Dean confronts Nicole and Jesse directly

"No, you two were definitely in there together. The fact that you're lying about it makes it worse. Were you two doing something?"

Krystal puts her hand on his shoulder, "I guess you caught us. Dean, we're Swingers. Jesse was just talking to her, to see if she'd be interested. The same thing I was trying to do when I showed you my breast juv now,"

"What? No, you fell, it just came out,"

She cupped her breasts, "Dean, I've had these since I was thirteen. You were around before they started growing... tits don't just," she used air quotes, "Come out,"

He looked back and forth between Krystal and his wife, "Seriously?"

Nicole nodded.

He focused on her, "Do you want to?"

Her face was even redder than before, "I.. think it could be fun,"

Dean rocked back as if he'd been punched.

"I told you we should have just talked to him about it," Jesse shook his head, "I don't feel right about this, we need to tell him,"

"Tell me what?" Dean stood and faced his brother in law.

Jesse grimaced, he had a feeling that he was about to get punched in the face, "Nicole and I were in the bathroom together, and we just finished having sex. I'm sorry man,"

Jesse was correct.

Dean hit him in the mouth with a clenched fist and the taller man staggered back.

"Fuck... I deserve that,"

The girls scrambled to put themselves between the men, but neither man moved after the punch.

"Apology accepted," he shook out his hand, and switched his gazing to Nicole, "I'd have let you, if you'd asked, but maybe that's not realistic. I've wanted to fuck Krystal for years, hell, there's been a few women I've wanted. I never found a way to ask, why should you?"

Dean asked himself if he could get past this. He concluded that he could, but only if he thought she answered his next question honestly.