Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 15
by AltUAuthor
What's next?
Day 3
"Truth or Dare? Sounds like a good time -- let's do it!" Barbara said eagerly as she and her friends -- and fiancee -- sat back drinking on one of the beach house's large balconies, one of which was attached to the master bedroom. The girls had made a nightly thing of drinking on that particular balcony, as they'd all agreed it had the best view of the ocean.
"Count me in," MJ grinned. "I don't think Babs and I have played since college. We've got some pretty great memories of those games..."
"Oh? Such as?" Gwen asked her and her girlfriend's curiosity piqued.
"It was the first time we played together," MJ reminisced. "Babs and I had known each other for something like a week, and we'd all been hanging out in a group. So it's our friend Liz's turn, and she dares me to kiss Babs. It was... kind of our first kiss."
"Awwww, look, they're blushing," teased Kitty, "You two are too cute together."
"It was pretty great," Barbara said, smiling widely even as she blushed. "I knew I felt something when she kissed me. It took us a while to realize we should be together, but I knew I felt something."
"Ditto," echoed MJ. "We got really into it, too. Our friends wouldn't shut up for weeks about how into each other we looked and how we should date. 'Pretty sure I'm not a lesbian,' I said -- turns out they were right."
"That's really sweet," Kori smiled. "I do love hearing such stories."
"So we're all in agreement? Truth or Dare?" Kitty asked, met with nods and yeses from everyone else.
"Great! OK, first rule -- everybody strip," Kitty ordered.
"Already?" MJ asked.
"Think about it -- what was your first dare going to be? Was it daring one of us to get naked?"
"When you put it like that, it seems so obvious," MJ admitted.
"Exactly. That was going to be everyone's first dare, I'm sure. This way we can get straight to the good stuff faster -- besides, we're not exactly wearing much anyway."
The other girls in full agreement, all shed the bikinis they'd been wearing, settling down on the patio furniture in the nude.
The first turn was Gwen's. "Truth or dare, MJ?"
"Truth," chose MJ.
"...how did it make you feel watching me have sex with Babs in Murderland?"
"...pretty damned hot, actually," MJ grinned coyly as Kitty and Kori wholeheartedly agreed. "Honestly, it didn't bug me as much as you might think. I still felt like I was a part of it, and you two had to do it to save those girls from Tetch."
"Ok, follow-up question. How would you feel if one of us had sex with Babs right now?"
"I think it'd be awesome. I mean, we're headed full steam into friends with benefits territory anyway, aren't we?"
"Hmmm. Good to know," Gwen smirked.
"Y'know, since then I've kinda wanted to watch one of you hook up with MJ," Barbara admitted. "Any volunteers?"
Kitty, Kori & Gwen's hands all shot up into the air.
"Ooooh! Pick me, Babs!" Kori hollered.
"No, pick me! You know how good I am! You know I'd take good care of MJ!" Gwen chuckled.
"Come on, Gwen -- you had your fun. Give someone else a turn!" Kitty teased.
"Ha! We'll have to come back to that," Barbara laughed. "Sounds like all the ladies love you, babe. You must be pretty flattered."
"That's an understatement," MJ said, beaming.
"All right, my turn. Babs, you're up," said Kitty.
"Truth."
"...could you see yourself in a polygamous marriage, or are you only interested in MJ as your wife? MJ, feel free to answer this one, too."
"Huh. I guess I'd be open to it if the right woman came along," Barbara admitted. "Of course, she'd have to love MJ as much as she loves me. I wouldn't marry anyone if it meant MJ wasn't an equal."
MJ echoed Barbara's sentiments. "Yeah, I'd be happy to do it if we all fit together, as you guys do. Babs and I have actually have had kind of a thing with another woman, but our relationship with her is... complicated. You girls though? You make it look easy."
"Yeah, you three are kind of our gold standard for polyamory," added Barbara.
"Uh, wow. I didn't know you saw our relationship that way. That means a lot, especially coming from you two," Kitty gushed. "Your turn, Babs."
"Alright. Kori, what'll it be?"
"Dare," Kori said boldly.
"Ooooh, you sound eager. I like it," Barbara enthused. "Ok, I want you to pour that wine over MJ's tits and see how long it takes to lick her clean -- If you can do it in less than two minutes, you get to sleep in our bed tonight. Pending approval from your girlfriends, of course."
"It's OK with me," said Gwen. "Kitty & I can have plenty of fun on our own."
"Yeah, we'll be fine. Besides, the idea of you girls in a threesome is just too hot," Kitty added. "I feel like denying the world of that would be an insult to sex."
Kori eagerly jumped at the opportunity, pouring the wine over MJ's breasts and diving in. However, as soon as her tongue touched MJ's skin, she was overcome with an overwhelming urge, and rather than licking the wine off of MJ's breasts, she immediately kissed and licked her way to MJ's sex, her tongue plunging between MJ's now wine-soaked folds and lashing enthusiastically. MJ moaned loudly as her mind was overwhelmed with sheer pleasure and it wasn't long before she climaxed. Kori withdrew from between MJ's legs and smiled at the panting redhead. As they looked into one another's eyes, both women couldn't help but feel an overwhelming, intense connection, something neither woman fully understood, nor could they explain. As MJ lay there, chest heaving as she breathed heavily, Kitty, Barbara, and Gwen sat there, gawking at the sight they just saw, pussies throbbing with arousal.
"Wow, Kori. That was... wow," MJ panted as she regained her breath.
"It really was, but you went over the time limit," Barbara said, disappointed she wouldn't get the opportunity to experience a tongue lashing that good that night. "Now I wish I'd given you like, an hour or something."
"Well, Gwen, Kitty, looks like I'm yours tonight," Kori smirked as she went and kissed her girlfriends before taking her seat. As much as she would have loved to have spent the night with MJ & Barbara, she found herself delighted to have pleased MJ so thoroughly. Besides, she'd be spending the night in bed with Gwen & Kitty. It was a win-win for Princess Koriand'r.
"As for you, MJ, We still need to get you clean," Barbara pointed out before licking the rest of the wine off of MJ's magnificent body. "And Kori, you'll have to do that to me sometime."
"I look forward to it," agreed Kori.
"All right -- MJ, your turn," said Kitty.
"Can I dare Kori to do that to me again?" MJ asked.
"Sadly, no," Kitty told her. "As much as I loved watching it, no repeating the dares."
"Awwww, darn," MJ pouted. "Fine then, Kitty, pick your poison."
"Hmmm... dare," chose Kitty.
"All right, let me think... oh, I've got it!"
MJ dashed out of the room momentarily. When she came back, she was holding a pair of small black panties and smiling mischievously. "I dare you to wear these for the rest of the game," she said coyly. Barbara immediately recognized the panties MJ was holding up and burst into laughter.
"What? What's so funny about a pair of panties?" Kitty wondered.
"They're vibrating panties!" MJ gleefully explained as she showed off the remote. Gwen & Kori cracked up as well and Kitty's face turned bright red.
"...well played, MJ..." Kitty mumbled.
"That is brilliant! You have got to let me have the remote!" requested Gwen, unable to contain her laughter.
"Oh, everyone gets a turn," MJ grinned. "Seems only fair, right?"
Kitty sighed, slipping the panties on. The moment she did, MJ hit the button on the remote control, and Kitty let out an aroused squeal much to the amusement of the rest of the girls. "I'll get you for this, MJ," Kitty said playfully. "All right, Kori, you're up."
"All right... Barbara, I dare you to show us the last adult video on your phone browser. And no trying to hide anything -- we'll all be watching..."
Barbara blushed a little at the dare and got up to get her phone. She unlocked it and handed it to Kori, who pulled up her browser history. When she and the rest of the women saw the video, their jaws dropped.
It was a five-way lesbian orgy in which the women eventually formed a daisy chain, enthusiastically eating one another out. That wasn't unusual -- all five women watched their fair share of lesbian porn -- but each woman bore at least a passing resemblance to each of the five women watching it.
"Wow, Babs. Do you notice anything... familiar about the girls in this video?" Gwen observed. "The redheads? The blonde? The brunette. How about that girl -- aside from the green hair, she looks a lot like Kori..."
"That *is* an exotic-looking woman," Kitty noted. "Really hot, too. Maybe she's a mutant?"
Kori's eyes widened as she focused on the gorgeous green-haired woman more deeply. "She's Tamaranean!"
"Seriously?!" Kitty asked, she and the rest of the girls were just as surprised as Kori. "There's another Tamaranean on Earth, and she's a porn star?!"
"Yes! That woman is Tamaranean, I'm sure of it!"
"Wow. How do you think she got here?" MJ asked.
"I stumbled upon Earth after fleeing Okaara. Maybe she ended up here through similar means?" Kori wondered. "Perhaps she was exiled by my sister... there are a few possibilities."
"Maybe aliens are just drawn here," Gwen theorized. "I've met several Kryptonians, for example, and that planet was destroyed."
"Whatever the case, we have *got* to track her down at some point..." Kitty suggested. "And now I am wondering how many languages she knows...as, given her profession, she could learn a new tongue every time she fucks a woman that knows a language she didn't know about. Would be a very hot way to learn quickly, that's for sure!"
"So, redheads, a brunette, a blonde, a Tamaranean..." Gwen said, reiterating what she had initially noticed about the video "And Babs bookmarked it, too."
"Are you saying it means something?" Barbara asked. An awkward silence followed the question -- Barbara may have been the one to find the video, but all five women were very turned on watching these women who resembled them locked in a daisy chain. Not only that but seeing it elicited an overwhelming feeling in all five women that they couldn't quite describe...
An awkward silence followed the question as the five women tried to process what they were feeling. After all, this was just a friends with benefits thing. Wasn't it?
The silence was broken by a low buzzing sound, quickly followed by Kitty gasping as she felt a humming sensation against her clit.
"EEEEP!"
The other four women burst into a fit of laughter, and Gwen held up the remote control, revealing herself as the culprit.
"What the fuck, Gwen!" Kitty yelled in exasperation.
"...Uh um, OK. Babs, you pick now."
"Hmmmmm... OK, I've got it. Gwen, MJ, get into a 69 position. But don't even think about kissing or licking each other! The first one that does loses, and sleeps alone on the couch tonight."
"The loser sleeps alone? YOU MONSTER!" Gwen teased as she crawled into position, her head between MJ's legs, the redhead's head between hers.
"What does the winner get?" MJ asked.
"The winner gets to have sex tonight," decreed Barbara.
Gwen sighed. "...I feel who ever wins this is gonna become a Nova Lantern..."
"Probably. I don't think I could last long. Aaaaaand... GO!"
As the minutes passed in what seemed like an eternity for MJ & Gwen, the other girls watched, enthralled by the display. Meanwhile, MJ & Gwen stared directly at each other's inviting folds, growing wetter by the moment, and fought their urge to lick or kiss the inviting cunt in front of them. Eventually, the urge became too overwhelming, and both women dove in at the same time, tongues lashing in a frenzy as they brought one another to a quick but intense orgasm.
"Wow. you two cracked at the exact same moment. It's almost as if your minds were linked," observed Kitty. "You sure you're not a telepath, MJ?"
"If I was, I'd have used my powers to make Gwen dive in right away," MJ answered.
"Hmmmmm. fair point," Kitty admitted. "But that would've been cheating."
"I guess," MJ admitted, "But I'd have still done it -- not so much because I care about winning -- I'd just want Gwen eating my pussy."
"I can't argue with that," Kitty nodded. "So, Babs, what's your decision?"
"Hmmmm... I didn't expect a draw. I'd say they both sleep on the couch, but then I'm punishing myself, because I sleep alone and they don't... I guess you both win, girls. Congrats."
"Kind of anticlimactic, don't you think?" Kitty asked.
"Maybe. But we got to see a really hot 69, albeit a short one, and everybody gets laid tonight. Win-win, right?" said Barbara.
"And MJ had her second orgasm of the night," Kori pointed out. "I feel like she's the real winner here."
The women continued the game for a few more rounds after that, the dares bringing them closer sexually as the truths brought them closer emotionally. There was no question about the sexual attraction the five women shared, but they all wondered -- could it go beyond that? There was no jealousy or bitter feelings seeing their girlfriend perform a sexual act with a woman in the other relationship. In fact, it actually kind of felt right. But nobody knew quite how bring it up. A five-way long-term relationship still seemed rather far-fetched. And yet, they all wanted it more and more...
The final turn of the night belonged to Kori. "Kitty, I want you to eat out Barbara. Barbara, if you can last five minutes, you can pick one of me, Gwen, or Kitty to join you and MJ tonight. Kitty, if you make Barbara cum, Gwen and I will spend the night concentrating on pleasuring you."
"I'm game for that," agreed Gwen.
"Go Babs! You got this!" MJ cheered.
Kitty crawled between Barbara's legs and got to work. A minute passed. Barbara had let out some soft moans and was obviously enjoying Kitty's tongue movement, but nothing yet. The another minute passed. And another. And another. By this point, Barbara's moans were louder and her muscles had tensed up. Twenty seconds left. Kitty knew she was close to the finish line. All she needed to do was keep concentrating. Ten seconds. She was so close now. And then...
*Buzzzzzzz.*
Kitty felt the vibration against her clit and her tongue movement slowed down just enough...
"...Aaaaaand time," Kori said. Immediately after hearing that time was up, Barbara let out a loud howl of pleasure and her pussy started gushing.
"YES!" MJ hollered, pumping her fists in the air. "That's my girl!"
"Nooooo! I was so close..." Kitty lamented as she stood up. "Who had the remote?!"
MJ held the remote up, a smug grin on her face. "I didn't break any rules, Kitty."
"...still a dirty trick..." Kitty muttered. "...Just wait until next tiiiihiiiihime -- damn it MJ, put that thing down!"
MJ had doubled over, laughing hysterically. "I'm so glad I packed these things..."
"Alright, Barbara, you win... with an assist from MJ," Kori announced. "So, who's it going to be?"
Barbara looked the the polyamorous trio, each woman with a hopeful look on their face. "I'm not sure I can choose. Any suggestions, MJ?"
MJ kissed her fiancee on the cheek and fixed her gaze in Kitty's direction. "Well, I do feel kinda bad about messing with Kitty. So I'd kinda like to make it up to her. So how about it, Kitty? Wanna spend the night with us? By the way, you can take those things off now."
Kitty slid the panties off and walked over to MJ, smiling. "Awwww, I can't stay mad at you," she cooed before pulling MJ in for a hug. Both women savored the closeness of each other's naked bodies, seemingly trying to ensure as much body contact as possible. "Is that OK with you two?" Kitty asked her girlfriends.
"Of course it is, but I would like to hear about it tomorrow," Kori smiled, excited for her lover.
"Me too. And don't worry, I have Kori with me," Gwen grinned, kissing Kori playfully. "We can have a ton of fun on our own."
Afterwards, the girls said good night to one another and headed to the bedrooms. Barbara and MJ each took one of Kitty's hands, leading her to their room down the hall, while Kori practically threw Gwen on to the bed in the master bedroom and crawled on top of her.
The group might not have had the words to describe it yet, but they all felt their bond become that much more intimate that night. And as they parted ways for the night, a small part of their minds all wondered the same thing -- how close were they going to be by the end of the vacation?
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
What Ifs and Elseworlds -- A Lesbian Multiverse
Tales From a Lesbian Multiverse
Stories of parallel universes, where the world's greatest superheroines and villainesses love (and lust after) other women.
- Tags
- 69, Lesbian, Zatanna Zatara, Wanda Maximoff, Fanfic, Fan Fiction, Lara Croft, Princess Peach, Princess Toadstool, Shadow Queen Peach, Princess Daisy, Bowsette, latex fetish, fetish, Wapeach, lesbian threesome, voyeur, strapon, toy sex, bondage, Storm, Wonder Woman, Ororo Munroe, Diana Prince, Crossover, Fan Fictions, Latex, Starfire, Koriandr, Mary Jane Watson, Wonder Girl, Cassie Sandsmark, Blackfire, Komandr, Miss Martian, Mgann Morzz, Black Cat, Felicia Hardy, altered reality, Black Widow, Natasha Romanoff, Tomb Raider, fanfiction, Princess Jeannie Toadstool, Jean Grey, Phoenix, Hawkwoman, Hawkgirl, Shayera Thal, Rogue, Power Girl, FF, Princess Diasy, Bisexual, girl on girl, Aerith Gainsborough, Jessie Rasberry, Tifa Lockhart, Spider-Gwen, Gwen Stacy, lesbian sex, lesbian foursome, foursome, bdsm, domme, sub, strip poker, Marvel, DC, mind control, lesbian seduction, Redheads, Mind porn, Princess Daisy 1993, redhead, Madam M, Shower, dommesub, Zarda, Power Princess, Mario Brothers, femalefemale, Reality change, shibari, Diana of Themyscira, Lesbain, Super Mario, Final Fantasy VII, FFF, Corruption, masturbation, super hero, avengers, red heads, alternate universe, AU, Comic book, Maxima, lesbian orgy, lesbian group, Mgann Morzz, Spanking, Femdom, Lezdom, romance, Wendy O Koopa, Kara Zor-El, Supergirl, gwenpool, comics, Sixty-nine, Selina Kyle, Catwoman, Laura Kinney, X-23
Updated on Jun 16, 2025
by AltUAuthor
Created on Oct 28, 2021
by AltUAuthor
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments