ask, so he was just about to find out what he had to do with the naked, defenseless, and no longer virgin catgirl on the bed, waiting to finally get some fun with him...