Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 32 by PhoenixAuthor PhoenixAuthor

What's next?

Dancing the Night Away, Part 2

Shoutout to chingchangchong for helping with this one!

Jayden Robinson was out of his element. Being at a party such as this wasn't much his forte anyway, but having such a sexy girl dancing with him, it was new, unfamiliar territory to say the least. His sister, Brooklyn, was smiling at him as they danced, which did make it easier to ignore the rest of the crowd, though it did make him a little more nervous. Everything about Brooklyn was sweetness incarnate, and her smile could brighten even the worst of Jayden’s days.

The Robinson siblings weren't touching as they danced, both facing each other standing about a 2 feet away, which wasn't Jayden’s preferred way of dancing with his sexy sister, but he would take whatever he could get.

Jayden did, however, feel awkward while dancing, sort of shuffling his feet and trying to move his arms in a way he hoped looked alright, and with Brooklyn smiling and laughing with him, he did his best to keep her distracted from Jace. He hoped that if he distracted her enough, she might loosen up even further on him. But that was likely wishful thinking, wasn't it? The delusions of a twisted teen who was ridiculously into his sister.

His sister was pretty clearly down in the dumps about Jace, and how he had just left her to dance with Valerie Barnes. It was a pretty stupid decision, especially when Jace had such a beautiful girl like Brooklyn fawning all over him, but Jayden wasn't going to complain, especially as it afforded him the opportunity to spend some time with his sexy sister. As they continued to dance, Brooklyn swayed her hips in a rhythm that matched the music, while moving her arms in a way that showcased her coordination as a cheerleader. Her smile was wide as she looked at her brother, thinking how she was glad he suggested a dance, as it was actually improving her mood.

But then an unexpected interruption came, in the form of someone’s hands grabbing her hips from behind, and something sizable and hard poking against her large butt, causing her to freeze her body’s motions.

“Why, hello there.” came a familiar voice, and Nolan Platt tightened his grip on her wide hips, lowering his head to whisper in her ear.

“Now why would a pretty girl like you be dancing all on her own? Surely you'd like some company.” he said, punctuating his sentence with an aggressive thrust of his hips, pushing his boner even more prominently into Brooklyn’s soft ass.

Jolting from the unexpected and unwelcome feeling, Brooklyn used her hands to shove his hands off of her thick hips, and she stepped forward to get away from his boner, but in her haste she bumped right into Jayden. Her very large breasts smushed against his chest, and he instinctively wrapped his arms around Brooklyn’s waist in a protective manner, while he glared daggers at Nolan.

“Did you really just try and do that? Fuck you!” Jayden snarled. Nolan chuckled, raising an eyebrow at the usually quiet junior. Jayden’s unusual confidence came from a place deep within him, his desire for Brooklyn transformed into a desire to protect her, especially from pervs like Nolan.

"Oh? And who says you get to decide for her? This is a party, squirt, look around us, everybody is dancing together, I was just filling the void for her." Nolan stated as if it was the most obvious and natural thing in the world, spreading his arms out to emphasize his point. He staggered a little, and Jayden realized he was drunk. Jayden very briefly hesitated, but then he tightened his arms around Brooklyn’s waist.

"If she wants to dance with you, she can. But she doesn't, so go away.” Jayden snapped, and to his surprise, his voice carried what he hoped was confidence and assertiveness, and a staring match ensured between the two boys, neither of them wanting to back down.

Nolan was too turned on from his time with Amy and too far gone thanks to the **** to simply give up a hottie like Brooklyn, and Jayden finally had Brooklyn clinging to him in his arms, so he also wasn't going to give up this moment too easily.

The staring contest ended when Brooklyn finally shook herself free from her shock, and stared up at Jayden with adoring eyes for her baby brother. Turning her head so that she could look at Nolan, she glared and promptly told him to piss off, something that Jayden was shocked to hear come from his usually sweet sister’s mouth.

Nolan looked angry for a brief moment, but that expression was rapidly covered by a drunken smile.

“If that's how you feel about things then fine, enjoy dancing alone again. Come find me when you realize being alone on the dance floor sucks." Nolan sighed, before turning around and walking off to find his next potential dance partner.

Jayden relaxed and let out a deep breath that he didn't realise he had been holding in. Feeling his sexy older sister pressed up against him was one of the best feelings ever, and it reminded him of when she was topless from losing her bikini top and clinging to him. Unfortunately (or fortunately depending on how you looked at it), the close body contact had caused Jayden to pop a pretty prominent boner, which was now sandwiched tightly between their two bodies, poking Brooklyn in her toned stomach.

"Um, Jay-Jay? I think you can let go now" Brooklyn laughted softly, as she smiled up at him.

"Oh, um, yeah, I guess so." Jayden replied, but he didn't loosen his arms at all. After a brief and slightly awkward pause, he forged ahead.

"You know, Nolan was right about something. It does suck to dance alone. W... Would you be okay if we danced together, at least for a little bit?" Jayden asked hopefully, his heart pounding in his chest. Brooklyn looked up at him, her expression unreadable. One second passed. Two seconds. Then five. After what felt like an eternity, she smiled.

"Of course, baby brother, I think you deserve a thank you after sticking up for me like that earlier." she said, as she started to sway her body to the beat again, "Although you're going to have to loosen your grip around me if I'm going to be able to dance at all" she giggled, and Jayden relaxed his arms around her, until his hands rested just above the swell of her delicious ass.

Even after he had loosened his arms around her, any movement either of them made caused her impressive rack to brush against his chest, and his boner to almost grind against her stomach and waist, which in turn caused both teens arousal to build.

Brooklyn could only endure so much from her sensitive nipples getting stimulated over and over again, and Jayden felt like he was in heaven, having his hard dick gently brushed back and forth by his sexy sister’s body, and having her tits mashed against his chest.

Oh, he so desperately wanted to lower his hands and grab two big handfuls of her luscious ass, but he know that if he did that, he would break the spell that the two of them had fallen under. When this song ended, a faster, more up-beat one came on, and the crowd went a little wild with activity, causing them to shift and heave as if they were a single living being.

The two siblings stumbled a little, and as Brooklyn tried to turn to see what the cause of some shouting was, another couple crashed into them, pinning her back against her brother, who's hands had never left her, and were now tightly holding her hips in a similar way to how Nolan had held onto her earlier, except this time, Brooklyn was already turned on from having her body rubbed against Jayden.

And most importantly, she once again felt something long and hard pressing against her right ass cheek. "J-Jayden... Is that?" she whispered, but her brother didn't hear her, his senses had shut down the moment her ass came in contact with his hard cock. If nothing else had happened, he surely would have released her and the moment would have ended. But Lady Luck was on his side that night, for a random guy next to him shouted an encouraging 'whoop', and made a dancing/grinding motion by thrusting his hips and holding an imaginary pair of hips in front of him before nodding towards Brooklyn, encouraging Jayden to copy him. Lost in his lust-filled stupor, Jayden rocked his hips forward, electing a moan out of Brooklyn at the feeling of his cock slipping into the crack between her two cheeks.

Jayden continued to rock back and forth in small subtle motions, his hands exploring his sisters sexy wide hips, as her panting became more obvious. Brooklyn for her part was waging an internal conflict, knowing the wrongness of the situation, but also enjoying the throes of attention and arousal that her body was feeling. After a particularly hard thrust, her body subconsciously pushed back against him, drawing a quiet 'fuck' from his lips that went right against her ear.

Smiling at being able to elect such a response, even from her own brother, Brooklyn's rational mind lost her internal conflict, and she placed her hands on Jayden’s at her hips, and started to dance back against him.

This forbidden dance continued for a few minutes, the siblings lost to the throws of lust, Jayden for his part savoring the feeling of his sister's sexy body pushing back against him, and his mind jumping with joy at Brooklyn seemingly wanting him, just like in his dreams!

Alas, each dream has its’ ending, and this ending was suddenly upon him, for as quickly as this sequence had started it stopped, when the music cut out abruptly. The loss of the music turned the party into an awkward chorus of drunk teens singing along and shuffling and grinding. However, the sudden quiet also brought clarity to Brooklyns mind, and she suddenly realized the position she was in.

Brooklyn gasped, realizing the way she was taking advantage of her brother. She was upset about Jace, she was downright furious at Nolan, and then Jayden… she’d lost herself in his arms. She’d been grinding on him! Her brother!

Embarrassment flushed Brooklyn’s cheeks, and she backed away from Jayden, shaking her head.

“Brook-” Jayden tried, but his sister shook his head.

“I’m sorry!” Brooklyn exclaimed, and the music came back to life, leaving Jayden alone on the dance floor as Brooklyn fled.

———

Jace was lost in the music, his hands on Val’s hips, his fingers right on the curve of her ass, holding the younger girl close, her enchanting blue eyes staring up at him hungrily. It wasn’t the first time he’d seen the trademark Barnes blue eyes looking at him like that, and he knew Val had been waiting for him to hold her in his arms like this for a long time.

Val’s lips weren’t far from Jace’s at all, and they seemed almost magnetized to him, he realized, and he decided that he was going to kiss Val, then, tonight, here, but fate intervened in the form of a small petite blonde arriving, and practically elbowing Val out of the way.

“Hey!” Valerie exclaimed, her blue eyes flashing.

“Sorry!” Dana exclaimed, and she grabbed Jace.

“Later.” Jace promised Val, and he saw eagerness fill her eyes yet again. Jace looked down at Dana, who had him by the forearms. Jace shuffled through the dance with her, distinctly aware of his straining erection that Val had caused, but Dana seemed oblivious.

In fact, his twin seemed very distracted.

“You OK, Dana?” Jace asked, and he put his hand on her side, grabbing her hand with his other hand, so they wound up in some kind of informal ballroom dance.

“Er… yes. Ruby and I, we were dancing, and, well, never mind. I just saw you and wanted to come dance with you.” Dana stumbled her way through an explanation.

“Right.” Jace said disbelievingly, “You elbowed Val out of the way just because you wanted to come dance with me.”

“I’m very demanding of your time.” Dana pouted her lips, and Jace was struck by how sexy Dana was these days. Fuck, him and Daisy sleeping together on Monday had screwed his mind up. Wait, had it only been since Monday? It felt like an eternity had passed since then.

“I suppose so.” Jace chuckled, “So, how long do you intend to demand my time?”

“I’m not sure. A few minutes, tops.” Dana said, but she still seemed distracted.

“Well, Danie, just know if you ever need anything, you can come straight to me.” Jace said.

“Danie?” Dana laughed, and Jace had to fight back a groan when his twin sister’s small but stacked body pressed up against him, “You haven’t called me that in years.”

Jace’s arms slid around Dana’s waist, and she looked at him with loving blue-green eyes.

“It just kind of slipped out.” Jace shrugged, entirely truthful.

“Well, I like it.” Dana smiled, and fuck if she wasn’t pretty when she smiled. Jace wondered again how she didn’t have boys killing each other for her. Or maybe they were intimidated by Jace, who really wasn’t a small guy. He wasn’t particularly scary, but he was on the football team, and maybe people were hesitant to cross him because of it? That was the only reason Jace could imagine for why Dana wasn’t one of the most sought after girls in school.

“Glad to hear it.” Jace chuckled, and he spun her around, making her laugh. Once he stopped spinning her, Dana looked up at her twin brother with a big smile on her face.

“Thank you. For being such an amazing big brother.” Dana said, and then without hardly thinking, she leaned up on her toes and kissed her brother.

Jace froze, completely stunned by this action.

“Dana.” Jace groaned when she drew back.

“I’m sorry, I shouldn’t-” Dana shook her head, but was cut off by Jace kissing her back.

“Thank you for always trusting me.” Jace chuckled. Dana giggled, and she put a hand on the back of his head.

“I’m sure there’s something else you need to be thanked for.” Dana murmured, and then she pulled him down for a third kiss.

Both Holland twins were very fortunate it was dark, and therefore hard to see that they were kissing in the dark, thanking each other several times for being such excellent siblings towards one another.

———

Amy Blackson hurtled into the bathroom quickly, panting hard, her nipples harder, and she felt a warmth between her thighs.

Her breathing was erratic, and she felt desperately like she needed release. Amy didn’t do this often, she hated feeling so dirty as she did it, but tonight, she couldn’t not do it.

Amy’s fingers were frantic as they found the buttons of her jean shorts and tugged them down a bit so they were around her thighs rather than her hips.

She shoved her red hair out of her face and slumped back, her plump ass pressing onto the edge of the sink as she pulled down her panties and slid her fingers inside herself.

Amy’s breath hitched at the feeling, and she leaned her head back, a soft moan escaping her lips. She was being so bad right now. Masturbating in the bathroom during a party. She hated how naughty she was, but she just couldn’t fight this off.

Amy’s fingers worked frantically inside her pussy, and Amy’s other hand seemed magnetized to her sensitive breasts, and she relished in freeing them from captivity, so she didn’t have her nipples dragging against fabric anymore. Amy gasped at the cool air on her nipples, and her eyes closed in pleasure as her one hand kept masturbating, while the other came up to cup and squeeze her breasts.

Thoughts of Evan filled her head, of him dancing with her, holding her… and thoughts of the thing that wasn’t a phone poking into her. She couldn’t make herself think it, really. But his thing that wasn’t a phone had been really big, Amy hated that she had noticed. She should have been grossed out, not turned on.

Right?

———

Aiden Blackson saw his sister practically sprinting through the party towards the bathroom, and thought worriedly that she was going to throw up. She was never too great at holding her ****, and Aiden was worried about her health. He stopped only to grab a cup of water for her, then hustled after her to the bathroom.

Aiden found the bathroom door ajar, and figured he was right, she was throwing up. She definitely wouldn’t leave the door open if she was using the bathro- Aiden’s thoughts died abruptly as he reached the slightly ajar bathroom door and was able to see through it.

Amy was leaned back against the sink, one hand inside her pussy, one hand pawing at her breasts. Amy’s fantastic, glorious pale tits were popped out of her top, and she was mailing them with her left hand. Her panties and shorts were around her thighs, and she was knuckle deep inside her pussy, her index and middle fingers submerged inside herself. Holy shit.

This was… this was a vision from heaven. Amy’s cheeks were flushed, face tilted up skywards, eyes squeezed closed. Her breathing was coming hard, and she was oblivious to Aiden’s presence.

His heart was thumping in his chest at supersonic speed, and he didn’t think his dick had ever been this hard in his life. Aiden set down the cup of water as quietly as possible, and he unzipped his shorts, and pulled out his rock hard cock.

Aiden started stroking himself watching Amy masturbate, and he quickly lost himself in the stroking and the ogling that he totally forgot what else was going on at the party. He forgot he was AT a party.

All he was focused on was Amy. And holy shit was she sexy.

Aiden had a brief impulsive thought to fill the water cup he’d brought for Amy with his cum, but the little reason he had left shut that down quickly. His sister could be a little gullible sometimes, but she wouldn’t miss cum in a cup of water.

Aiden jerked his cock faster, watching Amy finger herself, and at some point, Aiden foolishly walked into the bathroom. He mechanically closed the door behind him, but the soft sound of that didn’t rouse Amy from her lust induced euphoria.

Aiden didn’t stop jerking either, he was jerking harder from Amy’s nearer proximity, in fact. Aiden slowly drew closer to Amy, unable to help himself. His want for her grew with each step, and he was just a few feet from her when he stopped.

What was he doing? He would be caught. His life would be ruined. His relationship with Amy would be ruined.

But she was so fucking enticing. He wanted her with every damn perverted fiber in his damn perverted being.

Her fat, pale tits, those big, hard nipples. Her soft curves, her wide hips, her plump ass, every fucking inch of her flawless pale skin was like a **** to Aiden. He loved her red hair, her green eyes… everything about her. He wanted her so bad.

So fucking bad. And here she was. He could slide inside her pussy, here and now. He could fuck Amy. He could be inside his big sister and fuck her until she was moaning his name.

Somebody braver than Aiden might. Owen, had he found Olivia in this situation, wouldn’t have hesitated.

But, hesitation screwed Aiden over in the end, because just then, Amy’s eyes flew open.

Her eyes then widened when she saw him, and she got through the first half of his name before her eyes flicked down and she saw his cock.

Aiden opened his mouth to apologize, but Amy’s exclamation of his name transformed into a moan, and he realized why her eyes had flown open… she was orgasming.

Aiden had to stand there, looking at Amy as she orgasmed while moaning his name.

Holy shit.

Aiden hastily shoved his dick back into his shorts, massively unsatisfied, but it wasn’t like he could paint Amy with his seed. Now that Amy knew he was there, all the feeling of victory and triumph and hope and possibility and stupid fucking fantasy was gone.

He realized now that he had fucked up.

Amy finished orgasming, and there was silence in the bathroom, neither Blackson saying a word.

“Amy…” Aiden whispered, but thankfully he didn’t have to come up with a reason for him to be there in this bathroom because before he could say anything else, Amy opened her mouth.

“Get out!” Amy half-sobbed half-screamed, mortified tears running down her cheeks, her face bright, bright red.

Aiden fled, feeling like a total fucking idiot.

Amy looked at the cup of water sitting on the floor and realized he’d been trying to bring her water. He probably thought she was throwing up… it wouldn’t be the first time a night of drinking ended like that for her.

Her heart broke, devastated that Aiden had to see her doing something so fucking depraved. Hot, ashamed tears came out of her eyes, and she couldn’t even bask in the good feeling that came from her masturbating.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)